-
141Still Living Without Identity: Reply to TruemanAustralasian Journal of Philosophy 92 (1): 173-175. 2014.In ‘Eliminating Identity: A Reply to Wehmeier’, Robert Trueman attacks my claim that a commitment to a binary relation of identity is logically unnecessary and philosophically undesirable. I show that his two most serious objections are unconvincing.
-
60On Ramsey's 'Silly Delusion' Regarding Tractatus 5.53In Giuseppe Primiero (ed.), Acts of Knowledge: History, Philosophy and Logic, College Publications. 2009.We investigate a variant of the variable convention proposed at Tractatus 5.53ff for the purpose of eliminating the identity sign from logical notation. The variant in question is what Hintikka has called the strongly exclusive interpretation of the variables, and turns out to be what Ramsey initially (and erroneously) took to be Wittgenstein's intended method. We provide a tableau calculus for this identity-free logic, together with soundness and completeness proofs, as well as a proof of mutua…Read more
-
294Frege’s permutation argument revisitedSynthese 147 (1): 43-61. 2005.In Section 10 of Grundgesetze, Volume I, Frege advances a mathematical argument (known as the permutation argument), by means of which he intends to show that an arbitrary value-range may be identified with the True, and any other one with the False, without contradicting any stipulations previously introduced (we shall call this claim the identifiability thesis, following Schroeder-Heister (1987)). As far as we are aware, there is no consensus in the literature as to (i) the proper inte…Read more
-
157Subjunctivity and cross-world predicationPhilosophical Studies 159 (1): 107-122. 2012.The main goal of this paper is to present and compare two approaches to formalizing cross-world comparisons like John might have been taller than he is in quantified modal logics. One is the standard method employing degrees and graded positives, according to which the example just given is to be paraphrased as something like The height that John has is such that he might have had a height greater than it, which is amenable to familiar formalization strategies with respect to quantified modal lo…Read more
-
29The Proof of Hume’s PrincipleIn Philip A. Ebert & Marcus Rossberg (eds.), Essays on Frege's Basic Laws of Arithmetic, Oxford University Press. pp. 182-206. 2019.Beginning in _Grundgesetze_ §53, Frege presents proofs of a set of theorems known to encompass the Peano-Dedekind axioms for arithmetic. The initial part of Frege’s deductive development of arithmetic, to theorems (32) and (49), contains fully formal proofs that had merely been sketched out in _Grundlagen_. Theorems (32) and (49) are significant because they are the right-to-left and left-to-right directions respectively of what we call today “Hume’s Principle” (HP). The core observation that we…Read more
-
49Fragments of [mathematical formula] based on [mathematical formula]-inductionArchive for Mathematical Logic 36 (1). 1997.
-
161On the relations between Heinrich Scholz and Jan ŁukasiewiczHistory and Philosophy of Logic 28 (1): 67-81. 2007.The aim of the present study is (1) to show, on the basis of a number of unpublished documents, how Heinrich Scholz supported his Warsaw colleague Jan ?ukasiewicz, the Polish logician, during World War II, and (2) to discuss the efforts he made in order to enable Jan ?ukasiewicz and his wife Regina to move from Warsaw to Münster under life-threatening circumstances. In the first section, we explain how Scholz provided financial help to ?ukasiewicz, and we also adduce evidence of the risks incurr…Read more
-
32Frege’s Begriffsschrift Theory of Identity VindicatedIn Ernie Lepore & David Sosa (eds.), Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Language, Volume 1, Oxford University Press. pp. 122-147. 2019.In the _Begriffsschrift_, Frege held that identity is a relation between names, to wit, the relation of co-reference. The verdict of Frege scholarship on this conception of identity has not been favorable, to say the least; indeed, commentators including Alonzo Church, Michael Dummett, and Richard Heck have claimed that it is incompatible with ordinary first-order quantification. We show that these commentators are mistaken. The _Begriffsschrift_ conception of identity is perfectly consistent wi…Read more
-
71How Tarskian are Carnap's Semantics?History and Philosophy of Logic 47 (1): 148-166. 2026.It is a commonplace of the history of analytic philosophy that Carnap swiftly adopted Tarskian semantics in the mid-1930s. There is no doubt that, in a very general sense, this is true. But to what extent are the innovative technical details characteristic of Tarski's method, specifically the handling of quantification by way of a satisfaction relation between formulas and variable assignments, reflected in Carnap's writings on semantics? Curiously enough, their essentials are in place just befo…Read more
-
279On the consistency of the Δ11-CA fragment of Frege's GrundgesetzeJournal of Philosophical Logic 31 (4): 301-311. 2002.It is well known that Frege's system in the Grundgesetze der Arithmetik is formally inconsistent. Frege's instantiation rule for the second-order universal quantifier makes his system, except for minor differences, full (i.e., with unrestricted comprehension) second-order logic, augmented by an abstraction operator that abides to Frege's basic law V. A few years ago, Richard Heck proved the consistency of the fragment of Frege's theory obtained by restricting the comprehension schema to predicat…Read more