-
195Relevant logic and the theory of informationSynthese 109 (3). 1996.This paper provides an interpretation of the Routley-Meyer semantics for a weak negation-free relevant logic using Israel and Perry's theory of information. In particular, Routley and Meyer's ternary accessibility relation is given an interpretation in information-theoretic terms.
-
155A paraconsistent theory of belief revisionErkenntnis 56 (2). 2002.This paper presents a theory of belief revision that allows people to come tobelieve in contradictions. The AGM theory of belief revision takes revision,in part, to be consistency maintenance. The present theory replacesconsistency with a weaker property called coherence. In addition to herbelief set, we take a set of statements that she rejects. These two sets arecoherent if they do not overlap. On this theory, belief revision maintains coherence.
-
124The semantics ofrJournal of Philosophical Logic 22 (1). 1993.The Logic R4 is obtained by adding the axiom □(A v B) → (◇A v □B) to the modal relevant logic NR. We produce a model theory for this logic and show completeness. We also show that there is a natural embedding of a Kripke model for S4 in each R4 model structure
-
102The incompleteness of RGLStudia Logica 65 (3): 315-322. 2000.RGLis a version of the modal logic GLbased on the relevant logic R. It is shown that the class of RKframes that verify all theorems of RGLalso verify a scheme that we call (!). If RGLhas (!) as a theorem, however, it is not a relevant logic. I go on to show that not all instances of (!) are theorems of RGL, hence this logic is not complete over any class of RKframes.
-
105Semantics for relevance logic with identityStudia Logica 51 (1). 1992.Models are constructed for a variety of systems of quantified relevance logic with identity. Models are given for systems with different principles governing the transitivity of identity and substitution, and the relative merits of these principles are discussed. The models in this paper are all extensions of the semantics of Fine's Semantics for Quantified Relevance Logic (Journal of Philosophical Logic 17 (1988)).
-
184“Four-Valued” Semantics for the Relevant Logic RJournal of Philosophical Logic 33 (3): 327-341. 2004.This paper sets out two semantics for the relevant logic R based on Dunn's four-valued semantics for first-degree entailments. Unlike Routley's semantics for weak relevant logics, they do not use two ternary accessibility relations. Unlike Restall's semantics, they capture all of R. But there is a catch. Both of the present semantics are neighbourhood semantics, that is, they include sets of propositions in the specification of their frames
-
119Even dialetheists should hate contradictionsAustralasian Journal of Philosophy 78 (4). 2000.This Article does not have an abstract
-
98CE is not a conservative extension of EJournal of Philosophical Logic 29 (3): 263-275. 2000.The logic CE (for "Classical E") results from adding Boolean negation to Anderson and Belnap's logic E. This paper shows that CE is not a conservative extension of E
-
247A relevant theory of conditionalsJournal of Philosophical Logic 24 (6). 1995.In this paper we set out a semantics for relevant (counterfactual) conditionals. We combine the Routley-Meyer semantics for relevant logic with a semantics for conditionals based on selection functions. The resulting models characterize a family of conditional logics free from fallacies of relevance, in particular counternecessities and conditionals with necessary consequents receive a non-trivial treatment
-
199On SStudia Logica 53 (1). 1994.The sentential logic S extends classical logic by an implication-like connective. The logic was first presented by Chellas as the smallest system modelled by contraining the Stalnaker-Lewis semantics for counterfactual conditionals such that the conditional is effectively evaluated as in the ternary relations semantics for relevant logics. The resulting logic occupies a key position among modal and substructural logics. We prove completeness results and study conditions for proceeding from one f…Read more
-
61Gregory H. Moore , The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russell, Volume 5: Toward “Principia Mathematica”, London and New York: Routledge, 2014, c + 954 and 10 plates (review)Bulletin of Symbolic Logic 22 (2): 289-291. 2016.
-
The Semantic Completeness Of RkReports on Mathematical Logic 3-10. 1992.This paper extends the argument of Mares, ``Classically Complete Modal Relevant Logics'' Zeitschrift fur mathematische Logik und Grundlagen der Mathematik, to show that the system RK is complete over an Extension of the Routley-Meyer semantics.
-
15Relevant logic, probabilistic information, and conditionalsLogique Et Analyse 49 399-411. 2006.This paper sets out a theory of relevant conditional probability. The theory is motivated as a way of incorporating probabilistic inference into the theory of situated inference of [12]. The theory is then adapted to provide a theory of relevant conditional subjective probabilities and this latter theory is then used to provide a basis for a theory of indicative conditionals. © 2011 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
-
2Paraconsistent probability theory and paraconsistent bayesianismLogique Et Analyse 160 375-84. 1997.This paper presents a theory of probability based on the paraconsistent logic D4. The resulting probability functions are then used to define two sorts of Bayesian updating. One sort of updating merely uses the simple rule of conditionalisation. The other sort adds a wrinkle to the simple rule so that agents' beliefs become more consistent as well as more complete through updating.
-
152The nature of information: a relevant approachSynthese 175 (1). 2010.In "General Information in Relevant Logic" (Synthese 167, 2009), the semantics for relevant logic is interpreted in terms of objective information. Objective information is potential data that is available in an environment. This paper explores the notion of objective information further. The concept of availability in an environment is developed and used as a foundation for the semantics, in particular, as a basis for the understanding of the information that is expressed by relevant implicatio…Read more
-
185Relevant Logic and the Philosophy of MathematicsPhilosophy Compass 7 (7): 481-494. 2012.This paper sets out three programmes that attempt to use relevant logic as the basis for a philosophy of mathematics. Although these three programmes do not exhaust the possible approaches to mathematics through relevant logic, they are fairly representative of the current state of the field. The three programmes are compared and their relative strengths and weaknesses set out. At the end of the paper I examine the consequences of adopting each programme for the realist debate about mathematical…Read more
-
39I. The problem of Molinist conditionalsIn Ken Perszyk (ed.), Molinism: The Contemporary Debate, Oxford University Press. pp. 96. 2011.
-
1Logic and metaphysics : Dummett meets HeideggerIn James Williams, Edwin Mares, James Chase & Jack Reynolds (eds.), Postanalytic and Metacontinental: Crossing Philosophical Divides, Continuum. 2010.
-
30Can the mathematical structure of space be known a priori? A tale of two postulatesIn Vincenzo Fano, Francesco Orilia & Giovanni Macchia (eds.), Space and Time: A Priori and A Posteriori Studies, De Gruyter. pp. 107-136. 2014.
-
217General information in relevant logicSynthese 167 (2): 343-362. 2009.This paper sets out a philosophical interpretation of the model theory of Mares and Goldblatt (The Journal of Symbolic Logic 71, 2006). This interpretation distinguishes between truth conditions and information conditions. Whereas the usual Tarskian truth condition holds for universally quantified statements, their information condition is quite different. The information condition utilizes general propositions . The present paper gives a philosophical explanation of general propositions and arg…Read more
-
20Molinist ConditionalsIn Ken Perszyk (ed.), Molinism: The Contemporary Debate, Oxford University Press. pp. 96-117. 2011.This chapter distinguishes semantic and metaphysical problems facing Molinism. In the past thirty years, there has been a fair amount of uncertainty and confusion in the literature over the relationship between Molinist counterfactuals of freedom and the standard possible‐worlds semantics for counterfactuals. The authors show that Molinism is compatible with the standard semantics. They argue that two semantic arguments against Molinism‐the Might Argument and the Tie Argument—fail. Friends and f…Read more
-
17Halldén completeness and modal relevant logicLogique Et Analyse 46 59-76. 2003.This paper shows that a wide range of normal and non-normal modal relevant logics are Halldén-complete and also that there are some otherwise reasonable looking modal relevant logics that are not Hallden-complete. This paper is dedicated to Max Cresswell on the occasion of his 65th birthday. © 2011 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
-
64Editor's Introduction to C.I. Lewis and C.H. Langford 'A Note on Strict Implication'History and Philosophy of Logic 35 (1): 1-6. 2014.The article ‘A Note on Strict Implication’ was submitted for publication by C.I. Lewis and C.H. Langford but withdrawn in proof. The paper is, according to notes and letters by both Lewis and Langford, largely by Lewis. It constitutes an early attempt by Lewis to give meanings for the modal connectives using abstract objects. To be necessary, for example, is for a statement to have the same intension as a truth-functional tautology. This theory prefigures the view of Lewis's 1946 book, Analysis …Read more
-
108Belief Revision, Probabilism, and Logic ChoiceReview of Symbolic Logic 7 (4): 647-670. 2014.This paper presents a probabilist paraconsistent theory of belief revision. This theory is based on a very general theory of probability, that fits with a wide range of classical and nonclassical logics. The theory incorporates a version of Jeffrey conditionalisation as its method of updating. A Dutch book argument is given, and the theory is applied to the problem of choosing a logical system.
-
Victoria University of WellingtonSchool of History, Philosophy, Political Science and International RelationsProfessor
Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand