-
The ghost of the given: A case for epistemological ghostbusters or ghostloversBridges 1 59-81. 1989.
-
544Robert Richards, Darwin and the Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior Reviewed byPhilosophy in Review 8 (7): 285-287. 1988.
-
93A Course in the History and Philosophy of Mathematics from a Naturalistic PerspectiveTeaching Philosophy 14 (4): 375-388. 1991.This article describes .a course in the philosophy of mathematics that compares various metaphysical and epistemological theories of mathematics with portions of the history of the development of mathematics, in particular, the history of calculus.
-
5Operant Learning and the Scientific and Philosophical Foundations of Behavior TherapyBehaviorism 11 (2): 155-161. 1983.The continuing and expanding successes of behavior therapy in the treatment of psychological problems raise important questions about their scientific and philosophical bases. In this paper I examine the claims of Edward Erwin that behaviorism cannot provide an adequate philosophical basis for behavior therapy, contemporary learning theories which exclude cognitive factors as causes of behavior cannot provide an adequate empirical basis for behavior therapy; and learning theories have played onl…Read more
-
53It's been a pleasure, but that's not why I did it. Are Sober and Wilson too generous toward their selfish brethren?Journal of Consciousness Studies 7 (1-2): 1-2. 2000.Sober and Wilson demonstrate convincingly the fallacies of arguments for fundamental biological and psychological selfishness and establish the plausibility of both biological and psychological altruism. However, I suggest that they are more generous to proponents of fundamental selfishness than they need be and that morality is closer to our evolved and learned capacities than they suggest. I am less generous toward advocates of fundamental selfishness than are our altruistic authors.
-
299Why Wilfrid Sellars Is Right (and Right-Wing)Journal of Philosophical Research 36 291-325. 2011.Scholars of Wilfrid Sellars’s thought split into Right- and Left-wing Sellarsians. Right-wing Sellarsians urge Sellars’s scientific realism and the prominence of the scientific image of man in the synoptic vision. Left-wing Sellarsians emphasize the prominence of the logical space of reasons over that of causes, rejecting Sellars’s scientism. In his recent book James O’Shea attempts to reconcile these Sellarsian images, arguing that one best understands the Sellarsian synoptic image in terms of …Read more
-
135The Middle Does Not HoldJournal of Philosophical Research 36 361-369. 2011.This paper continues the dialogue between my right-wing-Sellars and James O’Shea’s middle-Sellars. In it, I reply to O’Shea’s middle-Sellars critique of my right-wing-Sellarsian criticism of his recent attempt (Wilfrid Sellars: Wilfrid Sellars: Naturalism with a Normative Turn) to develop an understanding of Sellars’s overall view that avoids the problems of both right and left-wing-Sellarsians. In his contribution to this issue O’Shea argues that Sellars follows a middle way between left and ri…Read more
-
92Discerning the Limits of Religious NaturalismZygon 36 (3): 467-475. 2001.In response to my “How to Make Naturalism Safe for Supernaturalism: An Evaluation of Willem Drees's Supernaturalistic Naturalism” (Rottschaefer 2001), Willem Drees maintains that I have misunderstood his purpose and views and have failed to make the case against his view that naturalism is intrinsically limited. In this response, I comment on these concerns.
-
84Singer, sociobiology, and values: Pure reason versus empirical reasonZygon 19 (2): 159-170. 1984.E. O. Wilson argues that we must use scientifically based reason to solve the values dilemma created by the loss of a transcendent foundation for values. Peter Singer allows that sociobiology can help us understand the evolutionary origin of ethics, but denies the claim that sociobiology or any science can furnish us with ultimate ethical principles. We argue that Singer's critique of Wilson's attempt to bridge the gap between fact and value using empirical reason is unconvincing and that Singer…Read more
-
76Biological and Physicochemical Explanations in Experimental BiologyBiological Theory 3 (4): 380-390. 2008.
-
72
-
646What can history tell us about founding ethics on biology?Biology and Philosophy 16 (1): 131-144. 2001.
-
118The insufficience of supervenient explanations of moral actions: Really taking Darwin and the naturalistic fallacy seriously (review)Biology and Philosophy 6 (4): 439-445. 1991.In a recent paper in this journal (Rottschaefer and Martinsen 1990) we have proposed a view of Darwinian evolutionary metaethics that we believe improves upon Michael Ruse's (e.g., Ruse 1986) proposals by claiming that there are evolutionary based objective moral values and that a Darwinian naturalistic account of the moral good in terms of human fitness can be given that avoids the naturalistic fallacy in both its definitional and derivational forms while providing genuine, even if limited, jus…Read more
-
Book reviews-the biology and psychology of moral agencyHistory and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 22 (3): 445-445. 2000.
-
338Really taking Darwin seriously: An alternative to Michael Ruse's Darwinian metaethics (review)Biology and Philosophy 5 (2): 149-173. 1990.Michael Ruse has proposed in his recent book Taking Darwin Seriously and elsewhere a new Darwinian ethics distinct from traditional evolutionary ethics, one that avoids the latter's inadequate accounts of the nature of morality and its failed attempts to provide a naturalistic justification of morality. Ruse argues for a sociobiologically based account of moral sentiments, and an evolutionary based casual explanation of their function, rejecting the possibility of ultimate ethical justification.…Read more
-
59The Moral Realism of Pragmatic NaturalismAnalyse & Kritik 34 (1): 141-156. 2012.In his The Ethical Project, Philip Kitcher offers a pragmatic naturalistic account of moral progress, rejecting a moral realist one. I suggest a moral realist account of moral progress that embraces Kitcher’s pragmatic naturalism and calls on moral realism to show how the pragmatic account is successful. To do so I invoke a hypothesis about moral affordances and make use of a cognitive account of emotions.
-
121Evolutionary Ethics: An Irresistible Temptation: Some Reflections on Paul Farber‘s The Temptation of Evolutionary Ethics (review)Biology and Philosophy 12 (3): 369-384. 1997.In his recent The Temptation of Evolutionary Ethics, Paul Farber has given a negative assessment of the last one hundred years of attempts in Anglo-American philosophy, beginning with Darwin, to develop an evolutionary ethics. Farber identifies some version of the naturalistic fallacy as one of the central sources for the failures of evolutionary ethics. For this reason, and others, Farber urges that though it has its attraction, evolutionary ethics is a temptation to be resisted. In this discus…Read more
-
91. Using as a model contemporary analyses of scientific cognition, Ian Harbour has claimed that religious cognition is neither immediate nor inferential but has the structure of interpreted experience. Although I contend that Barbour has failed to establish his claim, I believe his views about the similarities between scientific and religious cognition are well founded. Thus on that basis I offer an alternative proposal that theistic religious cognition is essentially inferential and that religio…Read more
-
109Naturalizing Ethics: the Biology and Psychology of Moral AgencyZygon 35 (2): 253-286. 2000.Moral agency is a central feature of both religious and secular conceptions of human beings. In this paper I outline a scientific naturalistic model of moral agency making use of current findings and theories in sociobiology,developmental psychology, and social cognitive theory. The model provides answers to four central questions about moral agency: what it is, how it is acquired, how it is put to work, and how it is justified. I suggest that this model can provide religious and secular moral t…Read more
-
87Gustafson's theocentrism and scientific naturalistic philosophy: A marriage made in heaven?Zygon 30 (2): 211-220. 1995.Examining James M. Gustafson's views on the relationships between the sciences, theology, and ethics from a scientifically based naturalistic philosophical perspective, I concur with his rejection of separatist and antagonistic interactionist positions and his adherence to a mutually supportive interactionist position with both descriptive and normative features. I next explore three aspects of this interactionism: religious empiricism, the connections between facts and values, and the centering…Read more
-
88In Augustinian fashion, James B. Ashbrook and Carol Rausch Albright develop a neurotheology that finds evolutionarily based correlations between the functions of the human mind‐brain and the roles God plays in human life. I argue that their assumptions of anthropomorphism, that the human mind‐brain must conceptualize its environment in human terms, and realism, that anthropomorphism is correct, are evolutionarily unlikely. I conclude that the image of God (imago dei) the authors find reflected i…Read more