-
89Thomas Reid's Science of PoliticsAnalytica. Revista de Filosofia 22 (1): 39-61. 2019.The paper covers the discussion of three aspects of Thomas Reid’s political thought. Initially, it presents and discusses Reid’s understanding of Politics. Secondly, it is argued that, unlike the first principles of other branches of knowledge, such as Mathematics, Philosophy of Mind and Morals, the first principles of Politics are not the first principles of common sense. Politics is founded on a form of empirical knowledge that cannot be identified with common sense, with the judgments and bel…Read more
-
263Solipcism in George Berkeley's PhilosophyAnalytica. Revista de Filosofia 23 (2): 88-116. 2021.The paper advances the hypothesis that George Berkeley's philosophy does not overcome solipsism. In order to do this, it presents four difficulties on his arguments for other existences: (I) the argument about the existence of an external cause for sensitive ideas faces the difficulty of not eliminating the possibility that the mind itself is the cause of these ideas; (II) the argument present in the Dialogues to prove the existence of God is circular: it presupposes the existence of objects dis…Read more
-
128The Theory of Substance in John Locke’s Essay concerning Human UnderstandingTrans/Form/Ação 46 (2): 35-60. 2023.In this paper, we intend to offer an interpretation about the explanation of the (relative) idea of pure substance in general on John Locke’s philosophy, from Thomas Reid’s notion of ‘natural suggestion’. To achieve this aim, after contextualizing Locke’s notion of pure substance in general and distinguishing it from the idea of particular substance (section 1), we explicit that Locke’s words about the source of the idea of the former in the mind (either empirical or rational) are ambiguous and …Read more
-
181Consciousness and Reflection in John Locke’s EssayDiscurso 52 (1): 84-100. 2022.The paper discusses the notions of ‘consciousness’ and ‘reflection’ in John Locke’s Essay on the Human Understanding. It attempts to present two criteria by means of which it would be possible to distinguish between these mental activities. Firstly, consciousness is a passive, involuntary activity and does not depend on attention to be exerted, unlike reflection, which is, at least in one of its degrees – since Locke conceives the existence of two degrees of reflection –, an active, voluntary, a…Read more
-
9Thomas Reid on the first principles of speculative, moral and political knowledgeDissertation, Université Paris-Sorbonne. 2017.This thesis aims to discuss Thomas Reid’s (1710-1796) theory of the first principles of knowledge, more particularly, the first principles of philosophy of mind, morals and politics. In the first chapter, I discuss Reid’s foundationalist commitments in philosophy of mind, morals and politics. I argue that he is clearly a foundationalist about speculative and moral knowledge, but it is not clear if he keeps foundationalist commitments with regard to political knowledge – the first principles of p…Read more
-
256Rene Descartes’ skepticism in Thomas Reid’s readingO Que Nos Faz Pensar? 29 (48): 55-82. 2022.The paper advances the hypothesis that René Descartes presents a skeptical system of philosophy in Thomas Reid’s reading. There is a sort of ‘involun-tary’ or ‘accidental’ skepticism that results from the adoption by Descartes of both a skeptical method and a skeptical principle. The first section shows to what extent the Cartesian method of doubt – which focuses on the reliability of the faculties of the mind - is a skeptical demand that cannot be satisfied. The second section shows…Read more
-
128Thomas Reid’s objection to Hume’s theory of personal identityCadernos de Filosofia Alemã: Crítica E Modernidade 24 (2): 53-69. 2019.The paper discusses Thomas Reid's objection to David Hume's theory of personal identity. The hypothesis states that this criticism is not effective because it is based on a misunderstanding of Hume’s theory, namely, that Hume would have admitted a negative ontological thesis - the inexistence of a mind beyond perceptions - and a positive ontological thesis - a mind reduced to a bundle of perceptions. After explaining in what measures Reid’s objection is based upo…Read more
-
89Thomas Reid's Science of PoliticsAnalytica (Rio) 22 (1): 39-61. 2018.The paper covers the discussion of three aspects of Thomas Reid’s political thought. Initially, it presents and discusses Reid’s understanding of Politics. Secondly, it is argued that, unlike the first principles of other branches of knowledge, such as Mathematics, Philosophy of Mind and Morals, the first principles of Politics are not the first principles of common sense. Politics is founded on a form of empirical knowledge that cannot be identified with common sense, with the judgments and bel…Read more
-
118Thomas Reid's Reply to SkepticismSíntese Revista de Filosofia 47 (147): 23-44. 2020.The paper presents and discusses how Thomas Reid's philosophy of common sense replies to the skepticism about the epistemic reliability of the faculties of mind. The hypothesis presented establishes that Reid’s reply has three arguments. First, Reid shows why it is impossible to prove the reliability of the faculties of mind and why philosophers may begin their investigations by accepting the truth of the beliefs due to these faculties. Secondly, Reid shows that it is inconsistent to choose one …Read more
-
91Thomas Reid’s Moderate Reply to SkepticismSíntese Revista de Filosofia 49 (154): 365. 2022.The paper states a hypothesis concerning Thomas Reid's moderation in his reply to skepticism. It is initially argued that commonsense beliefs, though due to reliable faculties, are doubtful, fallible, and correctable. They are not completely immune to skeptical attack. It is further argued that Reid intends to reply only to one form of skepticism, the partial one – the skepticism of authors who accept at least one mental faculty as a reliable source of knowledge. Reid does not intend to argue wi…Read more
-
121David Hume’s skepticism in Thomas Reid’s readingFilosofia Unisinos 1-15. forthcoming.The paper advances the hypothesis that, in Thomas Reid's reading, David Hume's skepticism of the Treatise on Human Nature is not solely due to his acceptance of the ‘ideal hypothesis’ – the principle according to which ideas are the immediate objects of the mental operations –, but it has another source, namely, that doubt on the reliability of the faculties of the senses, memory, and reason. Moreover, the paper argues that the suggested distinction between two roots for Hume’s skepticism allows…Read more
-
151David Hume on the Corporeal Dimension of the SelfPrincipia: An International Journal of Epistemology 26 (3): 489-508. 2022.The paper advances the hypothesis that David Hume’s philosophy explains the corporeal dimension of the self, particularly, one’s belief in a body as being ‘her own body’, as a part of one’s self, in light of three different perspectives: through the operations of the imagination, the associative principles and the perception of mental and physical parallel states; through the occurrence of certain passions in the mind, particularly, pride, humility, and self-interest which direct one’s attention…Read more
-
82The Uses of the Common Sense in Thomas Reid’s PhilosophyVeritas – Revista de Filosofia da Pucrs 64 (3). 2019.This paper aims to discuss the philosophical roles of common sense in Thomas Reid’s thought. I argue that there is not only one way of appealing to common sense in attempt of discovering truth and allowing knowledge. According to my understanding, Reid makes at least three distinct uses of common sense: (1) the foundational use, in which common sense is taken as the foundation upon which knowledge must be built; (2) the methodological use, in which common sense arises as a source of methodo-logi…Read more
-
18Why Thomas Reid Matters to the Epistemology of the Social SciencesPhilosophical Quarterly 70 (279): 282-301. 2020.Little attention has been paid to the fact that Thomas Reid's epistemology applies to ‘political reasoning’ as well as to various operations of the mind. Reid was interested in identifying the ‘first principles’ of political science as he did with other domains of human knowledge. This raises the question of the extent to which the study of human action falls within the competence of ‘common sense’. Our aim is to reconstruct and assess Reid's epistemology of the sciences of social action and to …Read more
-
27George Berkeley's Skepticism in Thomas Reid's ReadingPhilosophica: International Journal for the History of Philosophy 29 (57): 5-19. 2021.The paper advances two hypotheses concerning Thomas Reid’s reading of George Berkeley’s immaterialist system. First, it is argued that, on Reid’s view, Berkeley is skeptic about the existence of the objects of the material world, not in virtue of a doubt about the senses but for his adoption of the principle that ideas are the immediate objects of the operations of mind. On Reid’s view, that principle is a skeptical principle by its own nature. Secondly, it is argued that Berkeley really accepts…Read more
-
7Comentário ao artigo “Valores, Verdade e Investigação: uma alternativa pragmatista ao não cognitivismo de Russell”Trans/Form/Ação 43 (3): 269-272. 2020.
-
235The Notion of ‘Common Sense’ in Thomas ReidDiscurso 50 (1). 2020.The paper aims to discuss the notion of ‘common sense’ in Thomas Reid’s philosophy. It presents two hypotheses. The first hypothesis states that the common sense that Reid uses in philosophical matters is nothing but the set of original principles of the mind that determine human beings in regard to their notions, beliefs and inclinations, as well as the judgments and beliefs that are due to these principles. The second hypothesis states that Reid understan…Read more
-
173Thomas Reid’s objection to Locke’s Theory of personal identityPrincipia: An International Journal of Epistemology 24 (1): 147-164. 2020.The paper aims to present two distinct ways of defending John Locke’s theory of personal identity from Thomas Reid’s objection. First, it will be argued that this objection is not effective since it starts from a misunderstanding of Locke’s theory. The identity of a person is not preserved by the psychological continuity of consciousness, as Reid understood it, but by its ontological continuity: the existence of the same consciousness preserves the personal identity. Secondly, it will be argued …Read more
-
86David Hume on Personal Identity in Books I and II of the "Treatise of Human Nature"Filosofia Unisinos 20 (1). 2019.I intend to discuss Hume’s theory of personal identity in Books I and II of the Treatise of Human Nature. First, I intend to argue that Hume’s distinction between a ‘personal identity with regard to thought and imagination’ and a ‘personal identity with regard to passions and self-interest’ is only methodological, not radical. That is, the philosopher does not sug-gest the existence of two distinct ideas of personal identity in mind. Secondly, I try to show the con…Read more
Vinícius França Freitas
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
Alumnus, 2017
Areas of Specialization
Metaphysics and Epistemology |
History of Western Philosophy |
Philosophical Traditions |