-
88Parental Choice and Expert Knowledge in the Debate about MMR and AutismIn Angus Dawson & Marcel Verweij (eds.), Ethics, Prevention, and Public Health, Clarendon Press. 2007.I shall argue that where a coercive public health policy is backed by a clear medical consensus, appropriately reconsidered in the light of claims of doubters, there is sometimes a moral obligation on the part of the public to defer to the experts. The argument will be geared to the continuing controversy in the UK over the safety of the measles/mumps/rubella (MMR) vaccine. vaccine
-
12The normative and the explanatory in Hobbes's political philosophyRivista di Storia Della Filosofia 1. 2004.Tom Sorell modifies an interpretation he presented in his book, Hobbes (1986) . He continues to maintain that Hobbesian natural philosophy and Hobbesian civil philosophy are methodologically quite distinct, as well as distinct in subject-matter. But it is misleading to put this by saying that civil philosophy is normative and natural philosophy is explanatory, as if civil philosophy itself weren’t supposed to be explanatory. Civil philosophy can be explanatory in the sense of specifying normativ…Read more
-
The Burdensome Freedom of SovereignsIn Tom Sorell & Luc Foisneau (eds.), Leviathan After 350 Years, Clarendon Press. 2004.The freedom of A Hobbesian sovereign is limited by the freedom of other sovereigns but is otherwise extremely extensive. The other side of the coin of this wide latitude, however, are the huge responsibilities and practical challenges of seeing to the good of the people. This involves both the compulsion of obedience and the permission of enterprise on the part of the many. It also calls for equity in the application of law. Overall, the burdensomeness of sovereignty probably vastly outweighs th…Read more
-
30Online Grooming and Preventive JusticeCriminal Law and Philosophy 11 (4): 705-724. 2017.In England and Wales, Section 15 of the Sexual Offences Act criminalizes the act of meeting a child—someone under 16—after grooming. The question to be pursued in this paper is whether grooming—I confine myself to online grooming—is justly criminalized. I shall argue that it is. One line of thought will be indirect. I shall first try to rebut a general argument against the criminalization of acts that are preparatory to the commission of serious offences. Grooming is one such act, but there are …Read more
-
54The customer is not always rightJournal of Business Ethics 13 (11). 1994.Consumers can sustain markets that are morally questionable. They can make immoral or morally suspect demands of individual businesses, especially small businesses. Even when they do not, the costs to firms of consumer protection can sometimes drive them to ruin. This paper presents cases where deference to the consumer is variously unwarranted, cases that may prompt second thoughts about some kinds of consumerism.
-
Schmitt, Hobbes and the politics of emergencyFilozofski Vestnik 24 (2): 223-241. 2003.This paper discusses the disanalogies between Schmitt and Hobbes on responses to emergencies, such as civil disorder. (The paper engages with literature that claims a greater common ground between the two figures than there actually is.)
-
46Self, Society and Kantian ImpersonalityThe Monist 74 (1): 30-42. 1991.What view of the person must prevail in a society that claims to be just? There is supposed to be a Kantian answer to this question, according to which people must regard themselves and their fellows as free, equal and capable to acting rationally. In A Theory of Justice Rawls tries to give content to the idea of free, equal and rational persons, but in such a way, according to certain critics, that social relations between these figures appear impoverished. Sandel, for example, has described a …Read more
-
40Preventive Policing, Surveillance, and European Counter-TerrorismCriminal Justice Ethics 30 (1): 1-22. 2011.A European Union counter-terrorism strategy was devised in 2005.1 Of its four strands—prevent, pursue, protect, and respond—only two have a direct connection with policing. Perhaps surprisingly, th...
-
Seventeenth-century materialismIn G. H. R. Parkinson (ed.), The Renaissance and Seventeenth-Century Rationalism, Routledge. 1993.An article focusing on Hobbes and Gassendi
-
168Robot carers, ethics, and older peopleEthics and Information Technology 16 (3): 183-195. 2014.This paper offers an ethical framework for the development of robots as home companions that are intended to address the isolation and reduced physical functioning of frail older people with capacity, especially those living alone in a noninstitutional setting. Our ethical framework gives autonomy priority in a list of purposes served by assistive technology in general, and carebots in particular. It first introduces the notion of “presence” and draws a distinction between humanoid multi-functio…Read more
-
49The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes (edited book)Cambridge University Press. 1996.It was as a political thinker that Thomas Hobbes first came to prominence, and it is as a political theorist that he is most studied today. Yet the range of his writings extends well beyond morals and politics. Hobbes had distinctive views in metaphysics and epistemology, and wrote about such subjects as history, law, and religion. He also produced full-scale treatises in physics, optics, and geometry. All of these areas are covered in this Companion, most in considerable detail. The volume also…Read more
-
2On saying no to history of philosophyIn Tom Sorell & Graham Alan John Rogers (eds.), Analytic Philosophy and History of Philosophy, Oxford University Press. 2005.History of philosophy can be useful and relevant as philosophy even when philosophy is thought to be the solution of ahistorically formulated problems.
-
43Morality, consumerism and the internal market in health careJournal of Medical Ethics 23 (2): 71-76. 1997.Unlike the managerially oriented reforms that have brought auditing and accounting into such prominence in the UK National Health Service (NHS), and which seem alien to the culture of the caring professions, consumerist reforms may seem to complement moves towards the acceptance of wide definitions of health, and towards increasing patient autonomy. The empowerment favoured by those who support patient autonomy sounds like the sort of empowerment that is sometimes associated with the patient's c…Read more
-
4The Rise of Modern Philosophy: The Tension Between the New and Traditional Philosophies From Machiavelli to Leibniz (edited book)Oxford University Press UK. 1993.`Modern' philosophy in the West is said to have begun with Bacon and Descartes. Their methodological and metaphysical writings, in conjunction with the discoveries that marked the seventeenth-century scientific revolution, are supposed to have interred both Aristotelian and scholastic science and the philosophy that supported it. But did the new or `modern' philosophy effect a complete break with what preceded it? Were Bacon and Descartes untainted by scholastic influences? The theme of this boo…Read more
-
149Scientism: philosophy and the infatuation with scienceRoutledge. 1991.SCIENTISM AND 'SCIENTIFIC EMPIRICISM' WHAT IS SCIENTISM? Scientism is the belief that science, especially natural science, is much the most valuable part of ...
-
49Morality and EmergencyProceedings of the Aristotelian Society 103 (1): 21-37. 2003.Agents sometimes feel free to resort to underhand or brutal measures in coping with an emergency. Because emergencies seem to relax moral inhibitions as well as carrying the risk of great loss of life or injury, it may seem morally urgent to prevent them or curtail them as far as possible. I discuss some cases of private emergency that go against this suggestion. Prevention seems morally urgent primarily in the case of public emergencies. But these are the responsibility of defensibly partisan a…Read more
-
33Law and equity in HobbesCritical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 19 (1): 29-46. 2016.Equity is clearly central to Hobbes’s theory of the laws of nature, and it has an important place in his doctrine of the duties and exercise of sovereignty. It is also prominent in his general theory of law, especially as it is articulated in the late Dialogue between a Philosopher and a Student of the Common Laws of England. Still, it is not more central to Hobbes’s ethics, politics and legal philosophy than his concept of justice, or even as central. On the contrary, his theory of justice is p…Read more
-
7Hobbes without DoubtHistory of Philosophy Quarterly 10 (2). 1993.Contrary to Richard Popkin and Richard Tuck, here is no good evidence that Hobbes was impressed by philosophical scepticism, even to the extent of being consciously post-sceptical.
-
29Hobbes's Objections and Hobbes's SystemIn Roger Ariew & Marjorie Glicksman Grene (eds.), Descartes and His Contemporaries: Meditations, Objections, and Replies, University of Chicago Press. pp. 83--96. 1995.This paper surveys the many misunderstandings of Descartes Meditations in Hobbes' objections --the third set--issued in 1641. Some of the understanding can be traced to different understandings of philosophy or science, as well as differences over the importance epistemological scepticism.
-
Kant's Good Will and our Good Nature. Second Thoughts about Henson and HermannKant Studien 78 (1): 87. 1987.
-
57Kant good will and our good nature--2nd thoughts about Henson and HermanKant Studien 78 (1): 87-101. 1987.This paper considers whether right action in Kant can be over-determined, and takes issue with interpretations put forward by Richard Henson and Barbara Herman.
-
39L'état de nature de Hobbes dans la philosophie anglo-saxonne contemporaine : Gauthier, Hampton et GrayLes Etudes Philosophiques 79 (4): 461. 2006.Les usages que fait Hobbes de l’état de nature sont souvent mal compris par les philosophes anglo-américains contemporains, y compris par des commentateurs distingués comme Gauthier et Hampton. À la différence de Gauthier, je soutiens que Hobbes ne se soucie nullement de naturaliser le fondement de la motivation morale, et je conteste l’interprétation de Hampton qui considère que le contractualisme hobbesien a plus de pertinence pour nous aujourd’hui que le contractualisme kantien. Il existe cer…Read more
-
14Hobbes's UnAristotelian Political RhetoricPhilosophy and Rhetoric 23 (2). 1990.A review of those areas in which Hobbes breaks with Aristotle on the nature and uses of rhetoric.
University of Oxford
DPhil, 1978
Areas of Specialization
Value Theory |
History of Western Philosophy |
Metaphysics and Epistemology |
Other Academic Areas |