-
19Fausse route : Le chemin vers le pluralisme politique passe-t-il par le pluralisme axiologique?Archives de Philosophie du Droit 49 185-197. 2005.Pour certains philosophes pluralistes politiques, accepter la thèse de pluralisme des valeurs entraîne le rejet de l’autonomie libérale en faveur d’une forme de libéralisme fondée sur l’idéal de la tolérance. Cette idée est fausse. D’abord le pluralisme des valeurs partage avec le relativisme la difficulté inhérente à toute tentative de tirer une conclusion normative d’une thèse descriptive. Chercher à soutenir l’argument en comblant les prémisses manquantes montre que le pluralisme des valeurs …Read more
-
2711 Beyond exit rights: reframing the debateIn Avigail Eisenberg & Jeff Spinner-Halev (eds.), Minorities Within Minorities: Equality, Rights and Diversity, Cambridge University Press. pp. 227. 2005.
-
3The Antinomy of Language RightsIn Will Kymlicka & Alan Patten (eds.), Language Rights and Political Theory, Oxford University Press. 2003.
-
45Kwame Anthony Appiah, The Ethics of Identity:The Ethics of IdentityEthics 117 (1): 119-123. 2006.
-
57Motivating the global DemosMetaphilosophy 40 (1): 92-108. 2009.Abstract: Debates about the possibility of global democracy and justice are plagued by a fallacious assumption made by all parties. That assumption is that there is a "naturalness" to relations among fellow nationals to which a global demos could never aspire. In fact, nation builders employed a great many tools that mobilized the psychological and moral susceptibilities of individuals in order to create a sense of solidarity out of initially heterogeneous elements. Two such tools are described …Read more
-
14Just Talk?Dialogue 37 (1): 107-116. 1998.One of the most prominent themes of recent political philosophy, at least in the English-speaking world, has been the challenge which the cultural and moral diversity of modern Western societies poses for traditional liberal theories of justice. Given that these theories, in their classical formulations, either ignored the issue of social heterogeneity, or operated on the tacit assumption that the societies to which they would be applied were essentially homogeneous, what changes should a new ap…Read more
-
166How Democratic is Civil Disobedience?Criminal Law and Philosophy 10 (4): 707-720. 2016.In her book, Conscience and Conviction, Kimberley Brownlee argues that there is nothing undemocratic about the robust, primary right to civil disobedience that she devotes most of her argument to defending. To the contrary, she holds that there is nothing paternalistic about civil disobedients opposing the will of democratic majorities, because, inter alia, democratic majorities cannot claim particular epistemic superiority, and because there are flaws inherent to democratic procedures that civi…Read more
-
30Can parity of self-esteem serve as the basis of the principle of linguistic territoriality?Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 18 (2): 199-211. 2015.
-
30The Justification of Political LiberalismPacific Philosophical Quarterly 75 (3-4): 165-185. 1994.I outline Rawls's theory of justification, highlighting its philosophical and pragmatic conditions. I argue that the theory has remained essentially unchanged since his earliest methodological writings, and that his recent writings have sought to show how "justice as fairness" can satisfy these conditions, given Rawls's new construal of the "fact of pluralism" which theories of justice designed for modern Western liberal democracies must address. I argue that neither Rawls's revised conception o…Read more
-
25Perfectionism Versus Neutrality in Public Health: The Case of Advanced Maternal AgeAmerican Journal of Bioethics 15 (11): 49-50. 2015.
-
69Questions in Contemporary Medicine and the Philosophy of Charles Taylor: An IntroductionJournal of Medicine and Philosophy 36 (4): 329-334. 2011.This article provides an introduction to the articles in this theme issue. This collection examines epistemological, ontological, moral and political questions in medicine in light of the philosophical ideas of Charles Taylor. A synthesis of Taylor's relevant work is presented. Taylor has argued for a conception of the human sciences that regards human life as meaningful–deriving meaning from surrounding horizons of significance. An overview of the interdisciplinary articles in this issue is pre…Read more
-
1Joseph Raz, Engaging Reason. On the Theory of Value and Action Reviewed byPhilosophy in Review 22 (6): 439-442. 2002.
-
6GA Cohen, If You're an Egalitarian, How Come You're So Rich? Reviewed byPhilosophy in Review 20 (6): 405-407. 2000.
-
2Toward a Proceduralist Theory of SecessionCanadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 13 (2): 251-262. 2000.Substantive theorists of secession face a problem explaining why the international community ought on their view to withhold recognition from secessions which involve a loss in terms of the substantive criteria they privilege; this is so because the normal electoral politics giving rise to such a loss should not in their opinion meet with any adverse international reaction. The substantive theory of David Miller uses criteria for the legitimacy of secessions which give rise to strangely amoral c…Read more
-
85National PartialityThe Monist 82 (3): 516-541. 1999.Recent defenders of nationalism have pointed to the fact that most people feel that their obligations towards their compatriots are either more numerous or more stringent than those which bind them to people from other countries. They point to this fact as evidence that something is seriously amiss with the universalism which allegedly underpins liberal theory. That people believe quite strongly that they have such special obligations is taken as a datum for which different theories of justice m…Read more