-
1426Voittiko Messi vai Voittiko Barcelona? Jalkapallojoukkueiden olemisen tavastaIn Jussi Antti Saarinen & Mikael Vilhelm Melan (eds.), Sokrateen syöksypusku –jalkapallon filosofiaa, Docendo. pp. 54-69. 2014.Title in English: Did Messi win or did Barcelona? On the way of being of soccer teams.
-
1111Why Realists Need TropesMetaphysica 17 (1): 69-85. 2016.We argue that if one wishes to be a realist, one should adopt a Neo-Aristotelian ontology involving tropes instead of a Russellian ontology of property universals and objects. Either Russellian realists should adopt the relata-specific relational tropes of instantiation instead of facts, or convert to Neo-Aristotelian realism with monadic tropes. Regarding Neo-Aristotelian realism, we have two novel points why it fares better than Russellian realism. Instantiation of property universals by trope…Read more
-
969Quantity Tropes and Internal RelationsErkenntnis 84 (3): 519-534. 2019.In this article, we present a new conception of internal relations between quantity tropes falling under determinates and determinables. We begin by providing a novel characterization of the necessary relations between these tropes as basic internal relations. The core ideas here are that the existence of the relata is sufficient for their being internally related, and that their being related does not require the existence of any specific entities distinct from the relata. We argue that quantit…Read more
-
878The Problem of Trope Individuation: A Reply to LoweErkenntnis 79 (1): 65-79. 2014.This paper is the first trope-theoretical reply to E. J. Lowe’s serious dilemma against trope nominalism in print. The first horn of this dilemma is that if tropes are identity dependent on substances, a vicious circularity threatens trope theories because they must admit that substances are identity dependent on their constituent tropes. According to the second horn, if the trope theorist claims that tropes are identity independent, she faces two insurmountable difficulties. (1) It is hard to u…Read more
-
789Muisti (edited book)Tampere University Press. 2013.Proceedings of the annual congress of the Finnish Philosophical Association in 2013. Theme: memory.
-
652The Ontological Form of Tropes - Refuting Douglas Ehring’s Main Argument against Standard Trope NominalismPhilosophia 45 (2): 647-658. 2017.According to standard trope nominalism, there are simple tropes that do not have parts or multiply distinct aspects. Douglas Ehring’s reductio ad absurdum against this standard view concludes that there are no simple tropes. In this paper, we provide a response to Ehring defending the standard view. Ehring’s argument may be refuted by (1) distinguishing the ontological form of tropes from their contribution to the ontological content of the world, and (2) construing tropes as having primitive id…Read more
-
628Persistence of Simple SubstancesMetaphysica 11 (2): 119-135. 2010.In this paper, we argue for a novel three-dimensionalist solution to the problem of persistence, i.e. cross-temporal identity. We restrict the discussion of persistence to simple substances, which do not have other substances as their parts. The account of simple substances employed in the paper is a trope-nominalist strong nuclear theory, which develops Peter Simons' trope nominalism. Regarding the distinction between three dimensionalism and four dimensionalism, we follow Michael Della Rocca's…Read more
-
594Kinds of Tropes without KindsDialectica 72 (4): 571-596. 2018.In this article, we propose a new trope nominalist conception of determinate and determinable kinds of quantitative tropes. The conception is developed as follows. First, we formulate a new account of tropes falling under the same determinates and determinables in terms of internal relations of proportion and order. Our account is a considerable improvement on the current standard account (Campbell 1990; Maurin 2002; Simons 2003) because it does not rely on primitive internal relations of exact …Read more
-
520Kind Instantiation and Kind Change - A Problem for Four-Category OntologyStudia Neoaristotelica 14 (2): 139-165. 2017.In Lowe’s Four-Category Ontology, instantiation is a basic formal ontological relation between particulars (objects, modes) and their kinds (kinds, attributes). Therefore, instantiation must be considered as a metaphysically necessary relation, which also rules out the metaphysical possibility of kind change. Nevertheless, according to Lowe, objects obtain their identity conditions in a more general level than specific natural kinds, which allows for kind change. There also seems to be actual ex…Read more
-
477Bradley's Reductio of Relations and Formal Ontological RelationsIn Hemmo Laiho & Arto Repo (eds.), DE NATURA RERUM - Scripta in honorem professoris Olli Koistinen sexagesimum annum complentis, University of Turku. pp. 246-261. 2016.In this paper, we argue that formal ontological relations avoid Bradley's reductio of relations, including his famous relation regress.
-
433Metafysiikka valistuksenaIn Hemmo Laiho (ed.), Valistuksen perinnöt: Suomen Filosofisen Yhdistyksen kollokvion esitelmiä, University of Turku. pp. 37-48. 2022.Kirjoituksessa argumentoin, että metafysiikka on ollut valistusta, vaikka se edelleen kaipaa lisää valistumista, kun valistus ymmärretään avoimena prosessina, joka ei ole ajasta ja paikasta riippuvaista. Käsittelen ensin sitä, mitä metafysiikka ja valistus ovat. Sitten lausun länsimaisen metafysiikan historiasta hyvin lyhyesti. Päätän esseen argumentoimalla, että metafysiikka on valistunutta siinä mielessä, että klassisen substanssi-ominaisuus-skeeman sokeasta seuraamisesta on pitkälti päästy er…Read more
-
431Bradley’s Relation Regress and the Inadequacy of the Relata-Specific AnswerActa Analytica 38 (2): 229-243. 2022.F. H. Bradley’s relation regress poses a difficult problem for metaphysics of relations. In this paper, we reconstruct this regress argument systematically and make its presuppositions explicit in order to see where the possibility of its solution or resolution lies. We show that it cannot be answered by claiming that it is not vicious. Neither is one of the most promising resolutions, the relata-specific answer adequate in its present form. It attempts to explain adherence (relating), which is …Read more
-
406Hume on Spatial PropertiesIn Ghislain Guigon & Gonzalo Rodríguez Pereyra (eds.), Nominalism About Properties: New Essays, Routledge. pp. 79-94. 2015.I defend a reading of David Hume’s nominalism that he comes close to Keith Campbell's contemporary trope theory in the specific case of spatial properties. I argue that Hume's view should be construed as classifying spatial properties as Campbellian tropes (particular properties): abstract, particular, determinate and qualitatively simple properties. This has implications for reconstructing Hume's answer to the problem of universals. I argue that Hume’s account of objects resembling each other i…Read more
-
399What are Tropes, Fundamentally? A Formal Ontological AccountActa Philosophica Fennica 94 129-159. 2018.In this paper, I elaborate on the Strong Nuclear Theory (SNT) of tropes and substances, which I have defended elsewhere, using my metatheory about formal ontology and especially fundamental ontological form. According to my metatheory, for an entity to have an ontological form is for it to be a relatum of a formal ontological relation or relations jointly in an order. The full fundamental ontological form is generically identical to a simple formal ontological relation or relations jointly in an…Read more
-
393Metametafysiikkaa kategorioilla ja ilmanAjatus 73 225-253. 2016.Title in English translation: Metametaphysics - with and without Categories. A comment paper on An Introduction to Metametaphysics by Tuomas Tahko. Ehdotan artikkelissa uutta olevan ja sen muodon välistä erottelua. Erottelun avulla voidaan antaa täsmällinen käsitys ontologisen kategorian käsitteestä ja metafysiikan tutkimuskohteesta. Argumentoin myös, että metafysiikan epistemologiaa ja semantiikkaa sekä metafyysistä selitttämistä pitää lähestyä kategorianäkökulmasta. Artikkeli on kommentti Tuom…Read more
-
389Taxonomy of Relations: Internal and ExternalIn Daniele Bertini & Damiano Migliorini (eds.), Relations. Ontology and Philosophy of Religion, Mimesis International. pp. 93-121. 2018.In this paper, we discern different types of possible relations. We focus on the distinction between internal and external relations and their various possible sub-types. In the first section, we present what is nowadays more or less the standard distinction between internal and external relations. In the second section, we make two contributions to the literature of internal relations: a new taxonomy of internal relations and a novel distinction between formal and material ontological relation…Read more
-
383Kaila's Reception of HumeActa Philosophica Fennica 89 147-162. 2012.In this paper, I discuss Eino Kaila's (1890-1958) understanding of David Hume. Kaila was one of the leading Finnish philosophers of the 20th century and a correspondent of the Vienna Circle. He introduced logical empiricism into Finland and taught Georg Henrik von Wright. Final draft
-
289Käytäntöjen metodisista funktioista Humen filosofiakäsityksessäIn Pihlström Sami, Rolin Kristina & Ruokonen Floora (eds.), Käytäntö, Yliopistopaino. pp. 155-162. 2002.Title in English: Of the Methodological Functions of Practices in Hume's Conception of Philosophy
-
277The handout of my talk at the Nordic Network in Metaphysics webinar on Friday 2/10/2020
-
237Formal OntologyCambridge University Press. 2023.Formal ontology as a main branch of metaphysics investigates categories of being. In the formal ontological approach to metaphysics, these ontological categories are analysed by ontological forms. This analysis, which we illustrate by some category systems, provides a tool to assess the clarity, exactness and intelligibility of different category systems or formal ontologies. We discuss critically different accounts of ontological form in the literature. Of ontological form, we propose a charact…Read more
-
200Humen pyrrhonismin kieltoIn Heta Gylling, S. Albert Kivinen & Risto Vilkko (eds.), Kielto, Helsinki University Press. pp. 29-35. 2004.Title in English: Hume's Denial of Pyrrhonism
-
198Concrete Universals and Spatial RelationsEuropean Journal of Analytic Philosophy 11 (1): 57-71. 2015.According to strong immanent realism, proposed for instance by David M. Armstrong, universals are concrete, located in their instances. E.J. Lowe and Douglas Ehring have presented arguments to the effect that strong immanent realism is incoherent. Cody Gilmore has defended strong immanent realism against the charge of incoherence. Gilmore’s argument has thus far remained unanswered. We argue that Gilmore’s response to the charge of incoherence is an ad hoc move without support independent of str…Read more
-
191A Third Type of Distinction in the TreatiseHume Studies 38 (1): 55-78. 2012.In this paper, I resolve a potential contradiction between two of Hume's central tenets: that complex perceptions consist of simple perceptions and that distinct things are separable. The former implies that a complex perception is not separable from its constituent simple perceptions, as a change in its constituents destroys its identity. The latter entails that the complex perception is separable from these simple perceptions, since it is distinct from them. This is a contradiction. I resolve …Read more
-
187Kontekstualistinen vastaus Agrippan argumentilleIn Pietarinen Ahti, Pihlström Sami & Toppinen Pilvi (eds.), Usko, Juvenes Print. pp. 93-98. 2009.Title in English: : A Contextualist Answer to Agrippa's Argument
-
186Humen teoria avaruuden ymmärtämisestäIn Valtteri Viljanen, Helena Siipi & Matti Sintonen (eds.), Ymmärrys, Uniprint. pp. 67-75. 2012.Title in English: Hume's Theory of Understanding Space
-
174Humen syyn määritelmäIn Heta Gylling, Ilkka Niiniluoto & Risto Vilkko (eds.), Syy, Suomen Filosofinen Yhdistys. 2007.Title in English: Hume's Definition of Cause. Esitän artikkelissa tulkintani Humen kuuluisista kahdesta määritelmästä ”syylle”. Väitteeni on, että Hume ei esitä kahta erillistä määritelmää, joiden suhde olisi ongelmallinen, vaan syyn kahden oleellisen aspektin määritelmät. Yhdistänkin lopuksi määritelmät yhdeksi Humen syyn määritelmäksi. Artikkelini on luonteeltaan tulkitseva ja väittävä. Tarkoituksenani on tulkita erästä kausaliteetin klassikkoa mahdollisimman tarkasti ja siten estää tiettyjä t…Read more
-
156Hume's Scepticism and RealismBritish Journal for the History of Philosophy 20 (2): 283-309. 2012.In this article, a novel interpretation of one of the problems of Hume scholarship is defended: his view of Metaphysical Realism or the belief in an external world (that there are ontologically and causally perception-independent, absolutely external and continued, i.e. Real entities). According to this interpretation, Hume's attitude in the domain of philosophy should be distinguished from his view in the domain of everyday life: Hume the philosopher suspends his judgement on Realism, whereas H…Read more
-
137Hume on the Unity of Determinations of ExtensionHistory of Philosophy & Logical Analysis 22 (1). 2019.We do not fully understand Hume’s account of space if we do not understand his view of determinations of extension, which is too much ignored a topic. In this paper, I argue for an interpretation that determinations of extension are unities in Hume’s view: single beings in addition to their components. This realist reading is reasonable on both textual and philosophical grounds. There is strong textual evidence for it and no textual reason to reject it. Realism makes perfect sense of the metaphy…Read more
-
126Learning from the Past to the Future in MetaphysicsIn Jani Sinokki & Eero Kaila (eds.), Acta Philosophica Fennica XCVIII, Finnish Philosophical Society. pp. 125-141. 2023.I propose that metaphysical study is initially indifferent to the truth of Metaphysical Realism about Metaphysics (MRM) and Metaphysical Realism and does not presuppose them. Metaphysical Realism is a metaphysical doctrine the truth of which cannot be settled logically prior to metaphysical investigation. MRM presupposes Metaphysical Realism and therefore, one should not hold MRM uncritically. An epistemological consequence of this is that arguments against the possibility of cognition about met…Read more
-
121Hume’s Argument for the Ontological Independence of Simple PropertiesMetaphysica 12 (2): 197-212. 2011.In this paper, I will reconstruct Hume's argument for the ontological (in the sense of rigid existential) independence of simple properties in A Treatise of Human Nature , Book 1 (1739). According to my reconstruction, the main premises of the argument are the real distinctness of every perception of a simple property, Hume's Separability Principle and his Conceivability Principle. In my view, Hume grounds the real distinctness of every perception of a simple property in his atomistic theory of …Read more
Tampere, Finland
Areas of Specialization
1 more
Metaphysics |
David Hume |
Ontological Categories |
Tropes |
Relations |
Metaontology |