-
19Philosophie als Wissenschaft (review)Review of Metaphysics 37 (2): 431-432. 1983.Topp undertakes a difficult task. In preparation for a study of the logic inherent in Hegel's Philosophy of Right, he explores in a wide-ranging discussion the systematic character of Hegel's philosophy as a whole. Thus no single question structures the book. Its argument is developed under three themes.
-
13Hegel's systematic contingencyPalgrave-Macmillan. 2007.John Burbidge shows that, far from incorporating everything into an all-consuming necessity, Hegel's philosophy requires the novelty of unexpected contingencies to maintain its systematic pretensions. To know without fear of failure is to expect that experience will confound our confident claims to knowledge. And the universal character of all life involves acting, discovering what happens as a result, and incorporating both intention and result into a new comprehensive understanding. Burbidge e…Read more
-
27
-
38The Logic of Hegel's 'Logic': An IntroductionBroadview Press. 2006.George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel has seldom been considered a major figure in the history of logic. His two texts on logic, both called The Science of Logic, both written in Hegel's characteristically dense and obscure language, are often considered more as works of metaphysics than logic. But in this highly readable book, John Burbidge sets out to reclaim Hegel's Science of Logic as logic and to get right at the heart of Hegel's thought. Burbidge examines the way Hegel moves from concept to conce…Read more
-
3Hegel In His Time (edited book)Broadview Press. 1995.Georg Wilhelm Freidrich Hegel is now recognized as one of the great philosophers; his concept of the dialectic profoundly influenced the course of Western thought, and—particularly through the lens of Marxist philosophy—continues to exert great influence even today. Yet Hegel himself has often been accused of being a philosopher of reaction: on the political sphere the polar opposite of Marx. It was not until the publication of Jacques D’Hondt’s _Hegel en son temps_ that the vision of Hegel as a…Read more
-
30Wissenschaft der Logik. Teil 1 - Die Objektive Logik; Band 1 (review)The Owl of Minerva 18 (1): 67-68. 1986.No one who wants seriously to understand Hegel’s larger Logic can afford to ignore this volume of the collected works. It stands out from all other editions of the German text for two significant reasons.
-
12The Self and its Body in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit (review)International Studies in Philosophy 36 (1): 279-280. 2004.
-
12Wissenschaft der Logik. Teil 1 - Die Objektive Logik; Band 1 (review)The Owl of Minerva 18 (1): 67-68. 1986.No one who wants seriously to understand Hegel’s larger Logic can afford to ignore this volume of the collected works. It stands out from all other editions of the German text for two significant reasons.
-
54The First Chapter of Hegel’s Larger LogicThe Owl of Minerva 21 (2): 177-183. 1990.Discussions of Hegel’s Logic often concentrate on the first chapter, which starts from pure being and ends with Dasein. Quite regularly commentators find the argument flawed; having thus disposed of its foundation, they dismiss the rest of the logic as equally unreliable.
-
67The Syllogisms of Revealed Religion, or the Reasonableness of ChristianityThe Owl of Minerva 18 (1): 29-42. 1986.For the Fnlightenment a continuing question was the reasonableness of Christianity. John Locke devoted a treatise to the question; and it lies at the core of Hume’s essay on miracles, of Lessing’s ugly broad ditch, and of Kant’s religion within the limits of reason alone.
-
55The “Infinite Agony” of SpiritThe Owl of Minerva 34 (2): 171-186. 2003.Hegel suggests that spirit, in contrast to animal nature, can encounter infinite agony in the death of what was its center, and yet, by dwelling with this loss, emerge into a new form of existence. The paradigm for this move is described toward the end of the chapter on Revealed Religion in the Phenomenology of Spirit. An analysis of the key paragraph introduces a discussion of four questions: Why is this experience triggered by the death of a mediator? What characterizes the spiritual metamorph…Read more
-
33Philosophy and the Absolute: The Modes of Hegel's SpeculationRobert Grant McRae Dordrecht: Nijhoff, 1985. Pp. ix, 188. $31.00 (review)Dialogue 26 (2): 385-386. 1987.
-
27Man, God, and death in Hegel's phenomenologyPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research 42 (2): 183-196. 1981.
-
23In Memory of Emil Ludwig Fackenheim, 1916–2003The Owl of Minerva 35 (1-2): 49-52. 2003.At a time when Hegel studies were virtually non-existent in North America, Emil Fackenheim began teaching at the University of Toronto, in a department strongly committed to the history of philosophy. He taught medieval philosophy to third-year students in the honours program, and a course on metaphysics and the philosophy of history to students in fourth year honors, a combination of interests that found expression in his Aquinas Lectures of 1961: Metaphysics and Historicity. It was, however, h…Read more
-
18In Memory of Emil Ludwig Fackenheim, 1916–2003The Owl of Minerva 35 (1-2): 49-52. 2003.At a time when Hegel studies were virtually non-existent in North America, Emil Fackenheim began teaching at the University of Toronto, in a department strongly committed to the history of philosophy. He taught medieval philosophy to third-year students in the honours program, and a course on metaphysics and the philosophy of history to students in fourth year honors, a combination of interests that found expression in his Aquinas Lectures of 1961: Metaphysics and Historicity. It was, however, h…Read more
-
44Hegel on Logic and Religion: The Reasonableness of Christianity (edited book)State University of New York Press. 1992.The 13 essays, most previously published, discuss his logical theory, his applications in general, and his applications to Christianity. Paper edition (unseen), $14.95. Annotation copyrighted by Book News, Inc., Portland, OR
-
17Hegel's Science of Logic: A Critical Rethinking in Thirty Lectures, by Richard Dien Winfield.: Book Reviews (review)Mind 122 (488): 1213-1215. 2013.
-
21Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit (review)International Studies in Philosophy 35 (4): 248-250. 2003.
-
49Hegel in CanadaThe Owl of Minerva 25 (2): 215-219. 1994.Over the years, in various journals, I have seen lengthy articles about Hegelianism in Poland, in Japan, or in Holland. Never, however, have I seen anything about Hegel studies in Canada. In Europe, for example, anglophone Canadians are simply identified with Americans. On the other hand, in the membership list of the Hegel Society of America, Canadians are lumped together with all the others “outside the U.S.A.”—this despite the fact that three times over the past thirteen biennia Canadians hav…Read more
-
10Hegel’s Quest for Certainty (review)The Owl of Minerva 17 (1): 55-58. 1985.This is a good book. The quality of Flay’s analysis grows on the reader as he moves from the introductory comments, through the discussions of self-consciousness, reason, and spirit. We have here an interpretation of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit which does justice to the Hegelian project and at the same time renders most, if not all, of the standard criticisms ineffective. But it is not just a new reading of a work which has challenged many commentators of the past and present. In addition th…Read more
-
54Hegel and his Critics (review)The Owl of Minerva 22 (2): 227-228. 1991.The essays in this volume do more than simply conjoin Hegel with his critics. There is a full-fledged debate: on occasion the critics gain the upper hand; far more often Hegel rises from the dead to defeat, by anticipation, his opponents.
-
3Hegel and his Critics (review)The Owl of Minerva 22 (2): 227-228. 1991.The essays in this volume do more than simply conjoin Hegel with his critics. There is a full-fledged debate: on occasion the critics gain the upper hand; far more often Hegel rises from the dead to defeat, by anticipation, his opponents.
-
42Hegel (review)The Owl of Minerva 17 (1): 92-94. 1985.In the conclusion to his long book on Hegel, Michael Inwood cites a passage describing the way Stephen Spender’s tutors approached the study of philosophy: “This might be described as the Obstacle Race way of teaching philosophy. The whole field of human thought is set out with logical obstacles and the students watch the philosophers race around it.” Inwood mentions it because “it represents … one of the ways in which we should not treat Hegel - disqualifying him from the race altogether on acc…Read more
-
23G.W.F. Hegel: Gesammelte Werke. Band 11 (review)The Owl of Minerva 10 (4): 5-6. 1979.When he died in 1831, Hegel had just completed a revision of the first Book of the Science of Logic, “The Doctrine of Being”. Since the revised edition has been consistently used in subsequent printing, the first edition disappeared from view, to surface again only in 1966 when Vanderhoeck and Ruprecht of Gottingen published a facsimile reprint. Along with the never-revised “Doctrine of Essence” of 1813, that original text of Book I has now received elegant treatment in volume 11 of the critical…Read more