Imke Maessen

In In Praise of Theatre, an interview with Alain Badiou held by Nicolas Truong, Badiou answers questions about his ideas on the value and purpose of theatre. He explains that he takes ‘real theatre’ to be theatre that consists of performances that aim at making the members of the audience to reflect critically on what they have just heard or seen and, more importantly, the possibilities that were only implied by the performance. Contrary to disciplines such as philosophy, politics and literature, Badiou argues, theatre is uniquely suited for this purpose, because it takes place in a ‘here and now’ that is shared by performers and audience, which places the audience in a position to ‘grasp the relation between immanence and transcendence from the view of the idea’. In addition, it uses an indirect mode of representation, instead of a direct mode of teaching. While accepting Badiou’s claim that theatre performances form a valuable means to question social conventions by communicating and transforming subjectivity, in this article I will argue that Badiou’s enthusiasm about the possibilities of theatre lead him to exaggerate its uniqueness in relation to philosophy, politics and literature. That is to say, he stretches the differences between these disciplines too far by portraying them as opposites or even rivals. In what follows, I will show for each of the comparisons that Badiou makes between theatre and these other disciplines, that they are founded on a misunderstanding of theatre’s unique position when it comes to transforming subjectivity through communication.

Harold INNIS’S History of Communications: Paper and Printing – Antiquity to Early Modernity, William J. Buxton, Michael R. Cheney and Paul Heyer (eds) (2015) Lanham and London: Rowman and Littlefield, 200 pp., ISBN: 9781442243385, h/bk, £52.95 Philosophy for Multisensory Communication and Media, Keith Kenney (2016) New York, NY: Peter Lang Publishing, 250 pp., ISBN: 9781433122057, p/bk, 35 When the Word Becomes Flesh. Language and Human Nature, Paolo Virno (2015) South Pasadena, CA: Semiotext(e), 263 pp., ISBN: 9781584350941, p/bk, £14.95 Wild Beasts of the Philosophical Desert, Hein van Dongen, Hans Gerding and Rico Sneller (2014) Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 185 pp., ISBN: 9781443854535, h/bk, £39.99.