•  235
    Problem representation for refinement
    with H. Altay Guvenir
    Minds and Machines 2 (3): 267-282. 1992.
    In this paper we attempt to develop a problem representation technique which enables the decomposition of a problem into subproblems such that their solution in sequence constitutes a strategy for solving the problem. An important issue here is that the subproblems generated should be easier than the main problem. We propose to represent a set of problem states by a statement which is true for all the members of the set. A statement itself is just a set of atomic statements which are binary pred…Read more
  •  246
    Situated modeling of epistemic puzzles
    with Murat Ersan
    Logic Journal of the IGPL 3 (1): 51-76. 1995.
    Situation theory is a mathematical theory of meaning introduced by Jon Barwise and John Perry. It has evoked great theoretical interest and motivated the framework of a few ‘computational’ systems. PROSIT is the pioneering work in this direction. Unfortunately, there is a lack of real-life applications on these systems and this study is a preliminary attempt to remedy this deficiency. Here, we solve a group of epistemic puzzles using the constructs provided by PROSIT.
  •  302
    John Lyons, Linguistic Semantics: An Introduction (review)
    Natural Language Engineering 3 (1): 89-95. 1997.
    Sir John Lyons’s Linguistic Semantics: An Introduction (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1995) is a tolerable addition to the list of half a dozen or so impressive titles he has produced on linguistic subjects over the years. This book was initially planned to be a second edition of his Language, Meaning and Context (Lyons, 1981). However, in the end it turned out to be a successor and replacement. For it is, in the author’s words, a very different book compared to the 1981 volume: it …Read more
  •  249
    The use of situation theory in context modeling
    with Mehmet Surav
    Computational Intelligence 13 (3): 427-438. 1997.
    At the heart of natural language processing is the understanding of context dependent meanings. This paper presents a preliminary model of formal contexts based on situation theory. It also gives a worked-out example to show the use of contexts in lifting, i.e., how propositions holding in a particular context transform when they are moved to another context. This is useful in NLP applications where preserving meaning is a desideratum.
  •  141
    Situated semantics
    In Murat Aydede & P. Robbins (eds.), The Cambridge Handbook of Situated Cognition, Cambridge University Press. pp. 401-418. 2009.
    Situated semantics can be regarded as an attempt at placing situational context (context of situation) at the center of all discussions of meaning. Situation theory is a theory of information content that takes context very seriously. Individuals, properties, relations, and spatiotemporal locations are basic constructs of situation theory. Individuals are conceived as invariants; having properties and standing in relations, they tend to persist in time and space. An anchoring function binds the …Read more
  •  225
    Nonstandard set theories and information management
    with Mujdat Pakkan
    Journal of Intelligent Information Systems 6 5-31. 1996.
    The merits of set theory as a foundational tool in mathematics stimulate its use in various areas of artificial intelligence, in particular intelligent information systems. In this paper, a study of various nonstandard treatments of set theory from this perspective is offered. Applications of these alternative set theories to information or knowledge management are surveyed.
  •  242
    Issues in commonsense set theory
    with Mujdat Pakkan
    Artificial Intelligence Review 8 279-308. 1995.
    The success of set theory as a foundation for mathematics inspires its use in artificial intelligence, particularly in commonsense reasoning. In this survey, we briefly review classical set theory from an AI perspective, and then consider alternative set theories. Desirable properties of a possible commonsense set theory are investigated, treating different aspects like cumulative hierarchy, self-reference, cardinality, etc. Assorted examples from the ground-breaking research on the subject are …Read more
  •  132
    The mark of the mental
    Bilkent News 4 (27). 1998.
    This is a short introduction to the puzzling -- even mysterious -- subject that there is a place for minds in a material world.
  •  239
    Relational priming: obligational nitpicking
    Behavioral and Brain Sciences 31 (4): 378-379. 2008.
    According to the target article authors, initial experience with a circumstance primes a relation that can subsequently be applied to a different circumstance to draw an analogy. While I broadly agree with their claim about the role of relational priming in early analogical reasoning, I put forward a few concerns that may be worthy of further reflection.
  •  341
    John Barwise & Lawrence Moss, Vicious Circles: On the Mathematics of Non-Wellfounded Phenomena (review)
    Journal of Logic, Language and Information 6 (4): 460-464. 1997.
    This is a review of Vicious Circles: On the Mathematics of Non-Wellfounded Phenomena, written by Jon Barwise and Lawrence Moss and published by CSLI Publications in 1996.
  •  283
    Vladimir Lifschitz, ed., Formalizing Common Sense: Papers by John McCarthy (review)
    Artificial Intelligence 77 (2): 359-369. 1995.
    "Language has never been accessible to me in the way that it was for Sachs. I'm shut off from my own thoughts, trapped in a no-man's-land between feeling and articulation, and no matter how hard I try to express myself, I can rarely come up with more than a confused stammer. Sachs never had any of these difficulties. Words and things matched up for him, whereas for me they are constantly breaking apart, flying off in a hundred different directions. I spend most of my time picking up the pieces a…Read more
  •  155
    In search of intended meaning: investigating Barwise's equation $C_R(S, c) = P$
    Barwise and Situation Semantics, a Workshop Co-Located with CONTEXT 2003 Conference, Stanford, CA. 2003.
    Here, S is a sentence—or possibly a smaller or larger unit of meaningful expression for a language—that's written by an author and c is the circumstance in which S is used. R is defined as the language conventions holding between an author and a reader (or better yet, his readership). P, probably the most important part of the equation, is the content of S or, the intended meaning of the author. We assume that the communication between an author and a reader is limited only to written text. Cons…Read more
  •  133
    We take em-dash as our sample punctuation mark and examine its usage from a discourse perspective, using sentences from well-known corpora. We particularly comment on how dashes can give hints on information structure, focus, and anaphora. Throughout the paper Discourse Representation Theory is used as a framework.
  •  215
    Colin Allen & Michael Hand, Logic Primer (review)
    Journal of Logic and Computation 5 (2): 251-253. 1995.
    This a review of Logic Primer, written by Colin Allen and Michael Hand and published by MIT Press in 1992.
  •  549
    Editorial: Alan Turing and artificial intelligence
    Journal of Logic, Language and Information 9 (4): 391-395. 2000.
    The papers you will find in this special issue of JoLLI develop letter and spirit of Turing’s original contributions. They do not lazily fall back into the same old sofa, but follow – or question – the inspiring ideas of a great man in the search for new, more precise, conclusions. It is refreshing to know that the fertile landscape created by Alan Turing remains a source of novel ideas.
  •  203
    Jaap van der Does & Jan Van Eijk, eds., Quantifiers, Logic, and Language (review)
    Natural Language Engineering 4 (4): 363-382. 1998.
    This is a review of Quantifiers, Logic, and Language, edited by Jaap van der Does and Jan van Eijk, published by CSLI (Center for the Study of Language and Information) Publications, Stanford, CA, in 1996.
  •  290
    Introduction to the special issue on philosophical foundations of artificial intelligence
    Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Artificial Intelligence 12 (3): 247-250. 2000.
    This is the guest editor's introduction to a JETAI special issue on philosophical foundations of AI.
  •  356
    Contexts of social action: guest editors' introduction
    with Anita Fetzer
    Language and Communication 22 391-402. 2002.
    In traditional linguistic accounts of context, one thinks of the immediate features of a speech situation, that is, a situation in which an expression is uttered. Thus, features such as time, location, speaker, hearer and preceding discourse are all parts of context. But context is a wider and more transcendental notion than what these accounts imply. For one thing, context is a relational concept relating social actions and their surroundings, relating social actions, relating individual actors…Read more
  •  1041
    Burn all your textbooks
    Australasian Journal of Logic 14 (3). 2017.
    The standard propositional exposition of necessary and sufficient conditions, as available in introductory logic texts, leads to a contradiction. It should be abolished.
  •  124
    Guest editor's introduction: artificial intelligence
    Turkish Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences 9 (1). 2001.
    Founded in 1993, ELEKTRIK: Turkish Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences, has gradually become better known and is fast establishing itself as a research oriented publication outlet with high academic standards. In a modest attempt to advance this trend, this special issue of ELEKTRIK brings together five papers exemplifying the state of the art in artificial intelligence (AI). Written by experts, the papers are especially aimed at readers interested in gaining a better apprais…Read more
  •  179
    Context as a social construct
    In AAAI Fall Symposium on Context in Knowledge Representation and Natural Language, American Association For the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence Press. 1997.
    This position paper argues that in addition to the familiar approach using formal contexts, there is now a need in AI to study contexts as social constructs. As a successful example of the latter approach, I draw attention to 'interpretation' (in the sense of literary theory), viz. the reconstruction of intended meaning of a literary text that takes into account the context in which the author assumed the reader would place the text. An important contribution here comes from Harris (1988), enume…Read more
  •  172
    Guest editor’s introduction: situations and artificial intelligence
    Minds and Machines 8 (4): 475-477. 1998.
    In this special issue of Minds and Machines ("Situations and Artificial Intelligence") we take a close look at recent situation-theoretic research which has mostly originated within a philosophical framework but promises to have strong connotations for Artificial Intelligence workers. The seven papers which make up this special issue (three of the papers appear in Minds and Machines 9(1)) demonstrate the advantages of the situation-based approach towards problems with a definite AI flavor.
  •  212
    This is a review of From Discourse to Logic: Introduction to Modeltheoretic Semantics of Natural Language, Formal Logic and Discourse Representation Theory, written by Hans Kamp and Uwe Reyle and published by Kluwer Academic Publishers in 1993.
  •  150
    Information-based aspects of punctuation
    with Bilge Say
    In Bilge Say & Varol Akman (eds.), Intl. Workshop on Punctuation in Computational Linguistics, Santa Cruz, CA, June 1996, Association For Computational Linguistics. 1996.
    We offer a preliminary account of the information-based aspects of punctuation marks. We give our initial treatment within the Discourse Representation Theory and its segmented version. We hypothesize that this work will be useful in classifying the informational contributions of punctuation marks and bringing them to bear on the semantic characterization of written discourse.
  •  219
    The notion of context arises in assorted areas of artificial intelligence (AI), including knowledge representation, natural language processing, intelligent information retrieval, etc. Although the term ‘context’ is frequently employed in descriptions, explanations, and analyses of computer programs in these areas, its meaning is frequently left to the reader’s understanding. My aim in this paper is to offer a swift review of context in AI. I will first identify the role of context in various fi…Read more
  •  255
    Punctuation has so far attracted attention within the linguistics community mostly from a syntactic perspective. In this paper, we give a preliminary account of the information-based aspects of punctuation, drawing our points from assorted, naturally occurring sentences. We present our formal models of these sentences and the semantic contributions of punctuation marks. Our formalism is a simplified analogue of an extension --- due to Nicholas Asher --- of Discourse Representation Theory.
  •  155
    Contexts, oracles, and relevance
    with Mehmet Surav
    In Varol Akman & Mehmet Surav (eds.), Proceedings of the AAAI-95 Fall Symposium on Formalizing Context (AAAI Technical Report FS-95-02), Association For the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence Press. pp. 23-30. 1995.
    We focus on how we should define the relevance of information to a context for information processing agents, such as oracles. We build our formalization of relevance upon works in pragmatics which refer to contextual information without giving any explicit representation of context. We use a formalization of context (due to us) in Situation Theory, and demonstrate its power in this task. We also discuss some computational aspects of this formalization.
  •  196
    Answer Set Programming is a new paradigm based on logic programming. The main component of answer set programming is a system that finds the answer sets of logic programs. During the computation of an answer set, systems are faced with choice points where they have to select a literal and assign it a truth value. Generally, systems utilize some heuristics to choose new literals at the choice points. The heuristic used is one of the key factors for the performance of the system. A new heuristic fo…Read more
  •  154
    Using stable model semantics (SMODELS) in the causal calculator (CCALC)
    with Semra Dogandag and F. Nur Alpaslan
    In Semra Dogandag, F. Nur Alpaslan & Varol Akman (eds.), Proceedings of 10th Turkish Symposium on Artificial Intelligence and Neural Networks (TAINN), . 2001.
    Action Languages are formal methods of talking about actions and their effects on fluents. One recent approach in planning is to define the domains of the planning problems using action languages. The aim of this research is to find a plan for a system defined in the action language C by translating it into a causal theory and then finding an equivalent logic program. The planning problem will then be reduced to finding the answer set (stable model) of this logic program. This planner will be added as…Read more