All the most important epistemological and ontological theses of Kuhn's theory of science depend to a decisive extent on corresponding ideas of Wittgenstein's theory of meaning. The semantic and ontological assumptions that determine the main trend of Kuhn's epistemology consist, respectively, of a theory of meaning as use or application of empirical terms to nature and an ontology that conceives the real as a continuous essentially amorphous and undifferentiated, in which only language and its …
Read moreAll the most important epistemological and ontological theses of Kuhn's theory of science depend to a decisive extent on corresponding ideas of Wittgenstein's theory of meaning. The semantic and ontological assumptions that determine the main trend of Kuhn's epistemology consist, respectively, of a theory of meaning as use or application of empirical terms to nature and an ontology that conceives the real as a continuous essentially amorphous and undifferentiated, in which only language and its rules can insert order and regularity, In Kuhn's theory of science, however, beside this main trend of thought, there is another one, by far secondary, which moves towards a realistic conception of scientific theories, although it usually stops halfway, assuming the aspect of an unsustainable and unoriginal indirect realism. After highlighting the oscillations and internal difficulties not only of Kuhn's epistemology and methodology, but also of the Wittgensteinian theory of meaning, the final part of the volume outlines a realistic conception of scientific knowledge that takes as its foundation the intrinsically cognitive nature of instrumental operations and tries to provide a satisfactory response to Kuhn's challenge and, in particular, to his thesis of incommensurability. From this point of view, the use and reference of scientific terms or theories are constitutive and inseparable moments of their meaning, and refer to an internally structured relational reality.