My study of moral justice in Scottish Enlightenment thought shall focus on the ways in which the Scottish thinkers tackled the issue of the dual aspect which characterises justice, namely the legal and ethical dimensions inherent in the idea of justice. The literati were particularly interested in the problematic implications underlying this aspect and were concerned with reconciling the two dimensions. Their discussion emerged out of the fact that the literati did not all agree about the nature…
Read moreMy study of moral justice in Scottish Enlightenment thought shall focus on the ways in which the Scottish thinkers tackled the issue of the dual aspect which characterises justice, namely the legal and ethical dimensions inherent in the idea of justice. The literati were particularly interested in the problematic implications underlying this aspect and were concerned with reconciling the two dimensions. Their discussion emerged out of the fact that the literati did not all agree about the nature, origin and characteristics of justice. They also debated on whether or not, and if so on what grounds, being just deserves admiration and praise. Further, the literati sought to account for the development of the individual virtue of justice into an institutionalised practice in the social sphere, and they examined the decisive role played by the juridical and political institutions. However, the Scottish moralists warned against the risks and dangers of allowing institutions to wield too much authority, among which, the risk of disobedience on the part of individuals and the danger of political corruption on the part of the government. To resolve these issues, the Scots put forward instead a compromise in which the government and the citizens could cooperate. Lastly, the Scottish moralists proposed to re-define the idea of justice, in terms of equity and fairness as opposed to defining justice in terms of equality. Doing so would enable the governmental institutions to regain legitimacy. The purpose of my study is to outline the debates that took place in eighteenth-century Britain as regards the idea of justice and to account for the major approaches offered by the literati on the matter. The wider concerns addressed by the literati are found in different branches of ethics and law: I intend to show how those different branches are related to one another.