-
37Marx's Social Critique of Culture. By Louis Dupre (review)Modern Schoolman 63 (3): 220-222. 1986.
-
34Logi Gunnarsson. Making Moral Sense: Beyond Habermas and Gauthier (review)Modern Schoolman 79 (4): 315-318. 2002.
-
33Pluralism and the Pragmatic Turn: The Transformation of Critical Theory, Essays in Honor of Thomas Mccarthy (edited book)MIT Press. 2001.The essays in this volume reflect on and expand Frankfurt School critical theory as reformulated after World War II by Karl-Otto Apel, Jürgen Habermas, and others. Frankfurt School critical theory since the pragmatic turn has become a richer source of critical analysis that is at the same time socially and politically more effective. The essays are dedicated to Thomas McCarthy, who has done perhaps more than any other scholar to introduce English-speaking audiences to contemporary German critica…Read more
-
32Marx's Theory of Scientific Knowledge. By Patrick Murray (review)Modern Schoolman 66 (4): 316-318. 1989.
-
3117 Reason and Rhetoric in Habermas's Theory of ArgumentationIn eds Walter Jost and Michael J. Hyde (ed.), Rhetoric and Hermeneutics in Our Time: A Reader, Yale University Press. pp. 358-377
-
30Perceptual Intentionality and Brandom’s Pragmatics: Comments on Michael BarberModern Schoolman 84 (2-3): 267-277. 2007.
-
27The thesis of my paper is that argumentation theory provides a promising heuristic framework for addressing issues raised by the rationality debates in the philosophy of science, in particular the issues connected with scientific controversies over the appraisal and choice of competing theories. The first part of the paper grounds this thesis historically. In criticizing the logical empiricists, Thomas Kuhn set the stage for the subsequent opposition between a normative, anti-sociological philos…Read more
-
27The God of Faith and Reason: Foundations of Christian Theology. By Robert Sokolowski (review)Modern Schoolman 61 (4): 273-274. 1984.
-
25Remarks on legitimation through human rightsPhilosophy and Social Criticism 24 (2-3): 157-171. 1998.
-
25Moral discourse as reflection: Comments on James Swindal’s Reflection RevisitedPhilosophy and Social Criticism 29 (2): 127-136. 2003.In his Reflection Revisited, James Swindal interprets Habermas’s formal pragmatics as recasting the traditional philosophy of reflection in intersubjective, augmentation-theoretic terms. In this review essay, I consider some aspects of Swindal’s interpretation for situated moral criticism. I focus in particular on Swindal’s claim that moral discourse must be preceded by meta-discourses in which actors discuss issues related to the initiation of moral discourse. Although I reject Swindal’s argume…Read more
-
24Insight and Solidarity. A Study in the Discourse Ethics of Jurgen HabermasPhilosophical Review 105 (4): 547. 1996.Despite the foment of the last two decades, philosophical ethics has fallen on hard times. While an increasing number of universalistic moral theories in the Kantian tradition limit themselves to questions of social and political justice, neo-Aristotelian theories of the good, like that of Bernard Williams, question the very possibility and desirability of a philosophical ethics. Viewed against this landscape, the program of discourse or communicative ethics, initiated by Karl Otto-Apel and then…Read more
-
23Critical Science Studies as Argumentation Theory: Who’s Afraid of SSK?Philosophy of the Social Sciences 30 (1): 33-48. 2000.This article asks whether an interdisciplinary "critical science studies" (CSS) is possible between a critical theory in the Frankfurt School tradition, with its commitment to universal standards of reason, and relativistic sociologies of scientific knowledge (e.g., David Bloor's strong programme). It is argued that CSS is possible if its practitioners adopt the epistemological equivalent of Rawls's method of avoidance. A discriminating, public policyrelevant critique of science can then procee…Read more
-
21Review of Andrew Feenberg, Between Reason and Experience: Essays in Technology and Modernity (review)Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews 2010 (8). 2010.
-
21Discourse ethics for computer ethics: a heuristic for engaged dialogical reflectionEthics and Information Technology 17 (1): 27-39. 2015.Attempts to employ discourse ethics for assessing communication and information technologies have tended to focus on managerial and policy-oriented contexts. These initiatives presuppose institutional resources for organizing sophisticated consultation processes that elicit stakeholder input. Drawing on Jürgen Habermas’s discourse ethics, this paper supplements those initiatives by developing a more widely usable framework for moral inquiry and reflection on problematic cyberpractices. Given the…Read more
-
19Reason, Revelation, and the Foundations of Political Philosophy. By James V. Schall (review)Modern Schoolman 67 (2): 161-163. 1990.
-
19Understood as an analysis of clashing argument cultures, C. P. Snow’s “Two Cultures” illuminates challenges to interdisciplinarity. Argument cultures involve not only distinct styles of argumentation and background assumptions, but also emotional attitudes and prejudices, including disdain for other argument cultures, that rest on ideals of inquiry and society. Case studies suggest that fruitful interdisciplinary work across such cultures requires institutionalized boundary contexts in which het…Read more
-
17Review essay : Existentialism and formal pragmatics: Martin J. matu tík, postnational identity: Critical theory and existential philosophy in Habermas, Kierkegaard, and Havel. (New York: Guilford, 1993Philosophy and Social Criticism 21 (2): 135-140. 1995.
-
17Insight and Solidarity: A Study in the Discourse of Ethics of Jürgen HabermasUniversity of California Press. 1994.Discourse ethics represents an exciting new development in neo-Kantian moral theory. William Rehg offers an insightful introduction to its complex theorization by its major proponent, Jürgen Habermas, and demonstrates how discourse ethics allows one to overcome the principal criticisms that have been leveled against neo-Kantianism. Addressing both "commun-itarian" critics who argue that universalist conceptions of justice sever moral deliberation from community traditions, and feminist advocates…Read more
-
16Critique, Action, and Liberation (review)International Philosophical Quarterly 36 (3): 359-360. 1996.
-
16Philosophy and Technology. Edited by Paul T. Durbin and Friedrich Rapp (review)Modern Schoolman 64 (1): 67-68. 1986.
-
16Constellations, EarlyView.
-
16Business Firms as Moral Agents: A Kantian Response to the Corporate Autonomy ProblemJournal of Business Ethics 183 (4): 999-1009. 2023.The idea that business firms qualify as group moral agents offers an attractive basis for understanding corporate moral responsibility. However, that idea gives rise to the “corporate autonomy problem” (CAP): if firms are moral agents, then it seems we must accept the implausible conclusion that firms have basic moral rights, such as the rights to life and liberty. The question, then, is how one might retain the fruitful idea of firms as moral agents, yet avoid CAP. A common approach to avoiding…Read more