Mark Heller

There is a standard objection to libertarianism that is often put in terms of luck or randomness: if indeterminism is true in a way that initially seems helpful to the libertarian, then there is a freedom-threatening disconnect between one’s reasons and one’s actions. A standard reply to this sort of objection is to propose that reasons can “influence without determining” behavior. This paper proposes that this reply is vulnerable to a “degree argument”: whatever degree of freedom is present in a given case, it always seems that it would be better, from the perspective of avoiding the disconnect worry, to have a higher degree of influence. Thus, the Influence Strategy is rejected as a response to the Disconnect Problem. The paper is thereby led to reject libertarianism, though more tentatively. This leaves a choice between compatibilism and impossibilism, and a contextualist treatment of that choice is proposed.

Romania in Transition. Edited by Lavinia Stan xviii + 218 pp. £39.50 cloth. Early Greek Political Thought from Homer to the Sophists. Edited by Michael Gagarin and Paul Woodruff lvi + 324 pp. $59.95/£40.00 cloth, $18.95/£14.95 paper. Renaissance and Enlightenment Paradoxes. Edited by Natalie Zemon Davis and Arlette Farge. Vol. 3 of A History of Women in the West, general editors, Georges Duby and Michelle Perrot x + 595 pp. $29.95 cloth, $16.95 paper. The Cross and the Pear Tree: A Sephardic Journey. By Victor Perera 282 pp. n.p.g. Open the Social Sciences. Edited by Immanuel Wallerstein et al. Report of the Gulbenkian Commission on the Restructuring of the Social Sciences 105 pp. £8.95 paper, £25.00 cloth. Music & Culture in Eighteenth‐Century Europe: A Source Book. By Enrico Fubini, translated by Wolfgang Freis, Lisa Gasbarrone, Michael Louis Leone, translation edited by Bonnie J. Blackburn x + 421 pp. £43.95, $63.25 cloth £16.75/$24.25 paper. La Modernité. By Alexis Nouss 128 pp. n.p.g. Florentine Drama for Convent and Festival. Seven Sacred Plays. By Antonia Pulci, annotated and translated by James Wyatt Cook, xxx + 281 pp. $33.00 cloth/$15.00 paper. The Varieties of British Political Thought, 1500–1800. By J. G. A. Pocock, Gordon J. Schochet, and Lois G. Schwoerer x + 373 pp. £40.00/$59.95 cloth, £14.95 paper. Heidegger and French Philosophy: Humanism, Antihumanism and Being. By Tom Rockmore xx + 250 pp. £40.00 cloth, £14.99 paper. One King, One Faith: The Parlement of Paris and the Religious Reformations of the Sixteenth Century. By Nancy Lyman Roelker xiii + 543 pp. $65.00/£50.00 cloth. The Rabin Memoirs. By Yitzhak Rabin, with an afterword by Yoram Peri 435 pp. $40.00 cloth, $16.95 paper. On Voluntary Servitude. False Consciousness and the Theory of Ideology. By Michael Rosen xi + 289 pp. $35.00 cloth. Dante: Monarchy. Edited and translated by Prue Shaw xlviii + 121 pp. £30.00/$39.95 cloth, £10.95/$14.95 paper. Liberalism after Communism. By Jerzy Szacki, translated by Chester P. Kistel VII + 216 pp. £35.00 cloth, £12.99 paper. Oscar Wilde: Myths, Miracles, and Imitations. By John Stokes xiv + 216 pp. £30.00/$49.95 cloth. Volksgeist as Method and Ethic. Essays on Boasian Ethnography and the German Anthropological Tradition. History of Anthropology Series. Edited by George W. Stocking, Jr. 349 pp. £25.00 doth. The Life of a Painter. By Gino Severini, translated by Jennifer Franchina 310 pp. n.p.g. James Joyce and the Language of History: Dedalus's Nightmare. By Robert Spoo xii + 195 pp. Imagining Monsters: Miscreations of the Self in Eighteenth‐Century England. By Dennis Todd 339 + xvii pp. £41.50 doth/£14.25 paper. Nationalism in Europe, 1815 to the Present: A Reader. Edited by Stuart Woolf vi + 215 pp. £11.99 paper. In Defense of Decadent Europe. By Raymond Aron, translated by Stephen Cox, with a new introduction by Daniel J. Mahoney and Brian C. Anderson $24.95 paper. Why Movements Succeed or Fail: Opportunity, Culture, and the Struggle for Woman Suffrage.. By Lee Ann Banaszak xiii + 291 pp. $49.50/£40.00 cloth, $19.95/£15.95 paper. Conflicting Visions of Reform: German Lay Propaganda Pamphlets, 1519–1530. By Miriam Usher Chrisman. Studies in German Histories xiii + 208 pp. $60.00 cloth. Nicholas of Cusa: The Catholic Concordance. Edited by Paul. E. Sigmund xlvii + 326 pp. £16.95/$24.95 paper. Towards a New Europe: Stops and Starts in Regional Integration. Edited by Gerald Schneider, Patricia A. Weitsman, and Thomas Bernauer xiv + 224 pp. n.p.g. Irish Politics Today. 3rd edition. By Neil Collins and Terry Cradden x + 165 pp. £35.00 doth/ £9.99 paper. Paradoxes of Peace. By Alice Holmes Cooper 331 pp. $52.50 cloth. Modernism and Revolution: Russian Literature in Transition. By Victor Erlich $45.00 cloth. The Lacanian Subject: Between Language and Jouissance. By Bruce Fink xvii + 219 pp. $35.00 cloth/$ 15.95 paper. The European Economy Between the Wars. By Charles H. Feinstein, Peter Temin and Gianni Toniolo xi + 233 pp. £14.99 paper. Molding Japanese Minds: The State in Everyday Life. By Sheldon Garon xvii + 311 pp. $24.95/£19.95 cloth. Forms of Nationhood: The Elizabethan Writing of England. By Richard Helgerson xi + 350 pp. £12.75/$18.25 paper. The Pilgrimage of Grace: A Study of the Rebel Armies of October 1536. By Michael Bush xviii + 436 pp., £55.00 cloth. A Concise Historical Atlas of Eastern Europe. By Dennis P. Hupchick and Harold E. Cox 120 pp. $45.95 cloth, $17.95 paper. Mass Media and Media Policy in Western Europe. By Peter J. Humphreys ix + 349 pp. £45.00 cloth, £17.99 paper. Spies Without Cloaks: The KGB's Successors. By Amy Knight xiii + 318 pp. $24.95/£16.95 cloth. The Origins of the State in Italy, 1300–1600. Edited by Julius Kirshner 212 pp. $27.95 cloth, $15.95 paper. Aristocracy, Antiquity & History: Classicism in Political Thought. By Andreas A. M. Kinneging. xii + 348 pp. n.p.g. The Great Powers, Imperialism, and the German Problem, 1865–1925. By John Lowe x + 257 pp. £10.99 paper. Environment and the Nation State: The Netherlands, the European Union and Acid Rain. Issues in Environmental Politics. By Duncan Liefferink xiv + 225 pp. £40.00 cloth. Twentieth‐Century Irish Drama: Mirror up to Nation. By Christopher Murray x + 278 pp. £35.00 cloth, £12.99 paper. To the Other Shore: The Russian Jewish Intellectuals Who Came to America. By Steven Cassedy, xxiii + 197 pp. $29.95/£25.00 cloth. The Politics of Punishment: Prison Reform in Russia 1863–1917. By Bruce F. Adams viii + 237 pp. $32.00 cloth. The East in the West. By Jack Goody x + 295 pp. £37.50/$54.95 cloth, £13.95/$18.95 paper. Conservatism: An Anthology of Social and Political Thought from David Hume to the Present. Edited by Jerry Z. Muller xvi + 450 pp. n.p.g. Enlightenment and Religion. Rational Dissent in Eighteenth‐Century Britain. Edited by Knud Haakonssen, Ideas in Context, xi + 348 pp. £40.00/ $59.95 cloth. Reassessing Anglo‐Saxon England. By Eric John xii + 204 pp. £35.00 cloth/£12.99 paper. On or About December 1910: Early Bloomsbury and its Intimate World. By Peter Stansky x + 289 pp. $27.95 cloth.

In Eli Hirsch’s clever and careful Dividing Reality he asks us to consider several strange languages. For example, in the Gricular language there is no word that applies to all and only green things and none that applies to all and only circular things, but there are the three words “gricular,” which applies to anything that is either green or circular, “grincular,” which applies to anything that is either green or not circular, and “ngricular,” which applies to anything that is either circular or not green. Griculese is but one of the strange languages Hirsch explores, but they are all alike in having the same descriptive content as English—anything that can be said in English can be said in the strange languages, and vice versa. For instance, to say that something is green, we can say “it is both gricular and grincular.” Our strong intuition is that these languages are strange—irrational or worse. The challenge is to ground this intuition in some particular feature of the language that makes it defective. The problem is that there seems no good response to this challenge. Hirsch examines many proposals, and rejects every one. Thus he finds himself reaching a conclusion even he finds it difficult to accept. The disturbing conclusion, division relativism by title, is that our strong intuition is misguided—the “strange” languages are just as reasonable as English.

Henry Mehlberg, an eminent philosopher educated in the best traditions of Polish logic, till his death professor at the University of Chicago, was for a long time interested in an interdisciplinary study of time, especially in its physical and philosophical aspects. "Mehlberg's command of the most recent relevant developments in theoretical physics was outstanding even within the relatively small circle of philosophers working in the foundations of physics, most of whom are better known than he". These are some of the reasons that compel us to go through two volumes of Mehlberg's studies with a special interest.

René Descartes, one of the dominant figures in the history of philosophy, has been accused of one of the most obvious mistakes in the history of philosophy — the so-called cartesian circle. It is my goal in this paper to arrive at an understanding of Descartes's work that attributes to him a theory that should be of philosophical interest to contemporary epistemologists, is consistent with, and suggested by, the actual text, and avoids the circle.I begin with a brief explanation of the supposed circle. In his search for absolute certainty Descartes requires that in order for a proposition to be an instance of knowledge it must be indubitable for the knower, and in order for it to be indubitable for the knower she must be able to eliminate any possibility of the belief's being false. It is to provide a means to satisfy this requirement that Descartes proposes the principle whatever is clearly and distinctly perceived cannot be false.And it seems that Descartes's defense of CD traps him in the circle.

In 1962 Hilary Putnam forced us to face the possibility of robot cats. More than twenty years later Daniel Dennett found himself doing battle with mad scientists and other “bogeymen.” Though these two examples are employed in different philosophical arena, there is an important connection between them that has not been emphasized. Separating the concept associated with a kind term from the extension of that term, as Putnam and others have urged, raises the possibility of accepting counterexamples to compatibilistic analyses without rejecting compatibilism. Even if no compatibilist analysis of our concept of free action is acceptable, a compatibilist account of the essential nature of free action may be.