•  30
    Is There a Fact of the Matter in the Debate Between Structuralism and Factualism?
    In Maria J. García-Encinas & Fernando Martínez-Manrique (eds.), Special Objects: Social, Fictional, Modal, and Non-Existent, Springer. pp. 245-258. 2025.
    Structuralism and factualism are two significant metaphysical views about the fundamental traits of the world. Structuralism characterizes these traits in terms of structures, which, in turn, are either taken as primitive or accounted for mathematically in ways that may not settle what they are metaphysically (French, The structure of the world: metaphysics and representation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2014). Factualism takes fundamental traits of the world to be facts, which, in turn, ei…Read more
  •  48
    Mona Simion and Christoph Kelp (2020) have recently challenged the traditional conceptual engineering project. They defend a reorientation of this project that moves away from correcting conceptual shortcomings and emphasizes conceptual innovation instead. Central to their proposal is the role played by etiological functions. The present paper argues that this approach leaves them without a specific mechanism for conceptual innovation. It then proposes one such mechanism, which operates independ…Read more
  •  29
    Liars with Curry: Dialetheism and the Prospects for a Uniform Solution
    with Ben Burgis
    In Adam Rieger & Gareth Young (eds.), Dialetheism and its Applications, Springer. pp. 1-20. 2019.
    Some dialetheists have claimed that one of the central advantages of their approach to the Paradoxes of Self-Reference is that they are able to offer a unified solution to structurally similar paradoxes that arise in the semantic and set-theoretic realms (Priest in Mind 103:25–34, [12] and Beyond the limits of thought. Clarendon Press, Oxford, [16]). They argue that since the structures of all of these paradoxes conform with the Inclosure Schema (IS), the Principle of Uniform Solution (PUS) dict…Read more
  •  15
    Vasiliev and the Foundations of Logic
    In Dmitry Zaitsev & Vladimir Markin (eds.), The Logical Legacy of Nikolai Vasiliev and Modern Logic, Springer Verlag. pp. 43-58. 2017.
    Nikolai Vasiliev offered a systematic approach to the development of a class of non-classical logics, which he called “Imaginary Logics”. In this paper, I examine critically some of the central features of Vasiliev’s approach to logical theory, suggesting its relevance to contemporary debates in the philosophy of logic. I argue that there is much of significant value in Vasiliev’s work, which deserves close philosophical engagement.
  •  14
    The Epistemology of Modality and the Epistemology of Mathematics
    In Bob Fischer & Felipe Leon (eds.), Modal Epistemology After Rationalism, Springer. pp. 67-83. 2016.
    In this paper I explore some connections between the epistemology of modality and the epistemology of mathematics, and argue that they have far more in common than it may initially seem to be the case—even though modality need not (in fact, should not) be characterized in terms of possible worlds (as the modal realist insists) and mathematics need not (in fact, should not) be understood in terms of abstract entities (as the platonist recommends). Let’s see why.
  •  40
    Referring to Nothing
    Principia: An International Journal of Epistemology 28 (3). 2024.
    Typical accounts of reference demand that referring terms denote existent objects. This assumption is shared by theories across a variety of areas of philosophy, in particular, direct reference views in philosophy of language; neo-Fregean conceptions in the philosophy of mathematics, and easy-ontology approaches in metaphysics. In this paper, this assumption is resisted and the significance and the possibility of referring to the nonexistent is highlighted. After identifying difficulties in all …Read more
  •  10
    A companion to Latin American philosophy (edited book)
    with Susana Nuccetelli and Ofelia Schutte
    Wiley-Blackwell. 2013.
    This comprehensive collection of original essays written by an international group of scholars addresses the central themes in Latin American philosophy. Represents the most comprehensive survey of historical and contemporary Latin American philosophy available today Comprises a specially commissioned collection of essays, many of them written by Latin American authors Examines the history of Latin American philosophy and its current issues, traces the development of the discipline, and offers b…Read more
  •  36
    Heuristics and Mathematical Practice
    In Bharath Sriraman (ed.), Handbook of the History and Philosophy of Mathematical Practice, Springer Verlag. pp. 431-442. 2024.
    Proofs are central to mathematical practice in large part due to the heuristic role that some of them play. Not only do they help establish a result, but often provide new avenues of mathematical research. Jody Azzouni has argued that underlying the practice of creating mathematical proofs there is a very specific norm: to each proof there should be a corresponding algorithmic derivation, a derivation in an algorithmic system. Here a framework is provided to classify and assess mathematical proo…Read more
  •  502
    Lógica, lenguajes formales y modalidad
    Andamios 20 (53): 45-60. 2023.
    This paper examines two alleged limitations in the use of formal languages: on the one hand, the trade-offs between expressive and inferential power, and on the other, the phenomenon of system imprisonment. After reconceptualizing the issue, we consider the role played by modality in the understanding of certain aspects of mathematical structures and argue for its centrality.
  •  255
    Resisting easy inferences
    Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 102 (3): 729-735. 2021.
    Amie Thomasson has articulated a novel conception of ontological debates, defending an easy approach to ontological questions as part of the articulation of a deflationary metaphysical view (Thomasson, 2015). After raising some concerns to the approach, we sketch a neutralist alternative to her ontological framework, offering an even easier way of conducting ontological debates.
  •  178
    Putnam’s indispensability argument revisited, reassessed, revived
    Theoria : An International Journal for Theory, History and Fundations of Science 33 (2): 201-218. 2018.
    Crucial to Hilary Putnam’s realism in the philosophy of mathematics is to maintain the objectivity of mathematics without the commitment to the existence of mathematical objects. Putnam’s indispensability argument was devised as part of this conception. In this paper, I reconstruct and reassess Putnam’s argument for the indispensability of mathematics, and distinguish it from the more familiar, Quinean version of the argument. Although I argue that Putnam’s approach ultimately fails, I develop a…Read more
  •  380
    The authors provide an object-theoretic analysis of two paradoxes in the theory of possible worlds and propositions stemming from Russell and Kaplan. After laying out the paradoxes, the authors provide a brief overview of object theory and point out how syntactic restrictions that prevent object-theoretic versions of the classical paradoxes are justified philosophically. The authors then trace the origins of the Russell paradox to a problematic application of set theory in the definition of worl…Read more
  •  173
    Is there a zande logic?
    History and Philosophy of Logic 19 (1): 41-54. 1998.
    The issue of what consequences to draw from the existence of non-classical logical systems has been the subject of an interesting debate across a diversity of fields. In this paper the matter of alternative logics is considered with reference to a specific belief system and its propositions :the Azande are said to maintain beliefs about witchcraft which, when expressed propositionally, appear to be inconsistent. When the Azande have been presented with such inconsistencies, they either fail to s…Read more
  •  187
    The No-Category Ontology
    The Monist 98 (3): 233-245. 2015.
    In this paper we argue that there are no categories of being⎯at least not in the robust metaphysical sense of something fundamental. Central arguments that metaphysicians provide in support of fundamental categories, such as indispensability and theoretical utility arguments, are not adequate to guarantee their existence. We illustrate this point by examining Jonathan Lowe’s [2006] four-category ontology, and indicating its shortcomings. In contrast, we offer an alternative, no-category ontology…Read more
  •  381
    Suppes Predicates for Space-Time
    with Newton C. A. da Costa and Steven French
    Synthese 112 (2): 271-279. 1997.
    We formulate Suppes predicates for various kinds of space-time: classical Euclidean, Minkowski's, and that of General Relativity. Starting with topological properties, these continua are mathematically constructed with the help of a basic algebra of events; this algebra constitutes a kind of mereology, in the sense of Lesniewski. There are several alternative, possible constructions, depending, for instance, on the use of the common field of reals or of a non-Archimedian field (with infinitesima…Read more
  •  249
    Scientific representation and nominalism: an empiricist view
    Principia: An International Journal of Epistemology 12 (2): 177-192. 2008.
    Can a constructive empiricist make sense of scientific representation? Usually, a scientific model is an abstract entity, and scientific representation is conceptualized as an intentional relation between scientific models and certain aspects of the world. On this conception, since both the models and the representation relation are abstract, a constructive empiricist, who is not committed to the existence of abstract entities, would be unable to invoke these notions to make sense of scientific …Read more
  •  176
    An anti-realist account of the application of mathematics
    Philosophical Studies 173 (10): 2591-2604. 2016.
    Mathematical concepts play at least three roles in the application of mathematics: an inferential role, a representational role, and an expressive role. In this paper, I argue that, despite what has often been alleged, platonists do not fully accommodate these features of the application of mathematics. At best, platonism provides partial ways of handling the issues. I then sketch an alternative, anti-realist account of the application of mathematics, and argue that this account manages to accom…Read more
  •  209
    In this first paper of a series of works on the foundations of science, we examine the significance of logical and mathematical frameworks used in foundational studies. In particular, we emphasize the distinction between the order of a language and the order of a structure to prevent confusing models of scientific theories with first-order structures, and which are studied in standard model theory. All of us are, of course, bound to make abuses of language even in putatively precise contexts. Th…Read more
  •  315
    Is it possible to nominalize quantum mechanics?
    Philosophy of Science 70 (5): 1424-1436. 2003.
    Hartry Field (1980) has developed an interesting nominalization strategy for Newtonian gravitation theory—a strategy that reformulates the theory without quantification over abstract entities. According to David Malament (1982), Field's strategy cannot be extended to quantum mechanics (QM), and so it only has a limited scope. In a recent work, Mark Balaguer has responded to Malament's challenge by indicating how QM can be nominalized, and by “doing much of the work needed to provide the nominali…Read more
  •  116
    Paraconsistency: Towards a tentative interpretation
    with C. A. De Costa Newton
    Theoria: Revista de Teoría, Historia y Fundamentos de la Ciencia 16 (1): 119-145. 2001.
    In this expository paper, we examine some philosophical and technical issues brought by paraconsistency (such as, motivations for developing a paraconsistent logic, the nature of this logic, and its application to set theory). We also suggest a way of accommodating these issues by considering some problems in the philosophy of logic from a new perspective.
  • Consistency, paraconsistency and truth
    Ideas Y Valores 45 48-60. 1996.
  •  462
    Can Mathematics Explain Physical Phenomena?
    British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 63 (1): 85-113. 2012.
    Batterman raises a number of concerns for the inferential conception of the applicability of mathematics advocated by Bueno and Colyvan. Here, we distinguish the various concerns, and indicate how they can be assuaged by paying attention to the nature of the mappings involved and emphasizing the significance of interpretation in this context. We also indicate how this conception can accommodate the examples that Batterman draws upon in his critique. Our conclusion is that ‘asymptotic reasoning’ …Read more
  •  378
    How to change it: modes of engagement, rationality, and stance voluntarism
    with Darrell Patrick Rowbottom
    Synthese 178 (1): 7-17. 2011.
    We have three goals in this paper. First, we outline an ontology of stance, and explain the role that modes of engagement and styles of reasoning play in the characterization of a stance. Second, we argue that we do enjoy a degree of control over the modes of engagement and styles of reasoning we adopt. Third, we contend that maximizing one’s prospects for change also maximizes one’s rationality