-
1059Constitutional Failures of Meritocracy and Their ConsequencesHopos: The Journal of the International Society for the History of Philosophy of Science 3 (1): 142-144. 2013.Many of the commentators—let’s ignore their sex for the moment—suggested including women in the Feyerabend conference. Then the question was raised, “but are they of the right quality, status, rank?” That is, do they bring down the average quality of the conference in virtue of their being of inferior status, or, in Vincenzo Politi’s words, not “someone whose work is both relevant to the topic of the conference and also as widely recognized as the work of the invited speakers” (HOPOS-L archive, …Read more
-
1289Species selection on variabilityProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 90 595-599. 1993.this requirement for adaptations. Emergent characters are always potential adaptations. Not all selection processes produce adaptations, however. The key issue, in delineating a selection process, is the relationship between a character and fitness. The emergent character approach is more restrictive than alternative schemas that delineate selection..
-
1056Individuality and adaptation across levels of selection: How shall we name and generalize the unit of Darwinism?Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 96 (21): 11904-09. 1999.Two major clarifications have greatly abetted the understanding and fruitful expansion of the theory of natural selection in recent years: the acknowledgment that interactors, not replicators, constitute the causal unit of selection; and the recognition that interactors are Darwinian individuals, and that such individuals exist with potency at several levels of organization (genes, organisms, demes, and species in particular), thus engendering a rich hierarchical theory of selection in contrast …Read more
-
1113Reductionism in Medicine: Social aspects of healthIn Marc H. V. Van Regenmortel & David L. Hull (eds.), Promises and Limits of Reductionism in the Biomedical Sciences, J. Wiley and Sons. pp. 67-82. 2002.
-
6011Female sexual arousal: Genital anatomy and orgasm in intercourseHormones and Behavior 59 780-792. 2011.In men and women sexual arousal culminates in orgasm, with female orgasm solely from sexual intercourse often regarded as a unique feature of human sexuality. However, orgasm from sexual intercourse occurs more reliably in men than in women, likely reflecting the different types of physical stimulation men and women require for orgasm. In men, orgasms are under strong selective pressure as orgasms are coupled with ejaculation and thus contribute to male reproductive success. By contrast, women's…Read more
-
2208Evolutionary psychology: A view from evolutionary biologyPsychological Inquiry 13 (2). 2002.Given the recent explosion of interest in applications of evolutionary biology to understanding human psychology, we think it timely to assure better understanding of modern evolutionary theory among the psychologists who might be using it. We find it necessary to do so because of the very reducd version of evolutionary theorizing that has been incorporated into much of evolutionary psychology so far. Our aim here is to clarify why the use of a reduced version of evolutionary genetics will lead …Read more
-
3373The Nature of Darwin’s Support for the Theory of Natural SelectionPhilosophy of Science 50 (1): 112-129. 1983.When natural selection theory was presented, much active philosophical debate, in which Darwin himself participated, centered on its hypothetical nature, its explanatory power, and Darwin's methodology. Upon first examination, Darwin's support of his theory seems to consist of a set of claims pertaining to various aspects of explanatory success. I analyze the support of his method and theory given in the Origin of Species and private correspondence, and conclude that an interpretation focusing o…Read more
-
1480A structural approach to defining units of selectionPhilosophy of Science 56 (3): 395-418. 1989.The conflation of two fundamentally distinct issues has generated serious confusion in the philosophical and biological literature concerning the units of selection. The question of how a unit of selection of defined, theoretically, is rarely distinguished from the question of how to determine the empirical accuracy of claims--either specific or general--concerning which unit(s) is undergoing selection processes. In this paper, I begin by refining a definition of the unit of selection, first pre…Read more
-
3219Science Gone Astray: Evolution and Rape (review)Michigan Law Review 99 (6): 1536-1559. 2001.This is a critique of "A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion" (Thornhill & Palmer, 2000). Lloyd argues that they have failed to do "excellent science" as required to defend themselves against criticism. As an example, Lloyd contends that they make conclusions which depend on rape being a single trait, while failing to prorivde any basis for such an assumption.
-
2720Objectivity and the double standard for feminist epistemologiesSynthese 104 (3). 1995.The emphasis on the limitations of objectivity, in specific guises and networks, has been a continuing theme of contemporary analytic philosophy for the past few decades. The popular sport of baiting feminist philosophers — into pointing to what's left out of objective knowledge, or into describing what methods, exactly, they would offer to replace the powerful objective methods grounding scientific knowledge — embodies a blatant double standard which has the effect of constantly putting feminis…Read more
-
1093Groups on groups: Some dynamics and possible resolution of the units of selection debates in evolutionary biology (review)Biology and Philosophy 15 (3): 389-401. 2000.David Hull's analysis of conceptual change in science, as presentedin his book, Science as a Process (1988), provides a useful framework for understanding one of the scientific controversies in which he actively and constructively intervened, the units of selectiondebates in evolutionary biology. What follows is a brief overview ofthose debates and some reflections on them.
-
1253Confirmation of ecological and evolutionary modelsBiology and Philosophy 2 (3): 277-293. 1987.In this paper I distinguish various ways in which empirical claims about evolutionary and ecological models can be supported by data. I describe three basic factors bearing on confirmation of empirical claims: fit of the model to data; independent testing of various aspects of the model, and variety of evident. A brief description of the kinds of confirmation is followed by examples of each kind, drawn from a range of evolutionary and ecological theories. I conclude that the greater complexity a…Read more
-
1681The anachronistic anarchistPhilosophical Studies 81 (2-3). 1996.A reading of Feyerabend in Against Method, and a comparison of C.S. Peirce.
-
2905Adaptationism and the Logic of Research Questions: How to Think Clearly About Evolutionary CausesBiological Theory 10 (4). 2015.This article discusses various dangers that accompany the supposedly benign methods in behavioral evoltutionary biology and evolutionary psychology that fall under the framework of "methodological adaptationism." A "Logic of Research Questions" is proposed that aids in clarifying the reasoning problems that arise due to the framework under critique. The live, and widely practiced, " evolutionary factors" framework is offered as the key comparison and alternative. The article goes beyond the trad…Read more
-
1394Response to Puts and Dawood's 'The Evolution of Female Orgasm: Adaptation or Byproduct?'--Been ThereTwin Studies and Human Genetics 9 (4). 2006.
-
4840Evolutionary Psychology: The Burdens of ProofBiology and Philosophy 14 (2): 211-233. 1999.I discuss two types of evidential problems with the most widely touted experiments in evolutionary psychology, those performed by Leda Cosmides and interpreted by Cosmides and John Tooby. First, and despite Cosmides and Tooby's claims to the contrary, these experiments don't fulfil the standards of evidence of evolutionary biology. Second Cosmides and Tooby claim to have performed a crucial experiment, and to have eliminated rival approaches. Though they claim that their results are consistent w…Read more
-
190The role of 'complex' empiricism in the debates about satellite data and climate modelsStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 43 (2): 390-401. 2012.climate scientists have been engaged in a decades-long debate over the standing of satellite measurements of the temperature trends of the atmosphere above the surface of the earth. This is especially significant because skeptics of global warming and the greenhouse effect have utilized this debate to spread doubt about global climate models used to predict future states of climate. I use this case from an under-studied science to illustrate two distinct philosophical approaches to the relation …Read more
-
Book notices-the structure and confirmation of evolutionary theoryHistory and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 21 (2): 242-242. 1999.
-
28Selection Models and the Darwinian Theory of Natural SelectionPhilosophie Et Culture: Actes du XVIIe Congrès Mondial de Philosophie 3 108-112. 1988.
-
99
-
3376Pre-Theoretical Assumptions in Evolutionary Explanations of female sexualityPhilosophical Studies 69 (2-3): 139-153. 1993.My contribution to this Symposium focuses on the links between sexuality and reproduction from the evolutionary point of view.' The relation between women's sexuality and reproduction is particularly importantb ecause of a vital intersectionb etweenp olitics and biology feminists have noticed, for more than a century, that women's identity is often defined in terms of her reproductive capacity. More recently, in the second wave of the feminist movement in the United States, debates about women's…Read more
-
1646I—Elisabeth A. Lloyd: Varieties of Support and Confirmation of Climate ModelsAristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 83 (1): 213-232. 2009.Today's climate models are supported in a couple of ways that receive little attention from philosophers or climate scientists. In addition to standard 'model fit', wherein a model's simulation is compared to observational data, there is an additional type of confirmation available through the variety of instances of model fit. When a model performs well at fitting first one variable and then another, the probability of the model under some standard confirmation function, say, likelihood, goes u…Read more
-
170Units and levels of selectionStanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2008.The theory of evolution by natural selection is, perhaps, the crowning intellectual achievement of the biological sciences. There is, however, considerable debate about which entity or entities are selected and what it is that fits them for that role. This article aims to clarify what is at issue in these debates by identifying four distinct, though often confused, concerns and then identifying how the debates on what constitute the units of selection depend to a significant degree on which of t…Read more
-
Indiana University, BloomingtonDepartment of History and Philosophy of Science and MedicineDistinguished Professor
Bloomington, Indiana, United States of America
Areas of Specialization
| Philosophy of Biology |
| General Philosophy of Science |
Areas of Interest
| Philosophy of Biology |
| General Philosophy of Science |