This paper proposes an integrated conceptual framework concerning feeling, meaning, preference, planning, first-person consciousness, symbol grounding, and cultural influence: “Value Reference Frame Theory” (VRF). The core claim of the theory is that feelings are not neutral; non-neutrality must be defined relative to a neutral baseline, and this paper calls that baseline the “value reference frame.” The value reference frame is a precondition for the birth of consciousness: without a neutral ba…
Read moreThis paper proposes an integrated conceptual framework concerning feeling, meaning, preference, planning, first-person consciousness, symbol grounding, and cultural influence: “Value Reference Frame Theory” (VRF). The core claim of the theory is that feelings are not neutral; non-neutrality must be defined relative to a neutral baseline, and this paper calls that baseline the “value reference frame.” The value reference frame is a precondition for the birth of consciousness: without a neutral baseline, the non-neutrality of feeling cannot be organized into meaning, caring, and stable cognition, and conscious cognition lacks its constitutive conditions. The value reference frame itself is the evaluative standard and the yardstick for evaluating meaning. The impact of things on the value reference frame is remembered and used for future planning; this memory is called preference. Feeling is the process by which the system receives signals of impacts on the value reference frame. Planning is defined as the process of predicting planning outcomes before action; if planning predicts only external things and not the impact of their outcomes on the system’s own value reference frame, then value evaluation lacks motivational weight; if consequences are not predicted, behavior tends to be directly signal-driven. A system that self-plans, self-maintains, and undergoes its own states constitutes a natural first-person. In terms of origin, the value reference frame is endowed by non-cultural external processes such as biological evolution and bodily homeostasis; culture does not participate in generating the value reference frame. Operationally, the value reference frame itself is the yardstick; therefore, the system cannot evaluate itself by globally negating its own yardstick, and can only make local revisions. Differences in qualia can be understood as different impacts of stimuli on the value reference frame, thereby occupying different positions in the subjective world. This paper further proposes the symbol grounding proposition: symbol grounding produces meaning through the impact of the thing referred to by the symbol on the value reference frame; the symbol itself is neutral, and meaning comes from the triadic relation “symbol–referent–VRF impact.” This paper also proposes the “level-separation thesis of cultural influence”: culture only changes planning-level cognitive representations, normative narratives, causal models, goal hierarchies, and action strategies; it does not participate in generating the value reference frame, nor does it directly rewrite the value reference frame itself. This paper provides basic definitions, core propositions, dialogue with existing theories, and limitations.