• This paper examines McDowell’s claim that human beings ‘are born mere animals’ and become thinkers and intentional agents through the acquisition of second nature. Although his account resists crude naturalism, I argue that it too readily incorporates first nature into second nature and underestimates the educational significance of innocence and misunderstanding. Drawing on Cavell’s reflections on language learning, productive classroom misconceptions, and McDowell’s remarks on innovation. I ar…Read more