‘Excessive’ worry is the core symptom of one of the most commonly diagnosed anxiety disorders worldwide - generalized anxiety disorder. A widely held assumption is that it’s caused by irrational beliefs about the likelihood or cost of potential threats. In light of theoretical challenges that can be raised for this doxastic model, we propose that a more attractive explanation is made available by recent philosophical accounts of worry and anxiety. These suggest that it’s our emotional responses …
Read more‘Excessive’ worry is the core symptom of one of the most commonly diagnosed anxiety disorders worldwide - generalized anxiety disorder. A widely held assumption is that it’s caused by irrational beliefs about the likelihood or cost of potential threats. In light of theoretical challenges that can be raised for this doxastic model, we propose that a more attractive explanation is made available by recent philosophical accounts of worry and anxiety. These suggest that it’s our emotional responses that determine how much we worry, rather than our beliefs.
Such a view allows for the idea that excessive worry is driven not by any kind of epistemic error, but instead by ‘recalcitrant’ emotions - emotions that are in tension with our beliefs. We argue that this alternative explanatory model has advantages over the doxastic model. We also consider the implications it has for our understanding of the irrationality involved in GAD, and the theory underlying treatment of it too.