Persistently low trust in Chile’s business sector raises a broader question about its public legitimacy. This article develops a hermeneutic reconstruction of the problem, focusing on companies that exercise structural power in socially inescapable sectors, where relations of dependence intensify expectations of public justification. The analysis brings together four philosophical-political frameworks: Rawls’s public reason, Habermas’s discourse theory, the relationship between appearance and re…
Read morePersistently low trust in Chile’s business sector raises a broader question about its public legitimacy. This article develops a hermeneutic reconstruction of the problem, focusing on companies that exercise structural power in socially inescapable sectors, where relations of dependence intensify expectations of public justification. The analysis brings together four philosophical-political frameworks: Rawls’s public reason, Habermas’s discourse theory, the relationship between appearance and responsibility in Arendt, and the ethics of care developed by Gilligan and Tronto. We argue that the convergence of deficits in justifiability, communicative distortions, evasion of public responsibility, and limited relational sensitivity constitutes a second-order justificatory fracture that provides an interpretive account of persistent disaffection, even in the absence of manifest illegality or contingent crises. On the basis of this reconstruction, we propose the notion of Expanded Public Legitimacy (EPL), a second-order hermeneutic category that extends the interpretive scope of Rawlsian public reason to the justification of nonpolitical institutions and integrates four dimensions: public justifiability, undistorted communication, responsible public appearance, and relational sensitivity. EPL specifies the conditions under which the private exercise of structural power may aspire to public recognition, without prescribing substantive corporate decisions or a particular model of governance. The article thus offers an integrated interpretation of the public legitimacy deficit of companies exercising structural power in Chile and a conceptual tool whose relevance to other private actors with comparable power requires further comparative research.