• The right to protest ≠ the right to specific protest methods. Prohibiting blocking highways doesn’t infringe the right to protest. Extending Parliament Square restrictions may infringe this right. The Home Secretary’s power to define "serious disruption" is risky. The "serious disruption" threshold may be set too high. Lowering it to "more than minor" was rightly struck down. Scaling police powers to disruption severity is preferable. Disruption targeting essential services warrants firmer inter…Read more
  • Fiscal Devolution in England (FDE0004)
    House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee. 2026.
    Devolution’s aims can conflict: growth vs fairness vs legitimacy. Accountability needs electoral salience, not just structures. Distributional questions require a prior normative standard. What are citizens owed regardless of where they live? Equalization is a value judgement, not a technical fix. Legitimacy and accountability must precede fiscal autonomy. Scrutiny and accountability aren’t the same thing. Fiscal power needs stronger local standards frameworks. Decentralisation ≠ devolution: the…Read more
  • Retirement and Participation (RAP0009)
    House of Lords Retirement and Participation Committee. 2026.
    Any reform must achieve the purposes of the House of Lords. This inquiry shouldn’t aim to reduce the size of the membership. Peers must participate in the House of Lords to achieve its aims. Some peers should participate less often and more meaningfully. A participation requirement would have many perverse effects. A peer’s expertise must be prioritized over their participation. A token 10% participation requirement eliminates honorary peers. Mandatory retirements robs the House of Lords of its …Read more
  • Equality at Work: Flexible Working and Disability (FWD0023)
    House of Commons Women and Equalities Committee. 2026.
    Employment Rights Act destigmatizes "reasonable adjustments". However, it doesn’t meaningfully guarantee such adjustments: minor inconveniences qualify as a "detrimental impact" and adjustments can’t be discussed during job applications. EHRC enforcement relies on individuals coming forward: small disciplines mean complaints risk reputational harm and early-career employees fear non-renewal of contracts. Tribunal anonymity orders show a precedent for protection. Unclear overlap between Access to…Read more
  • Modernising Elections (MEL0146)
    House of Commons Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee. 2026.
    Lowering the voting age requires a clearer principled justification. Quality of democratic engagement matters, not just its quantity. Votes by 16-18-tear-olds are less informed on average. Under 18s risk coercion from parents, giving parents extra votes. Partisan electoral reform undermines trust in democratic institutions. Misinformation is entrenched; suppression risks free speech harms. Improving public reasoning is preferable to a Ministry of Truth. Honesty and objectivity are already two of…Read more
  • The Use of Artificial Intelligence and EdTech in Education (AIE0085)
    with Ching-Yuen Cheung and Shigeru Taguchi
    House of Commons Education Committee. 2026.
    AI offers major benefits: faster research and new pedagogy. Prohibitive AI policies in universities are misguided. Lack of national guidance has led to inconsistent institutional policies. Standard essays no longer reliably evidence student capability. AI is like calculators – adapt pedagogy, don’t resist the technology. Deskilling concerns are overstated; AI use is a skill itself. Access is deeply unequal; top platforms cost ~$200/month. Universities should adopt institutional AI subscriptions.…Read more
  • Realising Potential: Delivering the Child Poverty Strategy (CPS0031)
    House of Commons Education Committee and Work and Pensions Committee. 2026.
    Government lacks a coherent theory of what poverty is. Contradictory policies lead to fiscal recklessness. There are three main questions the strategy doesn’t answer: Is poverty caused structurally or individually? Is poverty material deprivation or low relative income? Are children the responsibility of parents or the state? The Child Poverty Strategy requires a sharper theory of poverty. Choose one primary metric and organize around it. Prioritize structural or individual interventions. Define…Read more
  • Childhood Vaccinations (CVX0008)
    House of Lords Childhood Vaccinations Committee. 2026.
    Merely making vaccination more trustworthy won’t increase trust. Trustworthy science isn’t always trusted by the public. Increasing trustworthiness can paradoxically decrease trust. Policymakers shouldn’t rely on their intuition to increase trust. Trust in vaccines is predicated on trust in science and government. Strengthening trust is a whole-of-government project. Official media must be held accountable, not just social media. Communication should be apolitical; don’t appeal to values. Misinf…Read more
  • National Resilience (NLR0070)
    House of Lords National Resilience Committee. 2026.
    Public trust is a precondition for national resilience. Low trust prevents "fast policy" and slows disaster response. The pandemic showed that trust directly predicted compliance. Vaccine hesitancy clustered in low-trust communities. Low trust forces costly coercion and enforcement measures. Trustworthiness doesn’t automatically produce trust. Transparency measures can paradoxically reduce public trust. Official communication must be objective and honest. Misinformation is best tackled by buildi…Read more
  • Road Safety Strategy (RSS0067)
    House of Commons Transport Committee. 2026.
    Evidence quality is inconsistent throughout the strategy. Vision Zero language is invoked but abandoned via 65% target. The 65% target lacks transparent modelling or derivation. The 70% child casualty sub-target has no coherent justification. Roadside eyesight test license revocation is disproportionate. There should be a 28-day remediation window before revocation. Expanding GP reporting duties risks losing trust in medicine. Minimum learning periods proxy competence poorly. Successful implemen…Read more
  • Student Loans and Taxation of Graduates (SLTG0279)
    House of Commons Treasury Committee. 2026.
    Low-income students pay 5x more than wealthy peers. 6% interest can inflate £100k debt to £570k over 30 years. The current system is regressive and undermines fairness. Above-inflation interest is unjustifiable for a welfare state. Government acts inconsistently as lender and welfare provider. Interest-free loans should target high-performing students. Introduce a public-private hybrid funding model. Limit funded places tied to potential and national priorities. This reduces over-enrolment and b…Read more
  •  1
    Innovation in the NHS: Personalised Medicine and AI (PMA0011)
    House of Lords Science and Technology Committee. 2026.
    Public trust in medical AI can’t be fixed by better governance alone. Trust and trustworthiness are causally distinct. Transparency can paradoxically decrease public trust in medicine. AI is the latest chapter in a long crisis of institutional trust. AI is blurring the line between clinical tool and decisionmaker. Accountability for AI-assisted harm is unresolved. This is exactly the kind of bad news that decreases public trust. The NHS oversells AI, setting up a steeper trust collapse later. Th…Read more
  • The Work and Performance of the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman (WPHS0020)
    House of Commons Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee. 2026.
    AI can assist with triage without replacing human judgment. Algorithmic bias must be benchmarked against human bias. Human caseworkers must be responsible for PHSO decisions. Efficiency gains should be reinvested in shorter waiting times. AI adoption should not justify cutting headcount. PHSO needs a bespoke AI system to address privacy concerns. Complains should not be uploaded into commercial tools. Publish a plain-language AI policy accessible to all complainants. KPI: case allocation reduced…Read more
  •  1
    Settlement, Citizenship and Integration (SCI0303)
    House of Lords Justice and Home Affairs Committee. 2026.
    Contribution to GDP is not a sufficient contribution. Stricter vetting criteria help to ensure immigrants contribute. Longer routes to settlement harm citizens with foreign spouses. Spouses of citizens should be exempt from the NHS surcharge. Spouses of citizens be exempt from income requirements.
  • Egg Donation and Freezing (EDF0056)
    House of Commons Women and Equalities Committee. 2026.
    UK donors receive £750 as compensation, not payment. Compensation acknowledges burden without coercing donors. Payment would increase supply but exploit vulnerable women. Donor protection outweighs recipient benefit. Recipients have alternatives (adoption, fostering). The current compensation model is the morally preferred solution.
  • The Seventh Carbon Budget (SCB0025)
    House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee. 2025.
  • Future of UK Aid and Development Assistance (UKA0171)
    House of Commons International Development Committee. 2025.
  • Propriety, Ethics and the Wider Standards Landscape in the UK (PEW0015)
    House of Commons Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee. 2025.
  • UK Research and Innovation (UKRI0007)
    House of Commons Public Accounts Committee. 2025.
  • Electronic Voting (EVO005)
    House of Commons Procedures Committee. 2025.
  • Home-Based Working (HBW0055)
    House of Lords Home-Based Working Committee. 2025.
  • A Contractarian Theory of Workplace Justice
    Journal of Markets and Morality 28 (1): 116-129. 2026.
    This study addresses the attainability of a just workplace. It begins by defining justice in contractarian terms: A just workplace is one in which (1) workers’ human rights are respected and (2) they are not coerced to do anything outside of their contract of employment. On this interpretation, workplace justice is easily attainable and is often achieved in workplaces around the world. This study then turns to the question of why, if it is possible for them to be just and equitable spaces, workp…Read more
  •  63
    How to Philosophize Like an Academic
    Metaphilosophy 57 (1-2): 55-60. 2026.
    How to write a philosophy paper? This paper seeks to answer that question. It proposes a progressive six-stage methodology for developing philosophical research, each step building in more rigorous forms of peer scrutiny: (1) independent ideation; (2) conceptualization and casual discussion; (3) short abstract and work-in-progress seminars; (4) referenced abstract and conference presentations; (5) first draft and written peer feedback; and (6) second draft and formal peer review. This framework …Read more
  • A recent survey of more than 1600 researchers spanning 111 countries found that over half of respondents reported using artificial intelligence (AI) in peer review. A majority of these stated they used AI to assist with drafting peer review reports, while significant minorities reported using AI to summarise findings, detect plagiarism or assess methodology or statistical soundness of manuscript. What should journal editors do when they receive an AI-generated review? There is little guidance. I…Read more
  • Political Polarization of Trust in Science
    Public Understanding of Science 35 (8): 1032-1040. 2026.
    Contrary to widespread claims of a crisis in public trust in science, this article argues that recent pandemic-era trends reflect a long-term pattern of bilateral political polarization rather than a universal decline in scientific confidence. Recent empirical data show that trust and distrust in science have both increased – producing an apparent “pandemic paradox” – driven by ideological bias operating within gaps in public understanding. The study identifies a misunderstanding of how science …Read more
  • Patients Might Distrust Honest Doctors
    Journal of Hospital Medicine 21 (10): 1191-1193. 2026.
    Evidence-based medicine revolutionized clinical practice, bringing expectations that physician–patient communication should be similarly transparent about scientific evidence and uncertainty. However, the replication crisis has revealed significant weaknesses in biomedical research. This creates something of a paradox: honest disclosure of uncertainty is ethically obligatory but often breeds patient distrust rather than confidence. This commentary argues that trust in medicine requires systemic …Read more
  • People Trust Medicine Too Much
    History and Philosophy of Medicine 8 (2): 11. 2026.
  • Public Support for Science Might Worsen Policy
    Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 53 (4): 309-310. 2025.
    Evidence-based policy has become the gold standard for trustworthy governance, yet the relationship between trust and trustworthiness in science-policy interactions is more complex than commonly assumed. This letter argues that increased public trust in science may undermine policy quality because of policy-based evidence-making–the selective use of scientific evidence to justify predetermined political decisions. Drawing on political science literature and Britain’s experience with evidence-bas…Read more
  • Surveys of the Scientific Community on the Existence of Extraterrestrial Life
    with Peter Vickers, Emma Gardiner, Catherine Gillen, Cyrille Jeancolas, Samantha Mitchell Finnigan, Julie Nekola Nováková, Henning Strandin, Ufuk Tasdan, Henry Taylor, and Sean McMahon
    Nature Astronomy 9 (1): 16-18. 2025.
    During February–June 2024 we conducted four surveys among researchers regarding the likely existence of basic, complex, and intelligent extraterrestrial life. Our results offer a snapshot of community opinion and reveal a significant degree of consensus that extraterrestrial life is likely to exist.