•  98
    Artificial intelligence, existential risk and equity: the need for multigenerational bioethics
    with Kyle Fiore Law and Stylianos Syropoulos
    Journal of Medical Ethics 50 (12): 799-801. 2024.
    > Future people count. There could be a lot of them. We can make their lives better. > > -- William MacAskill, What We Owe The Future > > [Longtermism is] quite possibly the most dangerous secular belief system in the world today. > > -- Émile P. Torres, Against Longtermism Philosophers,1 2 psychologists,3 4 politicians5 and even some tech billionaires6 have sounded the alarm about artificial intelligence (AI) and the dangers it may pose to the long-term future of humanity. Some believe it poses…Read more
  •  166
    The Hopkins-Oxford Psychedelics Ethics (HOPE) Working Group Consensus Statement
    with Edward Jacobs, Paul S. Appelbaum, Lori Bruce, Ksenia Cassidy, Yuria Celidwen, Katherine Cheung, Sean K. Clancy, Neşe Devenot, Jules Evans, Holly Fernandez Lynch, Phoebe Friesen, Albert Garcia Romeu, Neil Gehani, Molly Maloof, Olivia Marcus, Ole Martin Moen, Mayli Mertens, Sandeep M. Nayak, Tehseen Noorani, Kyle Patch, Sebastian Porsdam-Mann, Gokul Raj, Khaleel Rajwani, Keisha Ray, William Smith, Daniel Villiger, Neil Levy, Roger Crisp, and Julian Savulescu
    American Journal of Bioethics 24 (7). 2024.
  •  97
    Distinctive But Not Exceptional: The Risks of Psychedelic Ethical Exceptionalism
    with Katherine Cheung, Kyle Patch, and David B. Yaden
    American Journal of Bioethics 25 (1): 16-28. 2025.
    When used clinically, psychedelics may appear unusual or even unique when compared to more familiar or long-standing medical interventions, prompting some to suggest that the ethical issues raised may likewise be exceptional. If that is correct, then perhaps psychedelics should be treated differently from other medical substances: for example, by being subjected to different ethical or evidentiary standards. Alternatively, it may be that psychedelics have more in common with various existing med…Read more
  •  171
    A prominent critique of cognitive or athletic enhancement claims that certain performance‐improving drugs or technologies may ‘cheapen’ resulting achievements. Considerably less attention has been paid to the impact of enhancement on the value of moral achievements. Would the use of moral enhancement (bio)technologies, rather than (solely) ‘traditional’ means of moral development like schooling and socialization, cheapen the ‘achievement’ of morally improving oneself? We argue that, to the exten…Read more
  •  34
    Are Psychedelics Ethically Exceptional After All? Some Further Reflections
    with Katherine Cheung, Kyle Patch, and David B. Yaden
    American Journal of Bioethics 26 (5). 2026.
    We are grateful to those who commented on our Target Article on ethical exceptionalism around psychedelics (see Box 1 for a summary of our main points) and to Cohen and Marks (2025) for their compl...
  •  39
    Data for dollars? The ethics of trading African health data for American investment: lessons from the US–Kenya deal
    with Keymanthri Moodley
    Journal of Medical Ethics 52 (3): 137-141. 2026.
    Recent news reports describe a multibillion dollar health cooperation agreement between the Kenyan government and the USA, under which access to ‘de-identified and aggregated’ data from Kenyan health systems would be provided to US researchers within a legally governed framework, alongside substantial US funding commitments for healthcare infrastructure and services that are needed in Kenya.1 The arrangement has been cast, by representatives of both governments, as reasonable, efficient and lega…Read more
  •  63
    Seven Desiderata for Ethical Frameworks for AI Mental Health Agents
    with William R. Smith and Benjamin Buck
    American Journal of Bioethics 26 (2): 83-86. 2026.
    Volume 26, Issue 2, February 2026, Page 83-86.
  •  10
    Abolishing Gender
    In David Edmonds (ed.), Future Morality, Oxford University Press, Usa. pp. 35-49. 2021.
    This chapter evaluates the abolition of gender. There is a powerful set of assumptions in Western culture that influences how many of us think about sex and gender, even if we are not always fully aware of it. This set of assumptions can be called the “Dominant Gender Ideology” (DGI). Some people think it would better if sex was not linked to socially enforced gender roles that prescribe how people should be and behave on the basis of their sex. And their proposal for how to bring about this bet…Read more
  •  26
    Compared with high-income countries (HICs), developing ‘Chat-IRB’—application-specific large language models for research ethics review—may have different implications for resource-constrained Research Ethics Committees or Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). While certain concerns raised by Moodley, Malpani, and Reis—including resource challenges, reviewing research conducted in LMICs, and automation bias—are not entirely unique to LMIC IRBs, the hurdl…Read more
  •  49
    On 16 April 2025, the Supreme Court of the UK ruled that when interpreting the UK’s Equality Act (2010)—the Act of the UK Parliament that details protections against unlawful discrimination—the terms ‘man’, ‘woman’ and ‘sex’ pick out ‘biological sex’ (defined in the Court’s ruling as ‘the sex of a person at birth’) and not also ‘certificated sex’ (defined in the Court’s ruling as ‘the sex attained by the acquisition of a Gender Recognition Certificate’). Some have argued that the Court’s decisio…Read more
  •  90
    Experimental Bioethics, Linguistic Pragmatism, and Public Attitudes Toward Brain Organoids Research
    with Faisal Feroz and Jonathan Lewis
    American Journal of Bioethics 25 (4): 71-74. 2025.
    We agree with Clapp et al. (2025) that the representational view of language presents an impoverished account of communicative speech acts. Empirical research shows how people’s conceptual inferenc...
  •  72
    “Let’s Build It and Find Out!” Next Steps for Personalized Patient Preference Prediction
    with Sebastian Porsdam Mann, Tessa van Veenendaal, Jemima Winifred Allen, Sabine Salloch, Karin Jongsma, Matthias Braun, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, Annette Rid, David Wendler, and Julian Savulescu
    American Journal of Bioethics 26 (1): 1-6. 2026.
    In recent work, we introduced a Personalized Patient Preference Predictor (P4) that would make use of large language models (LLMs) trained on individual-specific data. The P4 would, if successfully...
  •  65
    As recently appointed co-editors-in-chief of the Journal of Medical Ethics, our goal is to serve the community of authors, reviewers and readers by ensuring that the work we publish is timely, rigorous and distinctive. In this editorial, we want to share a few notes about how we are approaching editorial decisions, so that our rationale is clear, and to call attention to some simplification of the journal’s article types and what we’re hoping for from work in each of these categories. First, som…Read more
  •  57
    Healthcare systems often delegate surgical consent-seeking to members of the treating team other than the surgeon (e.g., junior doctors in the UK and Australia). Yet, little is known about public attitudes toward this practice compared to emerging AI-supported options. This first large-scale empirical study examines how laypeople evaluate the validity and liability risks of using an AI-supported surgical consent system (Consent-GPT). We randomly assigned 376 UK participants (demographically repr…Read more
  •  40
    Digital Psychological Twins in Medicine: Addressing Risks to Human Relationships
    with Tessa van Veenendaal, Sebastian Porsdam Mann, and Julian Savulescu
    In Yanto Chandra & Ruiping Fan (eds.), Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Human Relations: Eastern and Western Perspectives, Springer Nature Singapore. pp. 239-257. 2025.
    Medical decision-making on behalf of individuals who have lost the capacity to make their own treatment choices poses significant challenges. The “substituted judgment” standard, which prioritizes individual autonomy, requires surrogate decision-makers to choose the course of action that the patient would have chosen or endorsed if they were able to do so. However, research suggests that surrogates often face difficulties in accurately predicting patient preferences, even when making a good-fait…Read more
  •  83
    Proposals to create AI chatbots or conversational ‘agents’ modelled on real human individuals, including specific bioethics scholars1 in the academic context, or individual patients (or potential future patients) in the medical context,2 have taken off in recent years. This has been accompanied by a lively and sometimes heated discussion about the ethics of creating or deploying such person-emulating chatbots in various contexts, both within and beyond the healthcare domain. Currently debated qu…Read more
  •  100
    Obtaining informed consent in paediatrics is an essential yet ethically complex aspect of clinical practice. Children have varying levels of autonomy and understanding based on their age and developmental maturity, with parents traditionally playing a central role in decision-making. However, there is increasing recognition of children’s evolving capacities and their right to be involved in care decisions, raising questions about facilitating meaningful consent, or at least assent, in complex me…Read more
  •  42
    When to create embryos or organoids for research
    with Sebastian Porsdam Mann and Julian Savulescu
    Journal of Medical Ethics 52 (7): 459-464. 2026.
    The development of brain organoids and use of human embryonic neural structures for research each raise distinct ethical considerations that require careful analysis. We propose that rather than attempting to resolve longstanding debates about embryonic moral status, a more productive approach is to examine how different positions on this fundamental question lead to distinct conclusions about appropriate research strategies. For those who ground moral status in species membership or development…Read more
  •  64
    Harms of the current global anti-FGM campaign
    with Fuambai Sia Nyoko Ahmadu, Dina Bader, Janice Boddy, Mamasa Camara, Natasha Carver, Rosie Duivenbode, Birgitta Essén, Ellen Gruenbaum, Saida Hodžić, Sara Johnsdotter, Saffron Karlsen, Sophia Koukoui, Cynthia Kraus, MariaCaterina La Barbera, Lori Leonard, Carlos D. Londoño Sulkin, Ruth M. Mestre I. Mestre, Sarah O’Neill, Christina Pantazis, Maree Pardy, Juliet Rogers, Nan Seuffert, Arianne Shahvisi, Richard A. Shweder, and Lotta Wendel
    Journal of Medical Ethics. forthcoming.
    Traditional female genital practices, though long-standing in many cultures, have become the focus of an expansive global campaign against ‘female genital mutilation’ (FGM). In this article, we critically examine the harms produced by the anti-FGM discourse and policies, despite their grounding in human rights and health advocacy. We argue that a ubiquitous ‘standard tale’ obscures the diversity of practices, meanings and experiences among those affected. This discourse, driven by a heavily raci…Read more
  •  100
    Digital Doppelgängers, Human Relationships, and Practical Identity
    with Cristina Voinea, Sebastian Porsdam Mann, and Julian Savulescu
    Bioethics 40 (5): 435-444. 2026.
    In this paper, we examine the potential effects of relationships with Large Language Model (LLM)‐based digital doppelgängers (DDs) on users' values, concerns, and interests, that is, on their practical identity. DDs are artificially intelligent conversational agents trained on individuals' data to replicate their speech patterns, mannerisms, and personality traits. We start by showing that practical identity is largely defined by the relationships we find ourselves in or cultivate. Next, we disc…Read more
  •  52
    Chat-IRB? How application-specific language models can enhance research ethics review
    with Sebastian Porsdam Mann, Jiehao Joel Seah, Stephen Latham, Julian Savulescu, and Mateo Aboy
    Journal of Medical Ethics. forthcoming.
    Institutional review boards (IRBs) play a crucial role in ensuring the ethical conduct of human subjects research, but face challenges including inconsistency, delays, and inefficiencies. We propose the development and implementation of application-specific large language models (LLMs) to facilitate IRB review processes. These IRB-specific LLMs would be fine-tuned on IRB-specific literature and institutional datasets, and equipped with retrieval capabilities to access up-to-date, context-relevan…Read more
  •  1325
    Aim To examine the challenges and opportunities presented by generative artificial intelligence in healthcare education and explore how it can be used ethically to enhance rather than compromise future healthcare workforce competence. Background Generative artificial intelligence is fundamentally changing healthcare education, yet many universities and healthcare educators have failed to keep pace with its rapid development. Design A discussion paper. Methods Discussion and analysis of the chall…Read more
  •  118
    Respecting formerly autonomous persons: clarifying the role of the Personalised Patient Preference Predictor (P4) in substituted judgement
    with Sebastian Porsdam Mann, Tessa van Veenendaal, Jemima Winifred Allen, Sabine Salloch, Karin Rolanda Jongsma, Matthias Braun, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, Julian Savulescu, Annette Rid, and David Wendler
    Journal of Medical Ethics 51 (7): 462-464. 2025.
    In a recent paper,1 we proposed a Personalised Patient Preference Predictor (P4), building on earlier work by Rid and Wendler.2 The P4 is a hypothetical computer program that would, in the context of surrogate decision-making (eg, following a substituted judgement standard), use generative artificial intelligence (AI) models to infer a patient’s underlying values and preferences and, on that basis, predict which treatment option they would choose in the current situation. Such AI models, we sugg…Read more
  •  91
    Know Thyself, Improve Thyself: Personalized LLMs for Self-Knowledge and Moral Enhancement
    with Alberto Giubilini, Sebastian Porsdam Mann, Cristina Voinea, and Julian Savulescu
    Science and Engineering Ethics 30 (6): 1-15. 2024.
    In this paper, we suggest that personalized LLMs trained on information written by or otherwise pertaining to an individual could serve as artificial moral advisors (AMAs) that account for the dynamic nature of personal morality. These LLM-based AMAs would harness users’ past and present data to infer and make explicit their sometimes-shifting values and preferences, thereby fostering self-knowledge. Further, these systems may also assist in processes of self-creation, by helping users reflect o…Read more
  •  193
    Digital Doppelgängers and Lifespan Extension: What Matters?
    with Samuel Iglesias, Cristina Voinea, Sebastian Porsdam Mann, Anda Zahiu, Nancy S. Jecker, and Julian Savulescu
    American Journal of Bioethics 25 (2): 95-110. 2024.
    There is an ongoing debate about the ethics of research on lifespan extension: roughly, using medical technologies to extend biological human lives beyond the current “natural” limit of about 120 years. At the same time, there is an exploding interest in the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to create “digital twins” of persons, for example by fine-tuning large language models on data specific to particular individuals. In this paper, we consider whether digital twins (or digital doppelgängers…Read more
  •  129
    Enabling Demonstrated Consent for Biobanking with Blockchain and Generative AI
    with Caspar Barnes, Mateo Riobo Aboy, Timo Minssen, Jemima Winifred Allen, Julian Savulescu, and Sebastian Porsdam Mann
    American Journal of Bioethics 25 (4): 96-111. 2025.
    Participation in research is supposed to be voluntary and informed. Yet it is difficult to ensure people are adequately informed about the potential uses of their biological materials when they donate samples for future research. We propose a novel consent framework which we call “demonstrated consent” that leverages blockchain technology and generative AI to address this problem. In a demonstrated consent model, each donated sample is associated with a unique non-fungible token (NFT) on a block…Read more
  •  36
    Something old, something new? The Journal of Medical Ethics turns 50
    Journal of Medical Ethics 51 (8): 505-507. 2025.
    The opening lines of the first issue of the Journal of Medical Ethics —an unsigned April 1975 editoriali—capture the uselessness of editorial policy statements: > The reputation of a newly founded journal must be established by the style, quality and range of the material it offers. Perhaps then editorial policy statements achieve very little, for, either the reader can appreciate the usefulness of the journal’s contents without editorial encouragement, or he discovers for himself their irreleva…Read more
  •  58
    Good bioethics and a good bioethicist: John McMillan’s contributions to JME’s legacy
    with Zoë Fritz, Arianne Shahvisi, Mehrunisha Suleman, Lucy Frith, and Kenneth Boyd
    Journal of Medical Ethics 51 (6): 359-360. 2025.
    Medical ethics is not known for being a fast-paced discipline; many of the principles we draw on are 2000 years old. And yet, during John McMillan’s 7 -year tenure as editor of the Journal of Medical Ethics ( JME ), the journal has changed a great deal and has in turn changed the discipline. The issues discussed and the ethical concepts in play have broadened while the purpose itself has been refined to publish excellent medical ethics articles that are both philosophically sound and of practica…Read more
  •  129
    Augmenting research consent: should large language models (LLMs) be used for informed consent to clinical research?
    with Jemima W. Allen, Owen Schaefer, Sebastian Porsdam Mann, and Dominic Wilkinson
    Research Ethics 21 (4): 644-670. 2025.
    The integration of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs) like OpenAI’s ChatGPT, into clinical research could significantly enhance the informed consent process. This paper critically examines the ethical implications of employing LLMs to facilitate consent in clinical research. LLMs could offer considerable benefits, such as improving participant understanding and engagement, broadening participants’ access to the relevant information for informed consent and in…Read more
  •  108
    Respecting bodily integrity and autonomy in pediatric populations
    with Kate Goldie Townsend
    Clinical Ethics 19 (4): 285-290. 2024.
    Children are treated differently to adults in liberal societies with respect to their right to bodily integrity. A commonly given justification for treating them differently is that they supposedly lack the sort of autonomy that is normally attributed to neurotypical adults. As such children fall through the cracks when it comes to protecting their bodily integrity: they are viewed as less than fully autonomous persons in philosophical, medical, and legal settings. With this editorial, we analys…Read more