-
62Applying semantic concepts to the media assigment problem in multi-media communicationIn Keith Stenning & Robert Inder (eds.), [Book Chapter], Springer Verlag. pp. 303-338. 1995.Our long term goal is an understanding of human communication in terms which would provide the basis for rational design. The kernel would be a theory of the cognitive consequences of allocating the same information to different media and modalities, based on the user's information processing characterised in computational terms. Our theory of the cognitive consequences of media/modality allocation starts from an analysis of differences in logical expressiveness of graphical and linguistic repre…Read more
-
161Theories of diagrammatic reasoning: Distinguishing component problems (review)Minds and Machines 8 (4): 533-557. 1998.Theories of diagrams and diagrammatic reasoning typically seek to account for either the formal semantics of diagrams, or for the advantages which diagrammatic representations hold for the reasoner over other forms of representation. Regrettably, almost no theory exists which accounts for both of these issues together, nor how they affect one another. We do not attempt to provide such an account here. We do, however, seek to lay out larger context than is generally used for examining the process…Read more
-
1Embedding logic in communication: lessons from the logic classroomIn Johan van Benthem (ed.), Logic and argumentation, North-holland. pp. 227--240. 1996.
-
Assigning Information to Modalities Comparing Graphical Treatments of the SyllogismHcrc Publications, University of Edinburgh. 1995.
-
157To Naturalize or Not to Naturalize? An Issue for Cognitive Science as Well as AnthropologyTopics in Cognitive Science 4 (3): 413-419. 2012.Several of Beller, Bender, and Medin’s (2012) issues are as relevant within cognitive science as between it and anthropology. Knowledge-rich human mental processes impose hermeneutic tasks, both on subjects and researchers. Psychology's current philosophy of science is ill suited to analyzing these: Its demand for ‘‘stimulus control’’ needs to give way to ‘‘negotiation of mutual interpretation.’’ Cognitive science has ways to address these issues, as does anthropology. An example from my own wor…Read more
-
1Effects of representational modality and thinking style on learning to solve reasoning problemsIn Morton Ann Gernsbacher & Sharon J. Derry (eds.), Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, Lawerence Erlbaum. pp. 716--721. 1998.
-
53Image and language in human reasoning: A syllogistic illustrationCognitive Psychology 34 109--159. 1997.Existing accounts of syllogistic reasoning oppose rule-based and model-based methods. Stenning \& Oberlander show that the latter are isomorphic to well-known graphical methods, when these are correctly interpreted. We here extend these results by showing that equivalent sentential implementations exist, thus revealing that all these theories are members of a family of abstract {\it individual identification algorithms} variously implemented in diagrams or sentences. This abstract logical analys…Read more
-
111Aligning logical and psychological perspectives on diagrammatic reasoningArtificial Intelligence Review 15 29--62. 2001.We advance a theoretical framework which combines recent insights of research in logic, psychology, and formal semantics, on the nature of diagrammatic representation and reasoning. In particular, we wish to explain the varied efficacy of reasoning and representing with diagrams. In general we consider diagrammatic representations to be restricted in expressive power, and we wish to explain efficacy of reasoning with diagrams via the semantical and computational properties of such restricted `la…Read more
-
179Throwing the normative baby out with the prescriptivist bathwaterBehavioral and Brain Sciences 34 (5): 249-249. 2011.It is neither desirable nor possible to eliminate normative concerns from the psychology of reasoning. Norms define the most fundamental psychological questions: What are people trying to do, and how? Even if no one system of reasoning can be the norm, pure descriptivism is as undesirable and unobtainable in the psychology of reasoning as elsewhere in science.