-
18Logical Argument Mapping: A cognitive-change-based method for building common groundAcm International Conference Proceeding Series; Vol. 280. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Pragmatic Web. 2007.In this paper, I situate Logical Argument Mapping within
-
16Climate Ethics: Structuring Deliberation by Means of Logical Argument MappingJournal of Speculative Philosophy 25 (1): 64-97. 2011.
-
16This argument map reconstructs David Hume's famous skeptical argument in logical form. The argument is open for debate and comments in AGORA-net . Search for map ID 9857
-
15Diagrams as Scaffolds for CreativityAaai Workshops, North America. 2010.Based on a typology of five basic forms of abduction, I propose a new definition of abductive insight that empha sizes in particular the inferential structure of a belief system that is able to explain a phenomenon after a new, abductive ly created component has been added to this system or the entire system has been abductively restructured. My thesis is, first, that the argumentative structure of the pursued problem solution guides abductive creativity and, second, that diagrammatic reasoning—…Read more
-
15This argument map represents an argumentation from Heyns, C. . Report of the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, Christof Heyns . S.l.: United Nations. Human Rights Council. The argument map is open for debate in AGORA-net, search for map ID 9206
-
11Reflective Consensus Building on Wicked Problems with the Reflect! PlatformScience and Engineering Ethics 26 (2): 793-819. 2020.Wicked problems—that is, problems that can be framed in a number of different ways, depending on who is looking at them—pose ethical challenges for professionals that have scarcely been recognized as such. Even though wicked problems are all around us, they are rarely addressed in education. A reason for this failure might be that wicked problems pose almost insurmountable challenges in educational settings. This contribution shows how students can learn to cope with wicked problems in problem-b…Read more
-
10Bad Arguments and Objectively Bad ArgumentsInformal Logic 43 (1): 23-90. 2023.Many have argued that it is impossible to determine criteria to identify good arguments. In this contribution, we argue that it is at least possible to identify features of objectively bad arguments. Going beyond Blair and Johnson’s ARS criteria, which state that reasons must be acceptable, relevant, and sufficient, we develop a list of eight criteria with instructions for how to apply them to assess arguments. We conclude by presenting data from two empirical studies that show how frequently st…Read more
-
10This argument map presents Paul Loewi’s crucial experiment in which he showed that neural transmissions of signals are chemical in nature, not electrical, in form of an argumentation. The map can be used in science education to show how the formulation of hypotheses should be related to a corresponding determination of experimental designs
-
8This argument map represents the argumentation of Sparrow, R. . "Just say No" to Drones. IEEE Technology and Society Magazine, M 1932-4529/12, 56-63. doi: 10.1109/MTS.2012.2185275. The argument map is open for debate in AGORA-net, search for map ID 9712
-
7Transcendental Arguments in Scientific ReasoningErkenntnis 84 (6): 1387-1407. 2019.Although there is increasing interest in philosophy of science in transcendental reasoning, there is hardly any discussion about transcendental arguments. Since this might be related to the dominant understanding of transcendental arguments as a tool to defeat epistemological skepticism, and since the power of transcendental arguments to achieve this goal has convincingly been disputed by Barry Stroud, this contribution proposes, first, a new definition of the transcendental argument which allow…Read more
-
6The "realization of the due-measure" as structural principle in Plato's statesmanPolis 12 (1-2): 77-98. 1993.
-
4Das Problem der Erkenntnisentwicklung und Peirces semiotisch-pragmatischer LösungsansatzAllgemeine Zeitschrift für Philosophie 27 (3): 223-240. 2002.homepage Atlanta
-
3Die Entstehung von Ordnung: zur Bestimmung von Sein, Erkennen und Handeln in der späteren Philosophie Platons (edited book)B.G. Teubner. 1996.
-
2The "Realization of the Due-Measure" as Structural Principle in Plato's StatesmanPolis. Newsletter of the Society for the Study of Greek Political Thought 12. 1993.
-
1The primary goal of this chapter is to present a new method—called Logical Argument Mapping —for the analysis of framing processes as they occur in any communication, but especially in conflicts. I start with a distinction between boundary setting, meaning construction, and sensemaking as three forms or aspects of framing, and argue that crucial for the resolution of frame-based controversies is our ability to deal with those “webs” of mutually supporting beliefs that determine sensemaking proce…Read more
-
1Skizze einer semiotischen Theorie des LernensJournal Für Mathematik-Didaktik 22 231-251. 2001.VG Wort 3740 Anschläge pro Seite
-
1Über die Bedingungen der Möglichkeit durch diagrammatisches Denken etwas zu lernen: Diagrammgebrauch in Logik und ArithmetikZeitschrift Für Semiotik 31 241-274. 2009.Summary. This paper analyzes Frederik Stjernfelt’s recently published Diagrammatology in order to clarify the role of diagrammatic reasoning within an epistemology that focuses on the problem of learning and the growth of knowledge. To achieve this goal, I provide more precise definitions of Peirce’s concepts of “diagram” and “diagrammatic reasoning,” emphasizing in particular the necessity of consistent systems of representation as a precondition for both. The paper starts with a critique of tw…Read more
-
Peirce's philosophy of science, logic and epistemology. New publications and editions. 1Philosophische Rundschau 51 (3): 193-211. 2004.
-
Mathematik als Prozess der Verallgemeinerung von Zeichen: Eine exemplarische Unterrichtseinheit zur Entdeckung der InkommensurabilitätZeitschrift Für Semiotik 22. 2000.
-
Chapter 13In Das Problem der Zukunft im Rahmen holistischer Ethiken. Im Ausgang von Platon und Peirce, Edition Tertium. pp. 105-118. 1996.Some “of the most influential and prominent scholars in the field of Peirce studies” were asked to answer five questions: 1) Why were you initially drawn to Peirce? 2) What do you consider your contribution to the field? 3) What is the proper role of Peirce’s work in relation to philosophy and other academic disciplines? 4) What do you consider the most important topics and/or contributions in the field of Peirce studies? 5) What are the most important open problems in this field and what are th…Read more
-
Learning by Developing Knowledge Networks. A semiotic approach within a dialectical frameworkZdm. Zentralblatt Für Didaktik der Mathematik 36 196-205. 2004.A central challenge for research on how we should prepare students to manage crossing boundaries between different knowledge settings in life long learning processes is to identify those forms of knowledge that are particularly relevant here. In this paper, we develop by philosophical means the concept of a dialectical system as a general framework to describe the de-velopment of knowledge networks that mark the starting point for learning processes, and we use semiotics to discuss the epistemol…Read more
-
The paper aims to show how by elaborating the Peircean terms used in the title creativity in learning processes and in scientific discoveries can be explained within a semiotic framework. The essential idea is to emphasize both the role of external representations and of experimenting with those representations , and to describe a process consisting of three steps: First, looking at diagrams "from a novel point of view" offers opportunities to synthesize elements of these diagrams which have nev…Read more
-
Einleitung. Lernen als ZeichenprozessZeitschrift Für Semiotik 22. 2000.VG Wort: auf einer Seite 3500 Anschläge!
-
Peirce's philosophy on science, logic and perception theoryPhilosophische Rundschau 51 (4): 296-313. 2004.
Ludwig Maximilians Universität, München
Faculty of Philosophy, Philosophy of Science and Study of Religion
PhD, 1993
Atlanta, Georgia, United States of America
Areas of Interest
Epistemology |
Applied Ethics |
General Philosophy of Science |