-
52
-
140Offsetting the harms of extinctionLaw, Ethics and Philosophy 3 8-29. 2015.Many people assume that the extinction of humanity would be a bad thing. This article scrutinizes this apparent badness and demonstrates that on most plausible consequentialist frameworks, the extinction of humanity is not necessarily bad. The best accounts of the badness of the extinction of humanity focus on the loss of potential utility, but this loss can be offset if it is the result of sufficiently large gains by the present generation. Plausible means of calculating the goodness of outcome…Read more
-
98The Complex Structure of Health RightsPublic Health Ethics 13 (1): 99-110. 2020.Research on how to understand legally recognized socio-economic rights produced many insights into the nature of rights. Legally recognized rights to health and, by extension, health care could contribute to health justice. Yet a tension remains between widespread international and transnational constitutional recognition of rights to health and health care and compelling normative conditions for rights recognition from both philosophers seeking to identify the scope and structure of the rights …Read more
-
86Public Reason and the Need to Identify State-Relevant DesertCriminal Justice Ethics 33 (2): 129-154. 2014.Plausible retributivist justifications for punishment assert that the commission of a moral wrong creates a pro tanto reason to punish the person who committed it. Yet there are good case-based and theoretical reasons to believe that not all moral wrongs are the proper subjects of criminal law or that they are within the proper domain of the state. This article provides these reasons, which suggest that a plausible retributivist justification for punishment must make distinctions between state-r…Read more
-
44Quantifying Desert Prior to the Rightful Condition: Towards a Theoretical Understanding of the Provocation DefenceCanadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 26 (1): 49-82. 2013.The provocation defence, which militates against full legal responsibility for unjustified killings in several common law jurisdictions, has been the subject of considerable controversy during recent decades. Much of the criticism focused on substantive legal issues. This article examines the philosophical bases for the defence in hopes of establishing a theoretical groundwork for future debate on the legal defence. The defence originated on desert bases and continues to be understood on those g…Read more
-
137Assisted Death: A Study in Law and Ethics L.W. Sumner Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011; 248 pp.; $65.00Dialogue 51 (3): 531-534. 2012.Book Reviews MICHAEL DA SILVA, Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review/Revue canadienne de philosophie, FirstView Article.
-
65COVID-19 and Health-Related Authority Allocation PuzzlesCambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 30 (1): 25-36. 2021.COVID-19-related controversies concerning the allocation of scarce resources, travel restrictions, and physical distancing norms each raise a foundational question: How should authority, and thus responsibility, over healthcare and public health law and policy be allocated? Each controversy raises principles that support claims by traditional wielders of authority in “federal” countries, like federal and state governments, and less traditional entities, like cities and sub-state nations. No exis…Read more
-
92Dual-Role Research and Consent by Unique SpecialistsAmerican Journal of Bioethics 19 (4): 46-48. 2019.