Jeff Noonan

Dussel’s complex work calls into question the standard history of philosophy, reveals a counter-history at work beneath the official history that gives voice to the victims of capitalism and colonialism, and systematically develops a novel ‘material ethics’ grounded in an unqualified, universal affirmation of life as the foundation of liberatory values. The Ethics of Liberation brings together the major problems explored in Dussel’s prolific body of earlier work: the relationship between Western philosophy and the expansion of European society; the relationship between centre and periphery in global political economy, considered as both a philosophical and an ethical problem; the ethical interpretation of Marxism; the politics of liberation in the colonial context; the defence of universal foundations of ethical norms; and the distinction between formal and critical ethics.

Marx is famous for apparently dismissing the practical role of philosophy. Yet, as accumulating empirical knowledge of growing life-crises proves, the simply availability of facts is insufficient to motivate struggles for fundamental change. So too manifest social crisis. The economic crisis which began in 2008 has indeed motivated social struggles, but nothing on the order of the revolutionary struggles Marx expected. Rather than make Marx irrelevant, however, the absence of global struggles for truly radical change make his early engagement with the role of philosophy more important than ever. This engagement suggests a conception of philosophy as a uniquely practical discipline distinguished from empirical science by its unique capacity to synthesise values from the facts of life. The article examines the development of this conception of philosophy in Marx’s early work and concludes with the outlines for a new critical philosophy capable of generating a new set of universal values necessary to motivate anti-capitalist struggles today.

The paper argues that the future of socialism depends upon the category of use value being grounded in a wider and deeper conception of life value. Only as such can it serve as the regulating principle of a future democratic socialist society. Life value is anchored in an understanding of the human life's space-time continuum understood as a continuum of life requirements. The multiple life crises regularly generated by capitalism are crises of its incapacity to adequately satisfy these life requirements. The practical conclusion is that a democratic socialist economy must prioritize the production not of use values as such, but only of those use values that also have life value.

To the extent that classical, neoclassical, and Marxist political economy have traditionally ignored the problem of economic scale and valorized economic growth, all three have much to learn from ecological economics. Its most important contribution is the argument that the human economy is a subsystem of the finite earth’s natural life-support system. Implied in this argument is a new metric of economic health, the life-value rather than the money-value of that which economies produce and distribute.

Since its publication in 1971, John Rawls’ A Theory of Justice has defined the terrain of political philosophical debate concerning the principles, scope, and material implications of social justice. Social justice for Rawls concerns the principles that govern the operation of major social institutions. Major social institutions structure the lives of citizens by regulating access to the resources and opportunities that the formulation and realization of human projects require. Rawls’ theory of social justice regards major institutions as just when they distribute what he calls “primary goods” in a manner that he regards as egalitarian. Hence, the subsequent social justice debate has been shaped by and large as a debate about the meaning and implications of egalitarianism. While on the surface a debate about egalitarianism as a distributional principle seems to uncover the core problem of social justice—how much of what everyone should get as a matter of right—the entire history of the debate has been conducted in abstraction fr om what matters most to people’s lives. It is as a corrective to such abstractions that the life-value approach to social justice has been developed.

A new collection of essays edited by Michael J. Thompson aims to explicate and defend the humanist values which, according to the authors, were the core of Marx's critique of capitalist society. The text does not aim to provide a political roadmap to building an alternative society in which those values could be realized but rather philosophical analysis of the meaning and implications of those values. While there are sometimes tensions between the philosophical arguments developed in the various essays that make up the text and the traditions of Marxist political practice, the book as a whole certainly proves that the human values of Marx's philosophy are central to his politics and that his emancipatory vision remains relevant, even necessary.

The long tradition of pessimism in philosophy and poetry notoriously laments suffering caused by vulnerabilities of the human body. The most familiar and contemporary version is antinatalism, the view that it is wrong to bring sentient life into existence because birth inevitably produces suffering. Technotopianism, which stems from a similarly negative view of embodied limitations, claims that we should escape sickness and death through radical human-enhancement technologies. In Embodiment and the Meaning of Life Jeff Noonan presents pessimism and technotopianism as two sides of the same coin, as both begin from the premise that the limitations of embodied life are inherently negative. He argues that rather than rendering life pointless, the tragic failures that mark life are fundamental to the good of human existence. The necessary limitations of embodied being are challenges for each person to live well, not only for their own sake, but for the sake of the future of the human project. Meaning is not a given, Noonan suggests, but rather the product of labour upon ourselves, others, and the world. Meaningful labour is threatened equally by unjust social systems and runaway technological development that aims to replace human action, rather than liberate it. Calling on us to draw conceptual connections between finitude, embodiment, and the meaning of life, this book shows that seeking the common good is our most viable and materially realistic source of optimism about the future.

In his Nobel Prize acceptance speech in 1987, the Russian-born American poet Joseph Brodsky argued that aesthetics is the mother of ethics. However, there is an ambiguity in his use of the term aesthetics. In the first part of this article, I distinguish between Brodsky’s narrow use of aesthetics, which refers to problems of beauty, and the broader sense, which refers to the cognitive function of sensibility and feeling. I then suggest that good sense can be made of the claim about the origins of ethics only if we employ the broader sense of aesthetics. The second part draws on examples from Brodsky and the American poet Jorie Graham to illustrate the ways in which the feelings generated by human sensuous receptivity transform the world from a meaningless physical system into meaningful sets of life-valuable relationships. The third part sharpens this conclusion by considering the conditions under which the world can appear to be meaningless. In the final section I link Brodsky’s poetic responsiveness to the world to John McMurtry’s philosophical analysis of “the felt side of being.” Poetic evocation and philosophical argument are two approaches to the same problem which, when brought together, provide a comprehensive explanation of why aesthetics is the mother of ethics.

The World on Paper. By David R. Olson xix + 319 pp. £17.95/$24.95 cloth. Milton and the Revolutionary Reader. By Sharon Achinstein xv + 272 pp. £27.50/$35.00 cloth. The Rise of Christianity: A Sociologist Reconsiders History. By Rodney Stark xiv + 246 pp. £16.95/$24.95 cloth. The Idea of Luxury: A Conceptual and Historical Investigation. By Christopher J. Berry xiv + 271 pp. £45.00/$69.95 cloth, £17.95/$24.95 paper. Will to Live: One Family's Story of Surviving the Holocaust. By Adam Starkopf 242 pp. $14.95 paper. Meditations of a Holocaust Traveler. By Gerald E. Markle, 185 pp. $12.95 paper. Nazism and German Society. 1933–1945. Edited by David C. Crew xii + 316 pp. £11.99 paper. Women in Ancient Greece. By Sue Blundell 224 pp. $19.95 paper. The Dear Purchase: A Theme in German Modernism. By J. P. Stern 445 pp. $64.95 cloth. An Introduction to Political Ideas. Edited by Peter M. R. Stirk and David Weigall xv + 385 pp. £14.99 paper. André Malraux: Politics and the Temptation of Myth. By Gino Raymond, Avery Series in Philosophy vi + 212 pp. $59.95 paper. Collingwood Studies, Volume 1: The Life and Thought of R. G. Collingwood. Edited by David Boucher xiii + 211 pp. paper. Perversion and Utopia: A Study in Psychoanalysis and Critical Theory. By Joel Whitebook 350 pp. $29.95 cloth. A Vindication of the Rights of Men with a Vindication of the Rights of Woman. By Mary Wollstonecraft, edited by Sylvana Tomaselli, Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought £8.95/$ 10.95 paper, £25.00/$44.95 cloth. Utopias of British Enlightenment. By Gregory Claeys, History of Political Thought, xli +305 pp. $19.95 paper. Baroque Personae. Edited by Rosario Villari, translated by Lydia G. Cochrane 357 pp. £37.95/ $54.75 cloth. The Narrative Fiction of Heinrich Boll: Social Conscience and Literary Achievement. Edited by Michael Butler xv + 280 pp. £37.50/$59.95 cloth. La Rochefoucauld and the Language of Unmasking in Seventeenth‐Century France. By Henry C. Clark, Histoire des idees et critique littéraire, vol. 336, 232 pp. paper. Jane Austen and the Representation of Regency England. By Roger Sales xxii + 283 pp. £13.99 paper. Eastern Europe in the Twentieth Century. By R. J. Crampton, xx + 475 pp. £14.99 paper. What Is Enlightenment? Eighteenth‐Century Answers and Twentieth‐Century Questions. Edited by James Schmidt xiii + 563 pp. $50.00 cloth, $24.95 paper. Only Paradoxes to Offer: French Feminists and the Rights of Man. By Joan Wallach Scott 256 pp. $27.95 paper. Darwin Machines and the Nature of Knowledge. By Henry Plotkin xviii + 269 pp. $26.95 cloth. Rediscovering History: Culture, Politics, and the Psyche. Edited by Michael S. Roth xv + 535 pp. $16.95 paper. Narrative, Authority, and Power: The Medieval Exemplum and the Chaucerian Tradition. By Larry Scanlon xii+ 378 pp. £40.00/$64.95 cloth Retreat from the Modern: Humanism, Postmodernism and the Flight from Modernist Culture. By N. J. Rengger vi+ 122 pp. $14.95 paper. Nature, Justice and Rights in Aristotle's Politics. By Fred D. Miller xvii + 424 pp. 40.00 cloth. Hauptsache Europa: Perspectiven für das Europäischen Parlament. By Peter Schönberger, Dokumente und Schriften der Europäischen Akademie Otzenhausen, vol. 72, 130 pp. DM 88.00/as 687/ sFF 88.00 paper. A Proper Dyaloge betwene a Gentillman and an Husbandman. Edited by Douglas H. Parker ix + 291 pp. £33.75/$55.00 cloth. The Genesis of the French Revolution: A Global‐Historical Interpretation. By Bailey Stone 268 pp. $49.95/ £37.50 cloth $14.95/£11.95 paper. Britain in the European Union Today. By Colin Pilkington 260 pp. £35.00 cloth £9.99 paper. Erasmus: His Life, Works, and Influence. By Cornelis Augustijn, translated by J. C. Grayson x + 239 pp. £13.00/$19.95 paper. Jean‐Jacques Rousseau: Music, Illusion and Desire. By Michael O'Dea viii + 284 pp. $59.95 cloth. The Early Political Writings of the German Romantics. Edited and translated by Frederick C. Beiser, Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought £37.50/$54.95 cloth, £13.95/$18.95 paper. Wollstonecraft's Daughters: Womanhood in England and France, 1780–1920. Edited by Clarissa Campbell Orr x + 206 pp. $69.95 cloth. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. By Jeremy Bentham, edited by J. H. Burns and H. L. A. Hart, with a new introduction by F. Rosen cxii + 343 pp. £17.99/$32.00 paper. Community and Consent: The Secular Political Theory of Marsiglio of Padua's Defensor Pacis. By Cary J. Nederman 161 pp. $22.95 paper, $57.50 cloth. Osip Mandelstam and the Modernist Creation of Tradition. By Clare Cavanagh xii + 365 pp. $39.50 cloth. God and Government in an “Age of Reason.” By David Nicholls 1995, xi + 278 pp. £45.00 cloth. Petersburg, Crucible of Cultural Revolution. By Katerina Clark xii + 377 pp. $39.95 cloth. Histoire du suicide: la société occidentale face à la mort volontaire. By Georges Minois 421 pp. FF 150.00 paper. Classical Probability in the Enlightenment. By Lorraine Daston xviii + 432 pp. $19.95 paper. Daedalus “Social Suffering.” Edited by V. Das, A. Kleinman, and M. Lock 283 pp. $7.95 / $10.35 paper. Cultural Politics in Greater Romania: Regionalism, Nation Building, and Ethnic Struggle, 1918–1930. By Irina Livezeanu 340 pp. £35.50/$45.00 / $49.50 cloth. The Correspondence of Sigmund Freud and Sándor Ferenczi, vol. 2, 1914–1919. Edited by Ernst Falzeder and Eva Brabant, translated by Peter T. Hoffer xlvi +397 pp. $45.00 cloth. Biologists Under Hitler. By Ute Deichmann, translated by Thomas Dunlap xviii + 468 pp. $45.00 cloth. The Crisis of Conservatism: The Politics, Economics and Ideology of the British Conservative Party, 1880–1914. By E. H. H. Green xiv + 412 pp., £50.00 cloth. Marx: Later Political Writings. Edited by Terrell Carver, Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought xxxiii + 260 pp. £a27.95/$24.95 cloth £9.95/$ 12.95 paper. A Small City in France: A Socialist Mayor Confronts Neofascism. By Françoise Gaspard, translated by Arthur Goldhammer xi + 194 pp. $32.50 cloth $15.95 paper. Reading Henry James in French Cultural Contexts. By Pierre A. Walker xxiv+ 230 pp. $28.50 cloth. The Glory of van Gogh: An Anthropology of Admiration. By Nathalie Heinich, translated by Paul Leduc Browne 218 pp. $29.95 paper. Poor Women and Children in the European Past. Edited by John Henderson and Richard Wall xiii + 347 pp. £45.00 cloth. Chopin at the Boundaries: Sex, History and Musical Genre. By Jeffrey Kallberg Convergences xiii + 301 pp. $45.00 cloth. After the USSR: Ethnicity, Nationalism, and Politics in the Commonwealth of Independent States. By Anatoly M. Khazanov xxi + 311 pp. $24.95 cloth. Reflections on Violence. By John Keane 200 pp. £16.95 paper. Fortuna, Money, and the Sublunar World: Twelfth‐century Ethical Poetics and the Satirical Poetry of the Carmina Burana. By Tuomas M. S. Lehtonen, Bibliotheca Histories 9. 188 pp. paper. La Pensée politique de Raymond Aron. By Stephane Launay, Recherches politiques x + 243 pp. 158 FF paper. Psychoanalysis and Gender: An Introductory Reader. By Rosalind Minsky xv + 317 pp. $69.95 cloth/$27.75 paper. Un ≪Intellectuel≫ avant la lettre: le journaliste Pierre Bayle. L'actualité religieuse dans les Nouvelles de la République des Lettres. By Hubert Bost. Etudes de l'Institut Pierre Bayle, Nijmegen xii + 584 pp. 150 cloth.

The article argues that historical materialism is not only a theory of historical change but more generally a mediation between the natural foundations of human life and its meaningful symbolic expressions. The article begins with an interpretation of the general philosophical significance of the basic premises of historical materialism as they are sketched in the German Ideology. I argue that these premises point us in two different directions: down, towards a scientific understanding of the natural world, and up, towards interpretations of meaningful human expressions. Reductionist scientific models are appropriate for the understanding of natural forces, but these reveal their own limitations when applied to social life. Social life cannot be understood outside its symbolic expressions, but these are not free floating ideal abstractions, but remain connected to fundamental human purposes and must be understood as such.

Current patterns of global economic activity are not only unsustainable, but unethical - this claim is central to Materialist Ethics and Life-Value. Grounding the definition of ethical value in the natural and social requirements of life-support and life-development shared by all human beings, Jeff Noonan provides a new way of understanding the universal conception of "the good life." Noonan argues that the true crisis affecting the world today is not sluggish rates of economic growth but the model of measuring economic and social health in terms of money-value. In response, he develops an alternative understanding of good societies where the breadth and depth of life-activity and enjoyment are dependent on dominant institutions. The more social institutions satisfy the necessary requirements of human life, the more they empower each person to develop and enjoy the capacities that make human life valuable and meaningful. A well-reasoned synthesis of traditional philosophical concerns and contemporary critiques of global capitalism, this book is a forward-looking treatise that defends political struggle and reconsiders what is most important for a happy life.

All varieties of socialism share this trait in common: they are systematic alternatives to capitalism. But why should a systematic alternative to capitalism be necessary? Has it not proven to be the most productive economic system in history? Has it not created social conditions in which the powers of human imagination, creativity, and scientific understanding have grown to wider scope than in any previous society? Has it not enabled human beings to extend their life span and live healthier and more active lives than ever before? Has it not proven extraordinarily plastic, able to solve unforeseen problems in ways that its opponents continue to predict that it cannot, thus proving itself superior to any proposed alternative? These are difficult questions that anyone who claims that an alternative is necessary must take seriously.

“The re-discovery of Marx,” Marcello Musto argues, “is based on his persistent capacity to explain the present: he remains an indispensible instrument for understanding it and transforming it.”. It is true that the continuity of problems connecting our world to Marx’s ensures the relevance of historical materialism. At the same time, changes in the structure and scale of capitalism, as well as failures of nineteenth and twentieth century socialism to build a democratic and life-affirming alternative, force twenty-first century socialists to risk new theoretical and practical departures. Yet, nowhere is a consistent ethical-political-economic foundation for twenty-first century socialism fully spelled out. The aim of this paper is to provide the missing foundations of a democratic and ecological socialism in the idea of life-value and the principle of life-coherence developed in the work of John McMurtry.