-
191The Scaling of Speeds and Distances in Galileo’s Two New Sciences: A reply to Palmerino and LairdCentaurus 54 (2): 182-191. 2012.In this reply, we respond to the comments of Palmerino and Laird on our article, "Galileo's Refutation of the Speed Distance Law of Fall Rehabilitated," published in the same issue of Centaurus.
-
183Time ReversalIn Eleanor Knox & Alastair Wilson (eds.), The Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Physics, Routledge. 2022.This article deals with the question of what time reversal means. It begins with a presentation of the standard account of time reversal, with plenty of examples, followed by a popular non-standard account. I argue that, in spite of recent commentary to the contrary, the standard approach to the meaning of time reversal is the only one that is philosophically and physically viable. The article concludes with a few open research problems about time reversal.
-
913Time-energy uncertainty does not create particlesJournal of Physics 1638 012005. 2020.In this contribution in honour of Paul Busch, we criticise the claims of many expositions that the time-energy uncertainty principle allows both a violation of energy conservation and particle creation, provided that this happens for a sufficiently short time. But we agree that there are grains of truth in these claims: which we make precise and justify using perturbation theory.
-
1065Reversing the arrow of timeCambridge University Press. 2022.'The arrow of time' refers to the curious asymmetry that distinguishes the future from the past. Reversing the Arrow of Time argues that there is an intimate link between the symmetries of 'time itself' and time reversal symmetry in physical theories, which has wide-ranging implications for both physics and its philosophy. This link helps to clarify how we can learn about the symmetries of our world, how to understand the relationship between symmetries and what is real, and how to overcome perv…Read more
-
351Galileo's refutation of the speed-distance law of fall rehabilitatedCentaurus 54 (2): 148-164. 2010.Galileo's refutation of the speed-distance law of fall in his Two New Sciences is routinely dismissed as a moment of confused argumentation. We urge that Galileo's argument correctly identified why the speed-distance law is untenable, failing only in its very last step. Using an ingenious combination of scaling and self-similarity arguments, Galileo found correctly that bodies, falling from rest according to this law, fall all distances in equal times. What he failed to recognize in the last ste…Read more
-
218I point out that some common folk wisdom about time reversal invariance in classical mechanics is strictly incorrect, by showing some explicit examples in which classical time reversal invariance fails, even among conservative systems. I then show that there is nevertheless a broad class of familiar classical systems that are time reversal invariant.
-
236Unreal observablesPhilosophy of Science 84 (5): 1265-1274. 2017.This note argues that quantum observables can include not just self-adjoint operators, but any member of the class of normal operators, including those with non-real eigenvalues. Concrete experiments, statistics, and symmetries are all expressed in this more general context. However, this more general class of observables also introduces a new restriction on which sets of operators can be interpreted as observables at once. These sets are referred to here as 'sharp sets.
-
317Three merry roads to T-violationStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 52 (Part A): 8-15. 2015.This paper is a tour of how the laws of nature can distinguish between the past and the future, or be T-violating. I argue that, in terms of the basic argumentative structure, there are basically just three approaches currently being explored. The first is an application of Curie's Principle, together with the CPT theorem. The second route makes use of a principle due to Pasha Kabir which allows for a direct detection. The third route makes use of a Non-degeneracy Principle, and is related to th…Read more
-
320Three myths about time reversal in quantum theoryPhilosophy of Science 84 (2): 315-334. 2017.Many have suggested that the transformation standardly referred to as `time reversal' in quantum theory is not deserving of the name. I argue on the contrary that the standard definition is perfectly appropriate, and is indeed forced by basic considerations about the nature of time in the quantum formalism.
-
98Regarding ‘Leibniz Equivalence’Foundations of Physics 50 (4): 250-269. 2020.Leibniz Equivalence is a principle of applied mathematics that is widely assumed in both general relativity textbooks and in the philosophical literature on Einstein’s hole argument. In this article, I clarify an ambiguity in the statement of this Leibniz Equivalence, and argue that the relevant expression of it for the hole argument is strictly false. I then show that the hole argument still succeeds as a refutation of manifold substantivalism; however, recent proposals that the hole argument i…Read more
-
245Observables, disassembledStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 63 150-162. 2018.How should we characterise the observable aspects of quantum theory? This paper argues that philosophers and physicists should jettison a standard dogma: that observables must be represented by self-adjoint or Hermitian operators. Four classes of non-standard observables are identified: normal operators, symmetric operators, real-spectrum operators, and none of these. The philosophical and physical implications of each are explored.
-
134New Perspectives on the Hole ArgumentFoundations of Physics 50 (4): 217-227. 2020.This special issue of Foundations of Physics collects together articles representing some recent new perspectives on the hole argument in the history and philosophy of physics. Our task here is to introduce those new perspectives.
-
568Group Structural RealismBritish Journal for the Philosophy of Science 62 (1): 47-69. 2010.We present a precise form of structural realism, called group structural realism , which identifies ‘structure’ in quantum theory with symmetry groups. However, working out the details of this view actually illuminates a major problem for structural realism; namely, a structure can itself have structure. This article argues that, once a precise characterization of structure is given, the ‘metaphysical hierarchy’ on which group structural realism rests is overly extravagant and ultimately unmotiv…Read more
-
447Comment on Ashtekar: generalization of Wigner's principleStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 52 21-23. 2015.Ashtekar has illustrated that two of the available roads to testing for time asymmetry can be generalized beyond the structure of quantum theory, to much more general formulations of mechanics. The purpose of this note is to show that a third road to T-violation, which I have called "Wigner's Principle," can be generalized in this way as well
-
421A General Perspective On Time ObservablesStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 47 50-54. 2014.I propose a general geometric framework in which to discuss the existence of time observables. This framework allows one to describe a local sense in which time observables always exist, and a global sense in which they can sometimes exist subject to a restriction on the vector fields that they generate. Pauli׳s prohibition on quantum time observables is derived as a corollary to this result. I will then discuss how time observables can be regained in modest extensions of quantum theory beyond i…Read more
-
134Curie’s Hazard: From Electromagnetism to Symmetry ViolationErkenntnis 81 (5): 1011-1029. 2016.Pierre Curie claimed that a symmetry of a cause must be found in the produced effects. This paper shows why this principle works in Curie’s example of the electrostatics of central fields, but fails in many others. The failure of Curie’s claim is then shown to be of special empirical interest, in that this failure underpins the experimental discovery of parity violation and of CP violation in the twentieth century.
-
1281The gauge argument: A Noether ReasonIn James Read & Nicholas J. Teh (eds.), The physics and philosophy of Noether's theorems, Cambridge University Press. pp. 354-377. 2022.Why is gauge symmetry so important in modern physics, given that one must eliminate it when interpreting what the theory represents? In this paper we discuss the sense in which gauge symmetry can be fruitfully applied to constrain the space of possible dynamical models in such a way that forces and charges are appropriately coupled. We review the most well-known application of this kind, known as the 'gauge argument' or 'gauge principle', discuss its difficulties, and then reconstruct the gauge …Read more
-
174Kramers degeneracy without eigenvectorsPhysical Review A 86 (3): 034103. 2012.Wigner gave a well-known proof of Kramers degeneracy, for time reversal invariant systems containing an odd number of half-integer spin particles. But Wigner's proof relies on the assumption that the Hamiltonian has an eigenvector, and thus does not apply to many quantum systems of physical interest. This note illustrates an algebraic way to talk about Kramers degeneracy that does not appeal to eigenvectors, and provides a derivation of Kramers degeneracy in this more general context.
-
339The Simple Failure of Curie’s PrinciplePhilosophy of Science 80 (4): 579-592. 2013.I point out a simple sense in which the standard formulation of Curie’s principle is false when the symmetry transformation it describes is time reversal.
-
London School of EconomicsDepartment of Philosophy, Logic and Scientific MethodAssociate Professor
London, England, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland