-
A Primer for Philosophers of MindBoD · Books on Demand GmbH. 2026.This book does not begin where philosophy of mind usually begins. It begins neither with qualia nor with zombies, neither with the hard problem nor with the question of whether consciousness is reducible to brain processes. It begins with the question of what life is. Proceeding reconstructively, it starts from the simplest process that maintains itself, a self-producing network of chemical reactions, and follows the consequences step by step: operational closure, endogenous production of substa…Read more
-
Category errors as a structural principle of philosophyZenodo. 2025.This paper identifies and analyzes systematic category mistakes that pervade classical and contemporary philosophical debates from antiquity to the present, structuring discussions in ontology, epistemology, philosophy of mind, and ethics. Six fundamental types of category errors are distinguished: ambiguity of central concepts; conflation of descriptive levels; substantive reification of processes; confusion of syntax with semantics; ungrounded metaphysical assumptions; and ontologization of no…Read more
-
Beyond Gödelian LimitsZenodo. 2026.Gödel's incompleteness theorems demonstrate fundamental limitations of formal systems: no sufficiently powerful consistent system can prove its own consistency. This insight is often interpreted as limiting all forms of systematic self-reference. This article develops an alternative perspective by introducing a dimensional epistemology that distinguishes between different modes of cognitive processing. It is argued that Gödel's results pertain specifically to formal self-reference (Dimension 2),…Read more
-
How the World Becomes Present for a Living BeingZenodo. 2026.Consciousness is approached here as feeling, experiencing, and being there: the felt presence of a living organism within which attention, reflection, and cognitive activities occur. The article develops a biological reconstruction of the conditions under which this state could have taken shape, followed by a philosophical interpretation of its character. It starts from two features of human experience: temporal continuity and wholeness. Seeing, hearing, bodily feeling, and thinking remain disti…Read more
-
This work develops a unified theory of valence as a scale-spanning organizational principle from quantum chemistry to political ideology. Valence is defined as preferential stabilization - a mechanism that begins with energetic preferences in chemical bonds and continues through biochemical affinities and neuromodulatory signaling to cognitive evaluation processes. The central thesis states that ideological beliefs emerge and are stabilized through the same valence-based weighting mechanisms tha…Read more
-
The standard neuroscientific account of the placebo effect identifies the neurochemical systems involved but fails to explain the constitutive transition from semantic context to physiological cascade. The dominant explanatory concept—expectation—does not resolve this gap; it merely relabels the explanandum. This paper proposes an alternative framework based on the theory of autocatalytic organization, drawing on the formal work of Rosen, Kauffman, and Montévil/Mossio. In an autocatalytically or…Read more
-
The Physical Infrastructure of ExperienceZenodo. 2026.Contemporary theories of consciousness share a common methodological deficit: they describe functional correlates of experience without determining the structural conditions under which experience as such becomes possible at all. The present article develops a framework for the physical infrastructure of experience, the set of necessary structural conditions, not sufficient causal mechanisms, that a physical system must satisfy in order to make phenomenal experience possible. Drawing on the theo…Read more
-
The Operator That Cannot Place ItselfZenodo. 2026.Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi's 1787 objection to Kant's transcendental idealism identified a structural problem that remains unresolved in the tradition of nested ontological frameworks: any system that posits causal relations between distinct ontological levels requires an operator to mediate those relations, but this operator cannot itself be ontologically located without generating an infinite regress. We argue that this problem is not peripheral to Kant's system but constitutive of it, and that…Read more
-
The mechanism of phenomenal experienceZenodo. 2026.The essay develops a reconstructive systems theory of consciousness based on the causal self-closure of biological systems. Consciousness is not understood as a property or effect, but as the epistemic form that inevitably arises when the causal structure of a system is completely self-contained. Physical, biological and phenomenal descriptions are epistemically autonomous forms of reconstruction that are structurally irreducible to each other. There is no translation relation between them, beca…Read more
-
The Functionalist TrilemmaZenodo. 2026.Functionalism is among the most influential positions in the philosophy of mind. Its central idea is that mental states are determined not by their material constitution but by their functional or causal role. This gives rise to the possibility of multiple realization: if the same functional organization can be realized in biological and artificial systems, then, in principle, the same mental states should also be possible in different material substrates. This paper argues that this inference d…Read more
-
The Invariance TrapZenodo. 2026.Philosophical fallacies arise not only from false premises or ambiguous words. They can also arise when an expression, a function, a structure, or a description is transferred from one context to another. In such transformations, something is typically preserved while something else changes. This paper calls a property invariant relative to a particular transformation when it is preserved across that transition. Depending on the case, what remains invariant may be a linguistic expression, a sema…Read more
-
The Emergence of Causal CoresZenodo. 2025.This article argues that the emergence of causal cores results from fundamental physical and biological principles. The argumentation proceeds in several interconnected steps: First, the thermodynamic framework is outlined, then the biological concretization is analyzed, followed by consideration of information-theoretic aspects, and finally discussion of evolutionary implications.
-
The Causal Core as a Structural Principle of Free WillZenodo. 2025.The debate on free will remains shaped by metaphysical speculation, reductionist simplifications, and categorical misunderstandings. While classical philosophy often conceived it as a gift of divine grace or the expression of rational autonomy, modern neuroscience and cognitive models tend to deny freedom in favor of deterministic or probabilistic causal chains. This article advances the thesis that the capacity for intentional action is not rooted in an immaterial will, but in a structural cent…Read more
-
This article develops the thesis that living systems form a centralist internal asymmetry from their very first appearance, a structure I refer to as the causal core. This core is not a morphological compartment and not a localisable site. It is a functional attractor that emerges from superposed thermodynamic flows within an operationally closed space, constitutes itself in the prokaryotic cell, and recurs in formally invariant fashion at every higher organisational level of the living. The art…Read more
-
The Biological Foundation of the SoulZenodo. 2026.The soul has an image problem. Anyone who mentions it today in a scientific conversation can expect, at best, an indulgent smile. The concept is considered obsolete, a relic of a pre-scientific era in which whatever could not be explained was given a name, and the name was then mistaken for an explanation. And yet the question behind the concept never disappeared. What is it that makes an organism a subject? What is that inner point from which a being acts, perceives, and refers to itself? Scien…Read more
-
This article proposes a system-theoretical and thermodynamically based model for the solution of the so-called 'Hard Problem of Consciousness'. Instead of asking why neuronal processes generate subjective experience, it is shown that consciousness can be understood as the structural result of a causal collapse in self-organizing systems. The reasoning develops along three evolutionary thresholds: autopoiesis, causal poiesis, and causal collapse. Consciousness does not appear as a property, but a…Read more
-
Physics of Organismic StorageZenodo. 2025.Current neuroscientific models of memory usually view memory as a function, for example as a reactivation of earlier activation patterns, as a symbolic encoding, or as the recognition of stored content. In this perspective, memory is primarily understood as a functional change in state or as the re-availability of semantic or sensory information that is stabilized by synaptic plasticity or molecular modulation. What is usually missing is a physically sound description of what "storage" actually …Read more
-
The question of consciousness remains one of the central challenges of philosophy and the interdisciplinary sciences. Phenomenological approaches – especially in the tradition of Edmund Husserl and its further developments in the 20th and 21st centuries – have chosen an approach that refers strictly to experience itself. They try to grasp consciousness as a structure of appearance and to assert it against naturalistic reductions. This essay presents an alternative theory: the model of causal col…Read more
-
Perturbation, Integration, Possibility SpaceZenodo. 2026.Neo-Darwinism describes the filter, not the structure of what gets filtered. It does not explain why highly adaptive phenomena occur: coherent, rapid adaptations across multiple traits simultaneously, which random search in the entire possibility space could not achieve. This paper develops an alternative framework. The central thesis is that autocatalytic systems generate, through their history of perturbations, a structured, non-uniformly distributed variation space whose topology makes certai…Read more
-
Perspective Ontology and Dimensional LogicZenodo. 2026.The present work develops an ontological foundation for dimensional logic (Stegemann, 2025a) that goes beyond its formal architecture. The starting point is a critique of Kant's concept of the thing-in-itself, which is rejected as a substance-realistic stage metaphor. In its place is a perspectival entity ontology: each entity constitutes its world through its own structural properties; there is no reality transcendent beyond these constitutional achievements. This position is shown as an episte…Read more
-
The nervous system invents no new evolutionary mechanism. It accelerates and complexifies an existing one. The first paper in this series showed that autocatalytic systems generate, through their history of perturbations, a structured variation space whose topology makes certain variations more probable than others. The present paper extends this thesis to the level of neural systems. The nervous system is not a fourth inheritance system in Jablonka's sense, but a possibility-space generator ope…Read more
-
Models and the test of consciousnessZenodo. 2025.For decades, new theories have been emerging that want to explain what consciousness is. They speak of information integration (Tononi, 2004, 2015), of global availability (Baars, 1988; Dehaene, 2014), recursive predictions (Friston, 2010) or phenomenological structures (Varela, Thompson & Rosch, 1991). Their common conviction is that consciousness can be explained by certain dynamics and forms of organization. But the crucial question remains: How could we tell that such a model not only sounds…Read more
-
Methodology of Consciousness TheoryZenodo. 2026.Consciousness research suffers from a methodological and categorical double deficit. While the natural sciences explicitly discuss and justify their methods, consciousness research lacks systematic methodological reflection. This methodological deficit is functionally related to a basic categorical error: the confusion of epistemic levels of description with ontological entities. This level confusion results in three pseudo-problems, which are treated as central research questions, namely the bo…Read more
-
Integrated model of causal collapseZenodo. 2025.This model assumes that consciousness arises when a recursive system loses its causal separability. The so-called causal collapse describes the transition in which disjoint causal partitioning of the system is no longer possible. Through a corresponding measure of causal entanglement (Σ) and its complement (Ω), consciousness is formally described as a gradual phenomenon that can be modeled across different biological and artificial systems.
-
From the Transcendental Subject to the Causal CoreZenodo. 2025.The relationship between subject and object has been the crystallization point of consciousness research since transcendental philosophy. From Kant to Husserl, attempts were made to understand the conditions of the possibility of knowledge from the structure of the subject. However, with the transition to empirical neuroscience, this question has not disappeared, but has merely been transformed. The transcendental framework continues to have an effect – as an implicit prerequisite of many theori…Read more
-
In earlier work, the phylogenetic sequence from autocatalytic autopoiesis through the causal core and electrification to defactorization was developed as a reconstructive derivation of the biological conditions of phenomenal consciousness. Non-factorizability appears there as the result of the fourth tipping point, criticality as its physical realization condition. The present article shows that both properties follow the same logic in the scaling sequence: they are present in autopoietic system…Read more
-
From Principle to Function: The Causal Core in the BrainZenodo. 2025.The theory of the causal core describes a centristic-causalistic principle that emerges as a universal structural form in open, dynamic systems. This principle is not a material object, but rather a systemic necessity that, under certain conditions, leads to the formation of a central integration mechanism. In biological evolution, this mechanism has manifested as the cell nucleus and later as the brain. This essay investigates how this causal structural principle is concretely realized in the b…Read more
-
From Autopoiesis to EnactionZenodo. 2026.This paper reconstructs a conceptual shift from the original theory of autopoiesis to later enactive approaches to cognition and experience. The central claim is that the transition is not a straightforward deduction from autopoiesis. Maturana’s identification of life with cognition expands the concept of cognition from the outset. Later developments add embodied action, autonomy, adaptivity, agency, sense-making, and first-person experience. Each addition addresses a genuine problem, but the se…Read more
-
From 2D Object Space to 3D Perspective StructureZenodo. 2026.This paper addresses the structural conditions under which objectivity can emerge when multiple perspectives are present. Standard approaches typically presuppose a shared object space and treat differences between observers as secondary deviations. This working paper suspends that assumption and formalizes the transition from a two-dimensional object space to a three-dimensional perspective structure. The formalization introduces a perspective group that acts on objects, allowing perspective-in…Read more
-
Experience as Self-ReferenceZenodo. 2026.The present article advances a physical identity principle for consciousness: experience is not produced by, correlated with, or supervenient upon a specific class of physical states, it is identical with them. More precisely, experience is identical with endogenously generated, self-sustaining self-reference of the kind that autocatalytic systems necessarily instantiate when the infrastructure conditions identified in Stegemann (2026) are satisfied. This identity is not a contingent empirical f…Read more