-
38Holism and indeterminacyDialectica 45 (1): 47-58. 1991.SummaryDonald Davidson's account of the interrelation between attitudes, and linguistic and non‐linguistic behaviour is a thoroughly holistic one. The project of radical interpretation itself embodies a holistic approach to the interpretative task. Yet Davidson also accepts a degree of indeterminacy in interpretation. Davidson's commitment to both holism and indeterminacy can give rise to a problem in the Davidsonian position. That problem is explained and a solution proposed. The indeterminacy …Read more
-
10Why Philosophy? (edited book)De Gruyter. 2019.Do we really need philosophy? The present collection of jargon-free essays aims at answering the question of why philosophy matters. Each essay considers the central question from different angles: the unavoidability of doing philosophy, the practical consequences of philosophy, philosophy as a therapy for the whole person, the benefits of philosophy for improving public policy, etc.
-
Reality: Fundamental Topics in Metaphysics (review)Review of Metaphysics 56 (3): 663-664. 2003.Although often taken to lie at the very heart of philosophical inquiry, metaphysics has, at least since the time of Hume and Kant, frequently been surrounded by uncertainty and doubt as to its nature, possibility, and significance. The dominance of idealist philosophy in the late nineteenth century, and the reaction against it in the early twentieth, was often seen in terms of the dominance and subsequent decline of metaphysical styles of thought. Indeed, during the first half of the twentieth c…Read more
-
39Assessing the significance of Heidegger's Black NotebooksGeographica Helvetica 73 (1): 109-114. 2018.The publication of Heidegger's Black Notebooks has provoked a storm of controversy. Much of this has centred on the pro-Nazi and anti-Semitic comments the volumes contain. But these aspects of the Notebooks are perhaps the least surprising and important. This essay offers a summary overview of the issues to which the Notebooks give rise, at the same time as it also aims to provide a preliminary assessment of their overall significance, especially in relation to what they show about the nature an…Read more
-
33On Overestimating Philosophy: Lessons from Heidegger’s Black NotebooksJournal of Aesthetics and Phenomenology 4 (2): 183-195. 2017.In this paper we discuss Heidegger’s conception of philosophy in the Black Notebooks. In particular, we set out a reading of the Notebooks from the 1930s and early 1940s as exhibiting an extremist view of philosophy, and its concern with being, which accords it an absolute and exclusive priority above and beyond everything else. We argue that such overcompensation for philosophy’s declining fortune involves a willful turning away from the realities of human life, and from the multifarious symbol…Read more
-
22In the Vicinity of the HumanInternational Journal of Philosophical Studies 25 (3): 423-436. 2017.Beginning with the situated character of the question concerning the human, this paper argues that the problem of the human is itself inextricably bound to the problem of situation or place. Consequently, any genuine philosophical anthropology must take the form of a philosophical topology. This line of argument is developed through the work Abraham Heschel, Martin Heidegger, Martin Buber, and also Helmut Plessner.
-
17Holism and IndeterminacyDialectica 45 (1): 47-58. 1991.SummaryDonald Davidson's account of the interrelation between attitudes, and linguistic and non‐linguistic behaviour is a thoroughly holistic one. The project of radical interpretation itself embodies a holistic approach to the interpretative task. Yet Davidson also accepts a degree of indeterminacy in interpretation. Davidson's commitment to both holism and indeterminacy can give rise to a problem in the Davidsonian position. That problem is explained and a solution proposed. The indeterminacy …Read more
-
8The Nature of Interpretative CharityDialectica 42 (1): 17-36. 1988.SummaryIn Davidson's Theory of radical interpretation the principle of charity plays a crucial role. However the principle is the subject of widespread misunderstanding. The author attempts to provide an overall account of the principle and in doing so details some aspects of the holism which characterises the Davidsonian approach to interpretation. Charity is shown as inseparable from that holism. Two aspects of the principle are distinguished and some objections to the principle are also consi…Read more
-
Transcendental Arguments and Conceptual Schemes. A Resonsideration of Körner's Uniqueness ArgumentSociété Française de Philosophie, Bulletin 81 (2): 232. 1990.
-
16Shanks, King-Farlow, and the Refutation of DavidsonIdealistic Studies 18 (1): 20-31. 1988.In a recent number of this journal there appeared an article by Niall Shanks and John King-Farlow on the theory of radical interpretation as developed by Donald Davidson. In that paper Davidson was presented as an opponent of “metaphysical openness in general [and] … idealism in particular” and as a philosopher who has “sought to silence all philosophically challenging talk both about the ordinary speaker’s systematic errors and about the claims of revisionary metaphysicians such as phenomenalis…Read more
-
3The Philosophical Papers of Alan Donagan, Volume 2: Action, Reason, and Value (edited book)University of Chicago Press. 1994.A major voice in late twentieth-century philosophy, Alan Donagan is distinguished for his theories on the history of philosophy and the nature of morality. The Philosophical Papers of Alan Donagan, volumes 1 and 2, collect 28 of Donagan's most important and best-known essays on historical understanding and ethics from 1957 to 1991. Volume 2 addresses issues in the philosophy of action and moral theory. With papers on Kant, von Wright, Sellars, and Chisholm, this volume also covers a range of que…Read more
-
3The Philosophical Papers of Alan Donagan, Volume 1: Historical Understanding and the History of Philosophy (edited book)University of Chicago Press. 1994.A major voice in late twentieth-century philosophy, Alan Donagan is distinguished for his theories on the history of philosophy and the nature of morality. The Philosophical Papers of Alan Donagan, volumes 1 and 2, collect 28 of Donagan's most important and best-known essays on historical understanding and ethics from 1957 to 1991. Volume 1 includes essays on Spinoza, Descartes, Bradley, Collingwood, Russell, Moore, and Popper, as well as two previously unpublished papers on the history of philo…Read more
-
15Comparing topographies: across paths/around place: a reply to CaseyPhilosophy and Geography 4 (2): 231-238. 2001.(2001). Comparing topographies: Across paths/around place: A reply to Casey. Philosophy & Geography: Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 231-238.
-
Bruce Aune: "Metaphysics: The Elements" (review)Australasian Journal of Philosophy 67 (n/a): 100. 1989.
-
R. Harre: "Varieties of Realism: A Rationale for the Natural Sciences" (review)Australasian Journal of Philosophy 66 (n/a): 253. 1988.
-
CHLESINGER, G. N.: "The Intelligibility of Nature" (review)Australasian Journal of Philosophy 65 (n/a): 344. 1987.
-
11Gadamer's Century: Essays in Honor of Hans-Georg GadamerMIT Press. 2002.A wide-ranging collection of philosophical essays in honor of Hans-Georg Gadamer.
-
University of TasmaniaPhilosophy & Gender Studies