Ian Rumfitt

According to Quine, in any disagreement over basic logical laws the contesting parties must mean different things by the connectives or quantifiers implicated in those laws; when a deviant logician ‘tries to deny the doctrine he only changes the subject’. The standard semantics for intuitionism offers some confirmation for this thesis, for it represents an intuitionist as attaching quite different senses to the connectives than does a classical logician. All the same, I think Quine was wrong, even about the dispute between classicists and intuitionists. I argue for this by presenting an account of consequence, and a cognate semantic theory for the language of the propositional calculus, which respects the meanings of the connectives as embodied in the familiar classical truth-tables, does not presuppose Bivalence, and with respect to which the rules of the intuitionist propositional calculus are sound and complete. Thus the disagreement between classicists and intuitionists, at least, need not stem from their attaching different senses to the connectives; one may deny the doctrine without changing the subject. The basic notion of my semantic theory is truth at a possibility, where a possibility is a way that things might be, but which differs from a possible world in that the way in question need not be fully specific or determinate. I compare my approach with a previous theory of truth at a possibility due to Lloyd Humberstone, and with a previous attempt to refute Quine’s thesis due to John McDowell

In his 'paratactic' analysis of indirect speech reports, Davidson took the occurrence of 'that' in 'Galileo said that the Earth moves' to be a demonstrative expression which refers to the reporter's subsequent utterance of 'the Earth moves'. Ian McFetridge used his 'counting problem' to argue that we get a better version of the paratactic theory if we take the demonstrative 'that' to refer to the proposition expressed by the reporter's utterance, rather than to the utterance itself. In this note, I defend McFetridge's argument against an objection of Richard Holton's.

The Logic of Gersonides, a Translation of Sefer ha‐Heggesh ha‐Yashar (The Book of the Correct Syllogism) of Rabbi Levi ben Gershom with Introduction, Commentary, and Analytical Glossary by Charles H. Manekin. New Synthese Historical Library, Vol. 40. Kluwer, Dordrecht, xii + 341 pp. ISBN 0–7923–1513–8 Luigi Firpo: Il processo di Giordano Bruno Rome (Salerno Editrice) 1993. pp. xxvii + 378. Hardback only: 44,000 liras. ISBN 88–8402–135–9. Anthony Kenny: Descartes. A Study of His Philosophy (Reissued Thoemmes Press, 1993) 256 pp. £9.99 ISBN 1 85506 236 4 A. John Simmons: The Lockean Theory of Rights Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1992 pp. ix, 387. £30.00. ISBN 0–691–08630–3 Ross Hutchison: Locke in France 1688–1734. The Voltaire Foundation, Oxford, 1991 (Studies on Voltaire and the Eighteenth Century, 290) pp. 251. £46.00. ISBN 0–7294–0418–8 Thomas Reid: Practical Ethics: Being Lectures and Tapers on Natural Religion, Self‐Government, Natural jurisprudence, and the Law of Nations Edited from the manuscripts with an Introduction and a Commentary by Knud Haakonssen. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1990. Pp. xvi + 556. £40.00. ISBN 0–691–07350–3 The Cambridge Companion to Kant ed. by Paul Guyer, Cambridge University Press, 1992. Pp. xii + 482 £40 hardback, £12.95 paperback. ISBN 0–521–36587–2 hardback, 0–521–36768–9 paperback. Gerd Buchdahl: Kant and the Dynamics of Reason Oxford: Blackwell. 1992. pp. x + 371 A. Bowie: Schelling and Modern European Philosophy: An Introduction Routledge: London and New York, 1993. Pp. 211. £37.50 hb. £11.99 pb. ISBN 0–415–10346–0 (hb), 0–415–10347–9 (pb) Miszellen zu Nietzsche. Versuche von operationalen Auslegungen von Jean‐Pierre Schobinger, Basel: Schwabe & Co. AG, 1992, 151 Seiten David Boucher and Andrew Vincent: A Radical Hegelian. The Political and Social Philosophy of Henry Jones Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 1993. Pp. x + 267. £35.00. ISBN 0–7083–1207–1 J. Alberto Coffa: The Semantic Tradition from Kant to Carnap: To the Vienna Station Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991, pbk. 1993, xii + 445 pp. £15.95. ISBN 0 521 44707 0.