• Traditional case studies in business ethics ask students to evaluate others’ decisions with hindsight and moral distance. The Business Project reverses this dynamic by requiring students to build companies they genuinely care about, make public commitments they must defend, and navigate ethical dilemmas emerging from their own choices. Over a semester, student teams pitch businesses grounded in ethical values, critique competitors’ moral failures, and respond to custom dilemmas that force diffic…Read more
  • Moral Grandstanding and Cancel Culture
    In Steven D. Hales (ed.), Reason and Relevance: Philosophy for Today, Hackett Publishing Company. forthcoming.
    Some people defend cancel culture by arguing that the motives behind cancellation don’t matter. If we award people social status for calling out wrongdoing, more wrongdoing will be called out, and we all benefit. We argue that although it is sometimes justified that people suffer social consequences for bad behavior, rewarding cancellation campaigns is a bad idea. People who cancel others to look good will go after easy targets rather than deserving ones, and a culture that hands out praise for …Read more
  •  8
    When Universities Censor, What Do They Say?
    Georgetown Journal of Law and Public Policy. forthcoming.
    Universities that practice censorship might offer various justifications for doing so. This essay considers three possible justifications and argues that each is undermined by what I call the Endorsement Effect. First, universities might argue that censorship is justified because it protects their community from bad ideas. Second, they might claim that censoring certain expressions is justified because doing so expresses the university community’s commitment to its values. Finally, they might ar…Read more
  •  15
    Censorship Boosts the Credibility of Bad Ideas
    Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy. forthcoming.
    Defenders of censorship sometimes claim that it is justified as a means of protecting audiences from the influence of bad ideas. This essay argues that censorship is likely to frustrate this aim, even under favorable conditions. The central problem arises from what I call the Endorsement Effect: when a censoring authority permits an idea to be expressed, its inaction functions as an implicit signal that the idea is credible. Where trust in the censor is warranted, this is a rational inference ra…Read more
  •  9
    David Foster Wallace on the Good Life
    In Steven M. Cahn & Maureen Eckert (eds.), Freedom and the Self: Essays on the Philosophy of David Foster Wallace, Columbia University Press. pp. 133-168. 2015.
  •  89
    Every year, millions of students in the United States and around the world graduate from high school and college. Commencement speakers—often distilling the hopes of parents and four years of messaging from educators—tell graduates that they must do something grand, ambitious, or far-reaching. Change the world. Disrupt the status quo. Every problem in the world is your problem, awaiting your solutions. This book is an antidote to that advice. It provides a clear-eyed assessment of three types of…Read more
  •  1317
    Don't Block the Exits
    In J. P. Messina (ed.), New Directions in the Ethics and Politics of Speech, Routledge. pp. 50-60. 2022.
    In contemporary political discussions, it is depressingly common to see people criticized for expressing impure beliefs. Moreover, those who sometimes defect from their tribe are criticized for failing to be firmly enough on the side of the angels. We consider explanations for this behavior, including its relationship to moral grandstanding. We will also argue, on both moral and epistemic grounds, in favor of a norm against “blocking the exits.” We should not use social pressure to discourage pe…Read more
  •  3880
    Conservative Critiques
    In Matt Zwolinski & Benjamin Ferguson (eds.), The Routledge Companion to Libertarianism, Routledge. pp. 579-592. 2022.
    American sociologist Robert Nisbet once described conservatives and libertarians as “uneasy cousins.” The description is apt. While sharing a family resemblance and many of the same political rivals, conservatism and libertarianism are fundamentally at odds. This paper explains why this is so from the conservative perspective. It surveys the starting points and major themes of conservatism and libertarianism. It identifies what conservatives and libertarians agree about. It concludes by showing…Read more
  •  1329
    Moral grandstanding, narcissism, and self-reported responses to the COVID-19 crisis
    with Joshua B. Grubbs, A. Shanti James, and Brandon Warmke
    Journal of Research in Personality 97 (104187): 1-10. 2022.
    The present study aimed to understand how status-oriented individual differences such as narcissistic antagonism, narcissistic extraversion, and moral grandstanding motivations may have longitudinally predicted both behavioral and social media responses during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. Via YouGov, a nationally representative sample of U.S. adults was recruited in August of 2019 (N = 2,519; Mage = 47.5, SD = 17.8; 51.4% women) and resampled in May of 2020, (N = 1,533). Results in…Read more
  •  3223
    Moral grandstanding and political polarization: A multi-study consideration
    with Joshua B. Grubbs, Brandon Warmke, and A. Shanti James
    Journal of Research in Personality 88. 2020.
    The present work posits that social motives, particularly status seeking in the form of moral grandstanding, are likely at least partially to blame for elevated levels of affective polarization and ideological extremism in the U.S. In Study 1, results from both undergraduates (N = 981; Mean age = 19.4; SD = 2.1; 69.7% women) and a cross-section of U.S. adults matched to 2010 census norms (N = 1,063; Mean age = 48.20, SD = 16.38; 49.8% women) indicated that prestige-motived grandstanding was cons…Read more
  •  187
    We are all guilty of it. We call people terrible names in conversation or online. We vilify those with whom we disagree, and make bolder claims than we could defend. We want to be seen as taking the moral high ground not just to make a point, or move a debate forward, but to look a certain way--incensed, or compassionate, or committed to a cause. We exaggerate. In other words, we grandstand. Nowhere is this more evident than in public discourse today, and especially as it plays out across the i…Read more
  •  3292
    Moral grandstanding as a threat to free expression
    Social Philosophy and Policy 37 (2): 170-189. 2020.
    Moral grandstanding, or the use of moral talk for self-promotion, is a threat to free expression. When grandstanding is introduced in a public forum, several ideals of free expression are less likely to be realized. Popular views are less likely to be challenged, people are less free to entertain heterodox ideas, and the cost of changing one’s mind goes up.
  •  1406
    Public discourse is often caustic and conflict-filled. This trend seems to be particularly evident when the content of such discourse is around moral issues (broadly defined) and when the discourse occurs on social media. Several explanatory mechanisms for such conflict have been explored in recent psychological and social-science literatures. The present work sought to examine a potentially novel explanatory mechanism defined in philosophical literature: Moral Grandstanding. According to philos…Read more
  •  1173
    Relational Sufficientarianism and Basic Income
    In Michael Cholbi & Michael Weber (eds.), The Future of Work, Technology, and Basic Income, Routledge. pp. 49-61. 2019.
    Basic income policies have recently enjoyed a great deal of discussion, but they are not a natural fit with views of distributive or social justice endorsed by many moral and political philosophers. This essay develops and defends a new view of social justice, called relational sufficientarianism, which is more compatible with a universal basic income. Relational sufficientarianism holds that persons in a just society must have sufficient social status, but not necessarily equal social status. I…Read more
  •  4365
    Rethinking the Principle of Fair Play
    Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 99 (4): 612-631. 2018.
    The principle of fair play is widely thought to require simply that costs and benefits be distributed fairly. This gloss on the principle, while not entirely inaccurate, has invited a host of popular objections based on misunderstandings about fair play. Central to many of these objections is a failure to treat the principle of fair play as a transactional principle—one that allocates special obligations and rights among persons as a result of their interactions. I offer an interpretation of the…Read more
  •  9363
    Moral Grandstanding
    Philosophy and Public Affairs 44 (3): 197-217. 2016.
    Moral grandstanding is a pervasive feature of public discourse. Many of us can likely recognize that we have engaged in grandstanding at one time or another. While there is nothing new about the phenomenon of grandstanding, we think that it has not received the philosophical attention it deserves. In this essay, we provide an account of moral grandstanding as the use of public discourse for moral self-promotion. We then show that our account, with support from some standard theses of social psyc…Read more
  •  2001
    A Fair Play Account of Legitimate Political Authority
    Legal Theory 23 (1): 55-67. 2017.
    There is an emerging consensus among political philosophers that state legitimacy involves something more than—or perhaps other than—political obligation. Yet the principle of fair play, which many take to be a promising basis for political obligation, has been largely absent from discussions of the revised conception of legitimacy. This paper shows how the principle of fair play can generate legitimate political authority by drawing on a neglected feature of the principle—its stipulation that m…Read more
  •  51
    Anticipating the ethical and political challenges of human nanotechnologies
    with David Guston, John Parsi, and Justin Tosi
    In Fritz Allhoff, Patrick Lin, James Moor, John Weckert & Mihail C. Roco (eds.), Nanoethics: The Ethical and Social Implications of Nanotechnology, Wiley. pp. 185-197. 2007.
  •  1925
    David Foster Wallace on the Good Life
    In Steven M. Cahn & Maureen Eckert (eds.), Freedom and the Self: Essays on the Philosophy of David Foster Wallace, Columbia University Press. pp. 133-168. 2015.
    This chapter presents David Foster Wallace's views about three positions regarding the good life—ironism, hedonism, and narrative theories. Ironism involves distancing oneself from everything one says or does, and putting on Wallace's so-called “mask of ennui.” Wallace said that the notion appeals to ironists because it insulates them from criticism. However, he reiterated that ironists can be criticized for failing to value anything. Hedonism states that a good life consists in pleasure. Wallac…Read more
  •  2214
    The philosophical literature on state legitimacy has recently seen a significant conceptual revision. Several philosophers have argued that the state's right to rule is better characterized not as a claim right to obedience, but as a power right. There have been few attempts to show that traditional justifications for the claim right might also be used to justify a power right, and there have been no such attempts involving the principle of fair play, which is widely regarded as the most promisi…Read more
  •  3236
    Punishment and Forgiveness
    In Jonathan Jacobs & Jonathan Jackson (eds.), The Routledge Handbook of Criminal Justice Ethics, Routledge. pp. 203-216. 2016.
    In this paper we explore the relationship between forgiving and punishment. We set out a number of arguments for the claim that if one forgives a wrongdoer, one should not punish her. We then argue that none of these arguments is persuasive. We conclude by reflecting on the possibility of institutional forgiveness in the criminal justice setting and on the differences between forgiveness and acts of mercy.
  •  1738
    Playing Fair and Following the Rules
    Journal of Moral Philosophy 14 (2): 134-141. 2017.
    In his paper “Fairness, Political Obligation, and the Justificatory Gap” (published in the Journal of Moral Philosophy), Jiafeng Zhu argues that the principle of fair play cannot require submission to the rules of a cooperative scheme, and that when such submission is required, the requirement is grounded in consent. I propose a better argument for the claim that fair play requires submission to the rules than the one Zhu considers. I also argue that Zhu’s attribution of consent to people common…Read more