•  1
    John Henry Newman's Humane Epistemology
    Cambridge University Press. forthcoming.
    This Element situates Newman’s humane epistemology against the historical backdrop of his philosophical interlocutors Richard Whately, William Froude, and John Locke. Walking a middle way between rationalism and fideism/sentimentalism, Newman holds that religious belief can meet reasonable standards of epistemic justification at play in ordinary secular matters. He further maintains that emotions have epistemic value, that the whole person must be educated for informed judgment, and that we are …Read more
  •  7
    Newman the Evidentialist
    New Blackfriars. forthcoming.
    A number of recent philosophers have argued that John Henry Newman is an anti-evidentialist – and not without reason. This article begins by examining three reasons one might think Newman is an anti-evidentialist: his dismissal of formal logic, his emphasis on emotions, and his critique of John Locke. It then seeks to rebut these reasons for thinking that Newman is an anti-evidentialist as well as to give three positive reasons for thinking that Newman is an evidentialist. Newman’s evidentialism…Read more
  •  216
    David Hume argues that theistic accounts of sense perception face two great hurdles. First, it seems unlikely that God had anything to do with our senses, since, if he had, they would be infallible. Second, the appeal to God is entirely circular: we know that God exists and benevolently ensures the reliability of sense perceptions because, using our reliable sense perceptions, we have proven a benevolent God’s existence. I argue that Thomas Reid’s theory of sense perception possesses the concept…Read more
  •  972
    Newman and Common Sense Epistemology
    In Frederick D. Aquino & Joe Milburn (eds.), John Henry Newman and Contemporary Philosophy, Routledge. pp. 28-46. 2025.
    While Newman scholars are nearly unanimous that John Henry Newman is an anti-skeptic, there is less agreement about the contours of his anti-skepticism. In this paper, we seek to lay bare the basic commitments of this anti-skepticism. First, we briefly discuss the type of skepticism with which Newman was most concerned. Second, we lay out Newman’s three-fold commitment to trust as the default epistemic stance. Third, we uncover Newman’s underlying commitment to a moderate form of evidentialism i…Read more
  •  30
    Contrary to the claims of many, Newman's project in An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent is epistemic and not merely psychological. Newman's dispute with Locke shows that Newman believes in knowledge and certitude, but disagrees with Locke in that knowledge and certitude can be had on less than conclusive reasoning.
  •  1281
    Newman’s Illative Sense Re-Examined
    In Frederick D. Aquino & Matthew Levering (eds.), John Henry Newman’s An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent: A Critical Guide, Emmaus Academic. pp. 183-202. 2025.
    Among John Henry Newman’s contributions to epistemology, his notion of the “illative sense” may be both the most significant and yet the least understood. In this chapter, we seek to rectify this problem. First, we carefully lay out Newman’s notion of the illative sense. Second, we discuss and evaluate three ways in which the illative sense might be understood in light of contemporary epistemology and psychology. Third, we create a model that attempts to fill out Newman’s sketch of the illative …Read more
  •  962
    Darwin Knows Best: Can Evolution Support the Classical Liberal Vision of the Family?
    In Logan Paul Gage, Bruce L. Gordon, Shawn E. Klein, Peter Lawler, Roger Masters, Angus Menuge, Michael J. White, Jay W. Richards, Timothy Sandefur, Richard Weikart, John West & Benjamin Wiker (eds.), Darwinian Evolution and Classical Liberalism: Theories in Tension, Lexington Books. pp. 135-156. 2013.
    In a time when conservatives believe that the traditional family is under increasing fire, some think an appeal to Darwinian science may be the answer. I argue that these conservatives are wrong to maintain that Darwinian theory can serve as the intellectual foundation for the traditional conception of the family. Contra Larry Arnhart and James Q. Wilson, a Darwinian philosophy of nature simply lacks the stability the traditional family requires; it cannot support the traditional conception of h…Read more
  •  5578
    St. Thomas Aquinas on Intelligent Design
    Proceedings of the American Catholic Philosophical Association 85 79-97. 2011.
    Recently, the Intelligent Design movement has challenged the claim of many in the scientific establishment that nature gives no empirical signs of having been deliberately designed. In particular, ID arguments in biology dispute the notion that neo-Darwinian evolution is the only viable scientific explanation of the origin of biological novelty, arguing that there are telltale signs of the activity of intelligence which can be recognized and studied empirically. In recent years, a number of Cath…Read more
  •  1710
    Beauty as Evidence of Intelligent Design
    In Ann Gauger (ed.), God's Grandeur, Sophia Institute Press. pp. 199-216. 2023.
    For centuries, people looked at the natural world and saw evidence of intelligent design not only in its complex structures but in its sheer beauty. With the rise of Darwinian theory, however, and the moral horrors of the last two centuries, it has been exceedingly difficult for intellectuals to see this world as beautiful. Any beauty we might perceive must be a kind of illusion. In this chapter, I lay out some reasons for thinking that beauty in nature is real and that it is yet another indi…Read more
  •  1386
    Understanding Design Arguments
    In Ann Gauger (ed.), God's Grandeur, Sophia Institute Press. pp. 17-26. 2023.
    Catholics face many challenges when it comes to thinking about evolution and intelligent design. This chapter aims to help us think more carefully and critically about these ideas. Without worrying yet about whether design arguments are sound, we must first figure out what these arguments claim—and, just as importantly, what they do not claim. To this end, I provide some background, attempt to define terms, discuss the form of such arguments, and consider common Catholic misconceptions. The hope…Read more
  •  1265
    Newman and Quasi‐Fideism : A Reply to Duncan Pritchard
    Heythrop Journal 64 (5): 695-706. 2023.
    In recent years, Duncan Pritchard has developed a position in religious epistemology called quasi‐fideism that he claims traces back to John Henry Newman's treatment of the rationality of religious belief. In this paper, we give three reasons to think that Pritchard's reading of Newman as a quasi‐fideist is mistaken. First, Newman's parity argument does not claim that religious and non‐religious beliefs are on a par because both are groundless; instead, for Newman, they are on a par because both…Read more
  •  1785
    Newman the Fallibilist
    American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 97 (1): 29-47. 2023.
    The role of certitude in our mental lives is, to put it mildly, controversial. Many current epistemologists (including epistemologists of religion) eschew certitude altogether. Given his emphasis on certitude, some have maintained that John Henry Newman was an infallibilist about knowledge. In this paper, we argue that a careful examination of his thought (especially as seen in the Grammar of Assent) reveals that he was an epistemic fallibilist. We first clarify what we mean by fallibilism and i…Read more
  •  673
    PC: Response to Critics
    In John M. DePoe & Tyler Dalton McNabb (eds.), Debating Christian Religious Epistemology: An Introduction to Five Views on the Knowledge of God, Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 98-106. 2020.
    In this chapter, Gage and McAllister respond to various objections to the phenomenal conservative position in religious epistemology. In particular, they respond to the objections that seemings are the ultimate source of justification, that PC makes epistemic justification too easy, that PC involves conceptual circularity, and that PC lacks an objective connection to truth.
  •  764
    We critique MacIntyre's traditions-based perspectivalist approach to religious epistemology as articulated by Erik Baldwin from the perspective of phenomenal conservatism.
  •  867
    We criticize the approach of covenantal epistemology to religious epistemology as articulated by Scott Oliphint from the perspective of phenomenal conservatism.
  •  776
    We criticize the proper functionalist approach to religious epistemology as articulated by Tyler McNabb from the perspective of phenomenal conservatism.
  •  660
    We criticize the classical evidentialist approach to religious epistemology as articulated by John DePoe from the perspective of phenomenal conservatism.
  •  1759
    On the Epistemic Role of Our Passional Nature
    with Frederick D. Aquino
    Newman Studies Journal 17 (2): 41-58. 2020.
    In this article, we argue that John Henry Newman was right to think that our passional nature can play a legitimate epistemic role. First, we unpack the standard objection to Newman’s understanding of the relationship between our passional nature and the evidential basis of faith. Second, we argue that the standard objection to Newman operates with a narrow definition of evidence. After challenging this notion, we then offer a broader and more humane understanding of evidence. Third, we survey r…Read more
  •  1317
    For some years now, Michael Bergmann has urged a dilemma against internalist theories of epistemic justification. For reasons I explain below, some epistemologists have thought that Michael Huemer’s principle of Phenomenal Conservatism can split the horns of Bergmann’s dilemma. Bergmann has recently argued, however, that PC must inevitably, like all other internalist views, fall prey to his dilemma. In this paper, I explain the nature of Bergmann’s dilemma and his reasons for thinking that PC ca…Read more
  •  688
    A review of Robert. B. Stewart's edited volume concerning a discussion between William Dembski and Michael Ruse. Further contributions are included from William Lane Craig and others.
  •  730
    John Polkinghorne: Science and Religion in Quest of Truth (review)
    Religious Studies Review 40 (3): 137. 2014.
    A brief review of John Polkinghorne's 2011 book Science and Religion in Quest of Truth (Yale University Press).
  •  2620
    A Saint for Our Times: Newman on Faith, Fallibility, and Certitude
    Logos: A Journal of Catholic Thought and Culture 23 (2): 60-76. 2020.
    This essay shows how John Henry Newman reconciled the certitude of faith with a fallibilist epistemology. While Newman holds that many of our beliefs are held with certitude, he does not conceive of all certitude as Cartesian, apodictic certitude. In this way, he walks a middle road between rationalism and fideism.
  •  2574
    Phenomenal Conservatism
    In John M. DePoe & Tyler Dalton McNabb (eds.), Debating Christian Religious Epistemology: An Introduction to Five Views on the Knowledge of God, Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 61-81. 2020.
    In this chapter, we argue for a phenomenal conservative perspective on religious epistemology and attempt to answer some common criticisms of this perspective.
  •  3626
    Newman’s Argument from Conscience: Why He Needs Paley and Natural Theology After All
    American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 94 (1): 141-157. 2020.
    Recent authors, emphasizing Newman’s distaste for natural theology—especially William Paley’s design argument—have urged us to follow Newman’s lead and reject design arguments. But I argue that Newman’s own argument for God’s existence (his argument from conscience) fails without a supplementary design argument or similar reason to think our faculties are truth-oriented. In other words, Newman appears to need the kind of argument he explicitly rejects. Finding Newman’s rejection of natural th…Read more
  •  3701
    Is the God Hypothesis Improbable? A Response to Dawkins
    In Kevin Vallier & Joshua Rasmussen (eds.), A New Theist Response to the New Atheists, Routledge. pp. 59-76. 2019.
    In this chapter, Logan Paul Gage examines the only real attempt to disprove God’s existence by a New Atheist: Richard Dawkins’s “Ultimate 747 Gambit.” Central to Dawkins’s argument is the claim that God is more complex than what he is invoked to explain. Gage evaluates this claim using the main extant notions of simplicity in the literature. Gage concludes that on no reading does this claim survive scrutiny. Along the way, Dawkins claims that there are no good positive arguments for God’s existe…Read more
  •  2715
    Edward Feser: Five Proofs of the Existence of God
    Philosophia Christi 21 (1): 228-232. 2019.
    A review of Edward Feser's Five Proofs of the Existence of God.
  •  1539
    A Pastor’s Kid Finds the Catholic Church
    In Brian Besong & Jonathan Fuqua (eds.), Faith and Reason: Philosophers Explain Their Turn to Catholicism, Ignatius Press. pp. 151-174. 2019.
    In this essay, I describe my journey to Catholicism and explain one of the many reasons I became Catholic--namely, an argument from the canon of Scripture.
  •  1582
    Can Experience Fulfill the Many Roles of Evidence?
    Quaestiones Disputatae 8 (2): 87-111. 2018.
    It is still a live question in epistemology and philosophy of science as to what exactly evidence is. In my view, evidence consists in experiences called “seemings.” This view is a version of the phenomenal conception of evidence, the position that evidence consists in nonfactive mental states with propositional content. This conception is opposed by sense-data theorists, disjunctivists, and those who think evidence consists in physical objects or publicly observable states of affairs—call it…Read more
  •  592
    Editor’s Introduction
    Quaestiones Disputatae 8 (2): 3-4. 2018.
    A brief introduction to a diverse and interesting group of papers in contemporary epistemology.