-
1PlatoIn Berys Nigel Gaut & Dominic Lopes (eds.), The Routledge Companion to Aesthetics, Routledge. 2000.Plato's writings about the arts play a foundational role in the history of aesthetics, not simply because they are the earliest substantial contribution to the subject. The arts are a central, rather than a marginal topic for Plato, and for him the whole of culture must reflect and inculcate the values that concern him. His philosophy of art (as we would call it) is closely integrated with his metaphysics, ethics and politics. We shall examine in outline the major issues that a reading of Plato …Read more
-
Introduction : Nietzsche on naturalism and normativityIn Simon Robertson & Christopher Janaway (eds.), Nietzsche, Naturalism & Normativity, Oxford University Press. 2012.
-
MaterialismIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Schopenhauer argues that the world of objects must be material, and that the only use for the concept of substance is that of matter. He argues that materialism is correlative with idealism. Even the brain functions of the subject are material processes. However, materialism is one‐sided because it does not account for the point of view of the consciousness of the subject of knowledge, from which idealism indispensably starts.
-
Determinism and ResponsibilityIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Gives an account principally of Schopenhauer's essay On the Freedom of the Human Will. He argues that human willing is determined by the combination of motives and the character of the agent. Self‐consciousness is not capable of deciding whether or not the agent could have willed otherwise, but an objective view dictates that all actions are necessitated by their cause. Despite this, Schopenhauer argues that our sense of being responsible for our actions remains, and he attempts to account for i…Read more
-
The Development of Schopenhauer's PhilosophyIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Schopenhauer's philosophy was formed during the years 1810–18. This chapter looks at the influences that shaped it, principally Kant, but also Plato, and the Upanishads. Schopenhauer aimed at a synthesis of these influences. Although indebted to Kant for the framework of his thought, he developed a conception of metaphysics and a ‘better consciousness’ of objective reality that would be free from the limitations imposed by Kant. Schopenhauer's antagonistic relationship with Fichte, Schelling, an…Read more
-
Kantian ObjectsIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Kant's central contribution to theoretical philosophy was the position he called ‘transcendental idealism’. Schopenhauer also adopted transcendental idealism, though he wanted to modify Kant's position considerably, as evidenced in his long ‘Critique of the Kantian Philosophy’ appended to The World as Will and Representation. This chapter outlines Kant's idealism, comparing it with the idealism of Berkeley, examining the limitation of knowledge to appearances as opposed to the thing in itself, a…Read more
-
Willing and Nothingness: Schopenhauer as Nietzsche's EducatorTijdschrift Voor Filosofie 61 (4): 802-805. 1999.
-
Grace, freedom, and the expression of emotion : Schiller and the critique of Kant / Affect and cognition in Schopenhauer and NietzscheIn Alix Cohen & Robert Stern (eds.), Thinking about the Emotions : A Philosophical History, Oxford University Press. 2017.
-
Nietzsche on morality, drives, and human greatnessIn Simon Robertson & Christopher Janaway (eds.), Nietzsche, Naturalism & Normativity, Oxford University Press. 2012.
-
Remarks on Wittgenstein and NietzscheIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Gives some of the background to the reception of Schopenhauer's philosophy by both Wittgenstein and Nietzsche, and then examines the influence on each of them of Schopenhauer's conceptions of self and will. In Wittgenstein's early notebooks and Tractatus, the notion of the subject's not being a part of the world and of happiness lying in not willing are distinctly Schopenhauerian notions. Wittgenstein's later pre‐occupation with the relation of willing and acting show a lasting influence from Sc…Read more
-
Freedom from WillIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Outlines the ways in which Schopenhauer alleges that value is to be attained by an escape from or denial of the will that is our essence. Schopenhauer's pessimism involves a negative assessment of the life of insatiable striving and egoism to which the will condemns the individual. Aesthetic experience provides an escape into a will‐less state of consciousness. Ethics is founded on the recognition that individuation is basically illusory and egoism an erroneous impulse to action. Finally, Schope…Read more
-
The Primacy of WillIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Schopenhauer conceives the will as metaphysically primary, as the thing in itself that underlies all phenomena, but also as having primacy over the intellect in human psychology. Experience is a function of the brain, which receives a teleological explanation as furthering the life of the organism. This is one example of Schopenhauer's conception of will to life, a blindly striving principle that manifests itself throughout individuals in the empirical world. The chapter examines the coherence o…Read more
-
Kantian SubjectsIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Looks at the legacy Kant left for theorizing about the subject, taken in two senses: the subject of will and action, and the subject of experience and knowledge. Kant argues for transcendental freedom, producing a conception of the self as subject of free will, while claiming that the agent's actions, as part of the empirical world, are causally determined. He argues also that the ‘I’ is not a substance, but must be conceived as existing over and above its experiences as their unitary subject. B…Read more
-
Subject and Object in SchopenhauerIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Shows how Schopenhauer uses the concepts of subject and object to describe experience and knowledge and to argue for idealism. The world of things in space and time is the world as representation, comprised of objects for the subject. There can be no subject without object and no object without subject. Schopenhauer's argument that this supports idealism is assessed critically on the grounds that ‘no subject without object’ is ambiguous.
-
Review of MAGEE, B. "The Philosophy of Schopenhauer" (review)Mind 93 (n/a): 608. 1984.Book review.
-
Willing and ActingIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Presents Schopenhauer's claims about the relation between willing and action. Willing is for him fundamentally a moving of the body, not a mental volition that causes bodily movement. His theory here is clearly opposed to dualism. Human action is distinguished from other bodily events by its having motives as its causes. The chapter suggests that this discussion of will and action had some influence on Wittgenstein and thereby perhaps on more recent action theory.
-
Knowing the Thing in ItselfIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.The central claim of Schopenhauer's metaphysics is that the thing in itself is will. He arrives at this by way of an observation about self‐knowledge: I can know myself only as willing or active, not as subject of knowledge. He claims that this unique knowledge gives access to my essence, and moves from this to the claim that the world in itself is will, of which the plurality of empirical things is an objectification. The chapter examines the problem of knowing the thing in itself at all. It is…Read more
-
ConclusionsIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Resumes the salient features of Schopenhauer's philosophy dealt with in the book. These include his dichotomy of subject and object, the correlativity of subjective and objective viewpoints, and the primacy of the will in accounting for the self. It concludes that Schopenhauer is helpful in uncovering two mysteries: that a ‘blind’ nature should produce a being with self‐consciousness, and that this being should be capable of understanding itself as a product of nature.
-
Schopenhauer: Subject, Object, and WillDissertation, Oxford University. 1983.DPhil thesis submitted 1983.
-
Self and WorldIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Addresses the question of the relevance of Schopenhauer's philosophy to a present‐day audience. Schopenhauer raises questions concerning I‐thoughts, in which one makes ascriptions to oneself without needing to identify oneself as an object in the world. He also provides a prototype of the thought that the ‘I’ cannot be conceived wholly as a disembodied or transcendental pure subject, but must be an active and embodied agent. Schopenhauer's dichotomy of subjective and objective viewpoints is argu…Read more
-
IdealismIn Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy, Oxford University Press. 1989.Discusses Schopenhauer's claim that his idealism unites insights of Kant and Berkeley, and contrasts his position on the subject–object relation with that of Fichte. The question whether his idealism is solipsistic is raised. Schopenhauer's arguments that idealism is the only viable alternative to scepticism, and that the existence of a world of objects except for a representing subject is inconceivable are also critically analysed.
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
Areas of Interest
Aesthetics |
Normative Ethics |
Ancient Greek and Roman Philosophy |
19th Century Philosophy |