-
40Two Dogmas of Naturalized EpistemologyDialectica 53 (2): 111-138. 1999.This essay is not concerned exclusively with procedure. In addition to developing and promoting an alternative methodology, I will also be utilizing it to defend, systematically, an unfashionable proposition nowadays. This is the proposition that the question of how a particular judgment, on a particular occasion, is to be justified, is independent of the question of how that judgment comes to be formed by the individual who forms it. This thesis, which I shall call j-independence, is deplored i…Read more
-
38On Planning: Toward a Natural History of Goal AttainmentPhilosophical Papers 37 (2): 289-317. 2008.The goal of the essay is to articulate some beginnings for an empirical approach to the study of agency, in the firm conviction that agency is subject to scientific scrutiny, and is not to be abandoned to high-brow aprioristic philosophy. Drawing on insights from decision analysis, game theory, general dynamics, physics and engineering, this essay will examine the diversity of planning phenomena, and in that way take some steps towards assembling rudiments for the budding science, in the process…Read more
-
37The trouble with superselection accounts of measurementPhilosophy of Science 65 (3): 518-544. 1998.A superselection rule advanced in the course of a quantum-mechanical treatment of some phenomenon is an assertion to the effect that the superposition principle of quantum mechanics is to be restricted in the application at hand. Superselection accounts of measurement all have in common a decision to represent the indicator states of detectors by eigenspaces of superselection operators named in a superselection rule, on the grounds that the states in question are states of a so-called classical …Read more
-
35Why we BelieveJournal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 30 (2): 317-339. 1999.The radical probabilist counsels the prudent never to put away uncertainty, and hence always to balance judgment with probabilities of various sizes. Against this counsel I shall advise in favor of the practice of full belief — at least for some occasions. This advice rests on the fact that it is sometimes in a person's interests to accept certain propositions as a means of bringing it about that others recognize oneself as having accepted those propositions. With the pragmatists, therefore, I s…Read more
-
34In favor of being only HumeanPhilosophical Studies 93 (3): 265-298. 1999.The twin conceptions of (1) natural law as causal structure and (2) explanation as passage from phenomenon to cause, are two sides of a certain philosophical coin, to which I shall offer an alternative – Humean – currency. The Humean alternative yokes together a version of the regularity conception of law and a conception of explanation as passage from one regularity, to another which has it as an instance but of which it is not itself an instance. I will show that the regularity conception of l…Read more
-
33Imitative ReasoningSocial Epistemology 23 (3): 381-405. 2009.On the classical instrumental view, practical reason is an all-things-considered enterprise, concerned not merely with identifying and evaluating appropriate means to the realization of ends construed as uncriticizable, but also with coordinating achievement of their sum. The concept of a totality of ranked concerns is the cornerstone of the theory of utility. This paper discusses some of the ways that practical reasoning, on the ground, is not instrumental in this sense. The paper will demonstr…Read more
-
23“Searle’s Foole: How a Constructionist Account of Society Cannot Substitute for a Causal One”American Journal of Economics and Sociology 62 (1): 105-122. 2003.In The Construction of Social Reality, John Searle promises a causal account of how social facts are constructed by human acts of intention, but specifically disavows a special theoretical space in that account for human motivation. This paper argues that such a story as Searle tells cannot serve as a causal account of society. A causal account must illuminate motivations, because doing so illuminates the aims and interests lacking which we cannot explain why these social practices come to be and…Read more
-
22The Sources of Behavior: Toward a Naturalistic, Control Account of AgencyIn Don Ross, David Spurrett, Harold Kincaid & G. Lynn Stephens (eds.), Distributed Cognition and the Will: Individual Volition and Social Context, Mit Press. pp. 123--67. 2007.
-
22Precaution has its reasonsIn W. Kabasenche, M. O'Rourke & M. Slater (eds.), Topics in Contemporary Philosophy 9: The Environment, Philosophy, Science and Ethics, Mit Press. 2012.This chapter focuses on finding better ways to conceptualize precaution. Precaution has now become an established principle of environmental governance, although it has not been distinguished from conventional risk assessment. It has been considered by some as the antithesis of risk assessment in the sense that it is done to avoid serious potential harm, without scientific certainty as to the likelihood, magnitude, or causation of that harm. The first and foremost task of this chapter is to show…Read more
-
21Philosophy in the age of science: J. Beale and I. J. Kidd, Eds.: Wittgenstein and scientism. Routledge, 2017, 232pp, $140 HB (review)Metascience 28 (1): 51-53. 2018.
-
21Why is there Philosophy of Mathematics at all? (review)Philosophical Quarterly 67 (269): 857-860. 2017.© The Author 2016. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of The Scots Philosophical Association and the University of St Andrews. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: [email protected] Hacking is a gripping writer with an ear for wickedly good turns of phrase. The joyous playfulness of his language can arouse interest in any topic whatsoever. He is also a skilled philosophical conversationalist, who can put long-dead philosophers into dialogue with those…Read more
-
19This is my impersonation of a philosopher working from home, which aims at making lively a few worthy philosophical questions. The old is new again, as each generation confronts its own challenges and demons, in its own context.
-
18Correction to: Philosophy in the age of science: J. Beale and I. J. Kidd, Eds.: Wittgenstein and scientism. Routledge, 2017, 232pp, $140 HB (review)Metascience 28 (1): 55-55. 2018.In “Philosophy in the age of science,” a review of J. Beale’s and I. J. Kidd’s edited volume, _Wittgenstein and scientism_, by Mariam Thalos, Chon Tejedor was mistakenly referred to as he, rather than she.
-
16Who will advise us?SATS 16 (1): 67-95. 2015.This essay argues that, in place of the present hit-and-miss system of specialist advisement (a system of scientific experts performing case-by-case studies at numerous regulatory agencies, the US Office of Technology Assessment, for example), we require a corps of professional public servants for the dissemination of credible, learned, relevant and useful information pertaining to the issues of the day. This is necessary because scientists as a group are poorly prepared for the task of advising…Read more
-
16The Grammar of ExperiencePhilosophy 89 (2): 223-250. 2014.What do we learn when we focus analysis – not so much on the content of experience – as on its universal features and functioning? Descartes believed that such focus (when exercised by someone employing his first-personal method of inquiry) held the key to the fundamental metaphysics of our universe – that it could reveal fundamental truths about the nature of substance, or at any rate could reveal some fundamental metaphysical categories and their contrasts. He believed such focus could lead to…Read more
-
15The Logic of Measurement: A Defense of Foundationalist EmpiricismEpisteme 1-26. forthcoming.Practitioners of science treat evidence as a separate and objective body of materials that is independent of, and possibly also prior to, all of theorizing. Philosophers of science, by contrast, are increasingly wary of the role of theory in testing and measurement contexts, and hence have problematized the notion of evidence as prior or independent, even in the context of measurement. This paper argues that there is an important sense in which empirical certification of a quantity, via measurem…Read more
-
15The reduction of causationIn Kyburg Jr, E. Henry & Mariam Thalos (eds.), Probability is the Very Guide of Life: The Philosophical Uses of Chance, Open Court. pp. 295. 2003.It is a perennial philosophical enterprise to propose the reduction of causal facts to facts of some other kind. Just as it is also a perennial enterprise to proclaim that certain such proposed reductions are doomed to failure. Here I shall champion a certain family of reductionist proposals—namely, those that quantify the notion of causality—referring to them as quantitative reductions. The opposition to quantitative reductionism proclaims that an antireductionist analysis of causation is to be…Read more
-
15A Modest Proposal for Interpreting Structural ExplanationsBritish Journal for the Philosophy of Science 49 (2): 279-295. 1998.Social sciences face a well-known problem, which is an instance of a general problem faced as well by psychological and biological sciences: the problem of establishing their legitimate existence alongside physics. This, as will become clear, is a problem in metaphysics. I will show how a new account of structural explanations, put forward by Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit, which is designed to solve this metaphysical problem with social sciences in mind, fails to treat the problem in any impor…Read more
-
13The Economy of Belief or, Explaining Cooperation among the PrudentAmerican Philosophical Quarterly 35 (4). 1998.
-
12Philosophical Meditations on “Black lives matter"The Critique. 2016.What does “Black lives matter” say that “All lives matter” does not? In particular, why do we appreciate a kind of conflict between them? This essay is about the way that social identities work in human life. Appreciating the way that identity works will shed light on the way that “All lives matter” undermines the force of “Black lives matter.”
-
12The Lens of ChemistryScience & Education 22 (7): 1707-1721. 2013.Chemistry possesses a distinctive theoretical lens—a distinctive set of theoretical concerns regarding the dynamics and transformations of a perplexing variety of organic and nonorganic substances—to which it must be faithful. Even if it is true that chemical facts bear a special (reductive) relationship to physical facts, nonetheless it will always still be true that the theoretical lenses of the two disciplines are distinct. This has consequences for how chemists pursue their research, as well…Read more
-
11A Social Theory of FreedomRoutledge. 2016.In A Social Theory of Freedom, Mariam Thalos argues that the philosophical theory of human freedom should be a broadly social and political theory that employs tools of phenomenology, rather than a theory that locates itself in relation to canonical positions regarding the issue of determinism. Thalos rejects the premise that a theory of freedom is fundamentally a theory of the metaphysics of constraint and, instead, lays out a political conception of freedom that is closely aligned with questio…Read more
-
11Powers that Reside in CommunicationSATS 24 (2): 147-166. 2023.Is it possible to measure a people’s capacity for containing the ambitions of any regime at its helm—its ability to resist the power of a tyrant? We begin here from the premise that this power has to be in proportion to individuals’ capacity (both individually and in groups) for communicating, at least among themselves, dissatisfaction with the regime. As the paper subsequently shows, by articulating an ontology of information diffusion on a communication network structure, it is possible to tak…Read more
-
10Mariam Thalos discusses freedomElucidations. 2018.We all categorize ourselves. You might think of yourself as a student, or as a painter, or as being good with numbers, or as being civic-minded. These labels we use to categorize ourselves have a huge effect on how we make our decisions–when faced with the choice of doing X vs. doing Y, whether I think of myself as someone’s who’s civic-minded and whether someone who’s civic-minded would do X can both play a huge role in influencing whether I decide to do X. What does all that have to do with fr…Read more
-
8The Wit of Knitting: A Philosophical Reflection on Knitting Things ArightApa Newsletter on Feminism and Philosophy 1 (8): 13-16. 2008.
-
8ExistentialismIn Graham Oppy (ed.), A Companion to Atheism and Philosophy, Wiley. 2019.This chapter explores connections among death, meaning, and belief in a divine being. It wrestles with questions around whether it is possible for an atheist to live a meaningful life, especially in the face of the twin realities of individual death, on the one hand, and human extinction, on the other. Can theists and atheists think about the meaning of life in the same way? The conclusion is that most likely there are unbridgeable chasms between the theists’ and the atheists’ conceptions of mea…Read more
-
4Philosophy of ScienceIn AccessScience. 2019.The subfield of philosophy that treats fundamental questions pertaining to science. The philosophy of science explores the fundamental principles, purposes, methodologies, implications, and reliability of the human enterprise known as science. It seeks to describe our best understanding of the universe, at all scales, as well as to engage with the question of how we can—as fallible organisms—reliably come to possess such knowledge. How can it be possible for us to arrive at theories that describ…Read more
-
3What is a feminist to do with rational choice?In Alan Nelson (ed.), A Companion to Rationalism, Blackwell. pp. 450-467. 2005.This chapter contains sections titled: Introduction Rational Choice Moral Philosophy Science of Human Behavior Back to Moral Philosophy Rational Choice, Finally Against Orthodoxy Public and Private.
Knoxville, Tennessee, United States of America
Areas of Specialization
Metaphysics and Epistemology |
Science, Logic, and Mathematics |
Philosophy, Misc |
Other Academic Areas |