Treatise 2.3.6, “Of the influence of the imagination on the passions,”
provides a magnified view into the relationship between motivation, morality,
and politics in Hume’s philosophy. Here, Hume analyzes a “noted passage”
from the history of antiquity in which the citizens of fifth-century Athens
deliberated over whether to burn the ships of their neighboring Grecians after
winning a decisive naval victory against the Persians. Hume finds the passage
notable precisely because of a failure of the…
Read moreTreatise 2.3.6, “Of the influence of the imagination on the passions,”
provides a magnified view into the relationship between motivation, morality,
and politics in Hume’s philosophy. Here, Hume analyzes a “noted passage”
from the history of antiquity in which the citizens of fifth-century Athens
deliberated over whether to burn the ships of their neighboring Grecians after
winning a decisive naval victory against the Persians. Hume finds the passage
notable precisely because of a failure of the imagination to exert an influence
on the Athenians’ passions during their deliberations, leading them to abstain
from further military action. This paper discusses how Hume’s analysis of this
event reveals new connections between his passional, moral, and political
theories in the Treatise.