In his 2023 AJOB article, Jorge Fabiano claims that a safety framework is needed to guard against the potential negative consequences of moral enhancement. He describes prudential desiderata that constitute the nodes of his proposed safety framework, ultimately arguing that a virtue theory, as opposed to a non-virtue based theory such as a consequentialist or deontological theory, hues closest to these desiderata. In this open peer commentary (OPC), I argue that Fabiano's trait-based analysis of…
Read moreIn his 2023 AJOB article, Jorge Fabiano claims that a safety framework is needed to guard against the potential negative consequences of moral enhancement. He describes prudential desiderata that constitute the nodes of his proposed safety framework, ultimately arguing that a virtue theory, as opposed to a non-virtue based theory such as a consequentialist or deontological theory, hues closest to these desiderata. In this open peer commentary (OPC), I argue that Fabiano's trait-based analysis of enhancement-related changes, while illuminating, necessarily commits us to a virtue theoretical framework.
