-
1052Mutual translatability, equivalence, and the structure of theoriesSynthese 200 (3): 1-36. 2022.This paper presents a simple pair of first-order theories that are not definitionally (nor Morita) equivalent, yet are mutually conservatively translatable and mutually 'surjectively' translatable. We use these results to clarify the overall geography of standards of equivalence and to show that the structural commitments that theories make behave in a more subtle manner than has been recognized.
-
884Plantinga on Providence and PhysicsEuropean Journal for Philosophy of Religion 5 (3): 19--30. 2013.Discussion of Alvin Plantinga's book, "Where the Conflict Really Lies"
-
843John Bell on ‘Subject and Object’: An ExchangeJournal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 54 (2): 305-324. 2022.This three-part paper comprises: (i) a critique by Halvorson of Bell’s (1973) paper ‘Subject and Object’; (ii) a comment by Butterfield; (iii) a reply by Halvorson. An Appendix gives the passage from Bell that is the focus of Halvorson’s critique.
-
829Some philosophers say that in special relativity, four-dimensional stuff is invariant in some sense that three-dimensional stuff is not. I show that this claim is false.
-
670What Scientific Theories Could Not BePhilosophy of Science 79 (2): 183-206. 2012.According to the semantic view of scientific theories, theories are classes of models. I show that this view -- if taken seriously as a formal explication -- leads to absurdities. In particular, this view equates theories that are truly distinct, and it distinguishes theories that are truly equivalent. Furthermore, the semantic view lacks the resources to explicate interesting theoretical relations, such as embeddability of one theory into another. The untenability of the semantic view -- as cur…Read more
-
653To be a realist about quantum theoryIn Olimpia Lombardi (ed.), Quantum Worlds: Perspectives on the Ontology of Quantum Mechanics, . 2019.I look at the distinction between between realist and antirealist views of the quantum state. I argue that this binary classification should be reconceived as a continuum of different views about which properties of the quantum state are representationally significant. What's more, the extreme cases -- all or none --- are simply absurd, and should be rejected by all parties. In other words, no sane person should advocate extreme realism or antirealism about the quantum state. And if we focus on …Read more
-
501The Philosophy of Science in Either-OrIn Ryan Kemp & Walter Wietzke (eds.), Cambridge Critical Guide to Either-Or, Cambridge University Press. forthcoming.Kierkegaard's Either-Or is a book about the choice between aesthetic, ethical, and religious approaches to life. I show that Either-Or also contains a proposal for philosophy of science, and in particular, about the ideal epistemic state for human beings. Whereas the Cartesian-Hegelian tradition conceived of the ideal state as one of detached deliberation -- i.e. "seeing the world as it is in itself" -- Kierkegaard envisions the ideal state as the achievement of equilibrium between the "spectato…Read more
-
487Carnap's Formal Philosophy of ScienceIn Christian Dambock & Georg Schiemer (eds.), Rudolf Carnap Handbuch, Metzler Verlag. forthcoming.A brief review of Carnap's formal program in philosophy of science.
-
462Theism and physical cosmologyIn Charles Taliaferro, Victoria Harrison & Stewart Goetz (eds.), Routledge Companion to Theism, . 2010.Physical cosmology purports to establish precise and testable claims about the origin of the universe. Thus, cosmology bears directly on traditional metaphysical claims -- in particular, claims about whether the universe has a creator (i.e. God). What is the upshot of cosmology for the claims of theism? Does big-bang cosmology support theism? Do recent developments in quantum and string cosmology undermine theism? We discuss the relations between physical cosmology to theism from both historical…Read more
-
461We give a simple proof that there is no time in a quantum world.
-
420On the nature of continuous physical quantities in classical and quantum mechanicsJournal of Philosophical Logic 30 (1): 27-50. 2001.Within the traditional Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics, it is not possible to describe a particle as possessing, simultaneously, a sharp position value and a sharp momentum value. Is it possible, though, to describe a particle as possessing just a sharp position value (or just a sharp momentum value)? Some, such as Teller, have thought that the answer to this question is No - that the status of individual continuous quantities is very different in quantum mechanics than in classical…Read more
-
403Steven French: There Are No Such Things as Theories: Oxford University Press: Oxford 2020, 288 pp., £55.00, ISBN: 9780198848158 (review)Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 52 (4): 609-612. 2021.
-
399A sentence's meaning may depend on the state of motion of the speaker. I argue that this context-sensitivity blocks the inference from special relativity to four-dimensionalism.
-
392The Semantic View, If Plausible, Is SyntacticPhilosophy of Science 80 (3): 475-478. 2013.Halvorson argues that the semantic view of theories leads to absurdities. Glymour shows how to inoculate the semantic view against Halvorson's criticisms, namely by making it into a syntactic view of theories. I argue that this modified semantic-syntactic view cannot do the philosophical work that the original "language-free" semantic view was supposed to do
-
380Objective description in physicsIn Tomas Marvan, Hanne Andersen, Hasok Chang, Benedikt Löwe & Ivo Pezlar (eds.), Proceedings of the 16th International Congress of Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science and Technology, College Publications. 2022.I argue against the claim -- advocated by Albert Einstein, Bernard Williams, and Ted Sider, among others -- that a description is objective only if it says how the world is in itself. Instead, I argue for the claim -- inspired by comments of Niels Bohr -- that a family of descriptions is objective only if they co-vary with their respective descriptive contexts. Moreover, I claim that "there is a shared objective reality" simply means that it is possible to satisfy this kind of covariance requi…Read more
-
374Closing the Hole ArgumentBritish Journal for the Philosophy of Science. forthcoming.The hole argument purportedly shows that spacetime substantivalism implies a pernicious form of indeterminism. We show that the argument is seductive only because it mistakes a trivial claim (viz. there are isomorphic models) for a significant claim (viz. there are hole isomorphisms). We prove that the latter claim is false -- thereby closing the debate about whether substantivalism implies indeterminism.
-
369How is spontaneous symmetry breaking possible? Understanding Wigner's theorem in light of unitary inequivalenceStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 44 (4): 464-469. 2013.We pose and resolve a puzzle about spontaneous symmetry breaking in the quantum theory of infinite systems. For a symmetry to be spontaneously broken, it must not be implementable by a unitary operator in a ground state's GNS representation. But Wigner's theorem guarantees that any symmetry's action on states is given by a unitary operator. How can this unitary operator fail to implement the symmetry in the GNS representation? We show how it is possible for a unitary operator of this sort to con…Read more
-
363The purpose of this paper is to examine in detail a particularly interesting pair of first-order theories. In addition to clarifying the overall geography of notions of equivalence between theories, this simple example yields two surprising conclusions about the relationships that theories might bear to one another. In brief, we see that theories lack both the Cantor-Bernstein and co-Cantor-Bernstein properties.
-
347A Theological Critique of the Fine-Tuning ArgumentIn Matthew A. Benton, John Hawthorne & Dani Rabinowitz (eds.), Knowledge, Belief, and God: New Insights in Religious Epistemology, Oxford University Press. pp. 122-135. 2018.According to the premises of the fine-tuning argument, most nomologically possible universes lack intelligent life; and the fact that ours has intelligent life is best explained by supposing it was created. However, if our universe was created, then the creator chose the laws of nature, and hence chose in favor of lifeless universes. In other words, the fine-tuning argument shows that God prefers universes without intelligent life; and the fact that our universe has intelligent life provides n…Read more
-
333AntimatterBritish Journal for the Philosophy of Science 61 (1): 93-121. 2010.The nature of antimatter is examined in the context of algebraic quantum field theory. It is shown that the notion of antimatter is more general than that of antiparticles. Properly speaking, then, antimatter is not matter made up of antiparticles—rather, antiparticles are particles made up of antimatter. We go on to discuss whether the notion of antimatter is itself completely general in quantum field theory. Does the matter–antimatter distinction apply to all field theoretic systems? The answe…Read more
-
294The Conventionality of ParastatisticsBritish Journal for the Philosophy of Science 66 (4): 929-976. 2015.Nature seems to be such that we can describe it accurately with quantum theories of bosons and fermions alone, without resort to parastatistics. This has been seen as a deep mystery: paraparticles make perfect physical sense, so why don’t we see them in nature? We consider one potential answer: every paraparticle theory is physically equivalent to some theory of bosons or fermions, making the absence of paraparticles in our theories a matter of convention rather than a mysterious empirical disco…Read more
-
294No place for particles in relativistic quantum theories?Philosophy of Science 69 (1): 1-28. 2002.David Malament (1996) has recently argued that there can be no relativistic quantum theory of (localizable) particles. We consider and rebut several objections that have been made against the soundness of Malament’s argument. We then consider some further objections that might be made against the generality of Malament’s conclusion, and we supply three no‐go theorems to counter these objections. Finally, we dispel potential worries about the counterintuitive nature of these results by showing th…Read more
-
289The thesis of quantifier variance is consistent and cannot be refuted via a collapse argument.
-
287Are Rindler Quanta Real? Inequivalent Particle Concepts in Quantum Field TheoryBritish Journal for the Philosophy of Science 52 (3): 417-470. 2001.Philosophical reflection on quantum field theory has tended to focus on how it revises our conception of what a particle is. However, there has been relatively little discussion of the threat to the "reality" of particles posed by the possibility of inequivalent quantizations of a classical field theory, i.e., inequivalent representations of the algebra of observables of the field in terms of operators on a Hilbert space. The threat is that each representation embodies its own distinctive concep…Read more
-
282Quine’s conjecture on many-sorted logicSynthese 194 (9): 3563-3582. 2017.Quine often argued for a simple, untyped system of logic rather than the typed systems that were championed by Russell and Carnap, among others. He claimed that nothing important would be lost by eliminating sorts, and the result would be additional simplicity and elegance. In support of this claim, Quine conjectured that every many-sorted theory is equivalent to a single-sorted theory. We make this conjecture precise, and prove that it is true, at least according to one reasonable notion of the…Read more
-
276A short note on why we use complex numbers in physics
-
272Characterizing quantum theory in terms of information-theoretic constraintsFoundations of Physics 33 (11): 1561-1591. 2002.We show that three fundamental information-theoretic constraints -- the impossibility of superluminal information transfer between two physical systems by performing measurements on one of them, the impossibility of broadcasting the information contained in an unknown physical state, and the impossibility of unconditionally secure bit commitment -- suffice to entail that the observables and state space of a physical theory are quantum-mechanical. We demonstrate the converse derivation in part, a…Read more
-
266Complementarity of representations in quantum mechanicsStudies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 35 (1): 45-56. 2004.We show that Bohr's principle of complementarity between position and momentum descriptions can be formulated rigorously as a claim about the existence of representations of the canonical commutation relations. In particular, in any representation where the position operator has eigenstates, there is no momentum operator, and vice versa. Equivalently, if there are nonzero projections corresponding to sharp position values, all spectral projections of the momentum operator map onto the zero eleme…Read more
-
249Entanglement and Open Systems in Algebraic Quantum Field TheoryStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 32 (1): 1-31. 2001.Entanglement has long been the subject of discussion by philosophers of quantum theory, and has recently come to play an essential role for physicists in their development of quantum information theory. In this paper we show how the formalism of algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT) provides a rigorous framework within which to analyse entanglement in the context of a fully relativistic formulation of quantum theory. What emerges from the analysis are new practical and theoretical limitations on…Read more
-
Princeton UniversityDepartment of Philosophy
Department of MathematicsStuart Professor of Philosophy -
Princeton, New Jersey, United States of America
Areas of Specialization
Philosophy of Physical Science |
Logic and Philosophy of Logic |
General Philosophy of Science |
PhilPapers Editorships
Philosophy of Physical Science |