Dr. Rajan

Allahabad University
  •  59
    Answering the question “What is Dharma according to the Mahābhārata?” is as complex as the epic itself, often symbolised by the Dharmayuddha—the war fought in the name of truth and righteousness. Key figures such as Yudhiṣṭhira and Bhīṣma are themselves portrayed as deeply conflicted in their attempts to define and uphold Dharma. This paper joins that interpretive tradition by proposing that the Bhagavadgītā offers the most coherent philosophical response to the epic’s normative riddles. After e…Read more
  •  5
    In an era where truth is increasingly malleable and violence—both physical and epistemic—permeates global discourse, _Gandhi, Truth, and Nonviolence: The Politics of Engagement in Post-Truth Times_ emerges as a timely and provocative intervention. Edited by Vinay Lal, this anthology does not merely revisit Gandhi as a historical figure but resurrects him as a “necessary provocation” (p. 1), challenging readers to confront the unsettling moral rigor of his vision. The book’s central thesis is aud…Read more
  •  4
    Lord Acton’s famous aphorism, “power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely” (Lazarski, 2012, p. 11), carries profound humanistic implications. It serves as a warning both to advocates of genuine freedom and to those pursuing positive axiological aims in life. As this paper will discuss, many thinkers have endorsed and elaborated Acton’s insight in diverse ways. Their shared concern is straightforward: reflection on catastrophic historical events compels us to ask who most dama…Read more
  • FREE WILL DEBATE: FROM ILLUSIONISM TO COMPATIBILISM
    Philosophical Papers 18 224-237. 2022.
    The philosophy of free will is a longstanding concern that has been continually reformulated. Acknowledging this, the present paper has three objectives: first, to introduce the free will problem as it appears in contemporary philosophical debates; second, to examine the claim that free will may be an illusion; and third, to suggest that critical reflection on this issue can help us recognize the extent to which we remain free to make decisions that resist existential nihilism and affirm meaning…Read more
  •  9
    In recent times, there has been a growing interest in the comparative analysis of Immanuel Kant and K.C. Bhattacharya’s contributions to the fields of metaphysics, epistemology, and methodology. Numerous significant works have emerged, examining the confluence of these two thinkers’ ideas within these domains. However, an area where their joint study has been notably lacking is in their perspectives on culture, humanism, and civilization. Likewise, while there is an abundance of literature addre…Read more
  •  5
    This paper examines the nature of True World theories, which uphold transcendental and utopian conceptions of reality while devaluing earthly existence. It explores their structure and background, prevalent in both philosophical and religious discourse, analyzes the existential anxieties they seek to address, and critically interrogates their fundamental tenets through the life-affirming philosophies of Lokāyata and Friedrich Nietzsche. By the end of this composition, our aim is to refresh sever…Read more
  •  1
    As science continues to expand its capacity to explain the nature of existence and reality, a new belief system has emerged regarding how humans can acquire pure knowledge, often referred to as Scientism. Scientism posits that science is the exclusive source of knowledge about the world. This belief gained prominence in the early 20th century, influenced by movements such as logical positivism. Prominent thinkers such as Karl Popper, A.O. Quine, Thomas Kuhn, and Ernest Nagel have contributed to …Read more
  •  1
    The reviewed book, titled “The Making of Contemporary Indian Philosophy Krishnachandra Bhattacharyya” (Raveh, D., & Coquereau-Saouma, E. (Eds.). 2023) (the/this book hereafter), edited by Daniel Raveh and Elise Coquereau-Saouma, is part of the Routledge Hindu Studies Series in collaboration with the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies. This series aims to foster dialogue between Hindu traditions and modern research trends. The editors deserve commendation for adding value to the series and contribut…Read more
  •  2
    What is the central philosophy of the Upanishads? Is it theistic, monistic, polytheistic, panpsychistic, or something else? Are the world and God real or unreal? Such questions have been a riddle for ancient sages and modern scholars of the Vedāntic tradition, alike. Interestingly, if any thinker has made this discourse more puzzling, it is none other than Śaṅkarācārya (c. 7th–9th centuries CE); through his famous dictum, Brahma satyam jagat-mithya jivo brahmaiva naparah (“Brahman alone is real,…Read more
  •  5
    Every powerful thing holds many incentives of attractiveness which also create the scope for corruption. As the famous saying advocates"power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely". So whether it is social media or a bureaucratic post, among others, the same applies to ancient Indian Yogic philosophy and practice. While people are aware of the misuse of material world pursuits, very few pay attention to the fact that the spiritual world can be just as destructive if not practiced as pr…Read more
  • Despite the fact that certain individuals elicit intense emotions of aversion or admiration, their influence is undeniable. Gandhi is a prime example of this proposition, as he captivates intellectuals and global leaders. Gandhi is renowned for his advocacy for Swaraj and Satyagraha, his dedication to truth and nonviolence, and his regard for all religions. Following the same sentiment, the book Gandhi and the Idea of Swaraj (Jahanbegloo, 2023), currently under review, is an exceptional starting…Read more
  •  2
    Remembering the Devoted Kashmir Śaivist: Mark Dyczkowski
    Journal of Dharma Studies 8 559-564. 2025.
    A young British seeker, driven by a profound intellectual and spiritual curiosity, embarked on a journey to India at the age of 18, drawn by the philosophical and spiritual traditions he had encountered through the works of Vivekananda, Yogananda, and Ramakrishna, as well as sacred texts like the Bhagavad Gītā and the Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra. Although the decision to travel may, in retrospect, seem unconventional, it appeared entirely natural at the time. However, he was unprepared for the stark reali…Read more
  •  10
    No oppressive ideologies, such as racism, sexism, and imperialism, disappear easily; they require strong antitheses from external forces or through self-reflection. Embracing this premise, this paper explores anti-colonial solidarity in light of the reflective philosophy of Swaraj, emphasizing the importance of reflective ideas over brute force and discarding the assumption that violence is necessary for change. To accomplish this task, we examine into the profound historical and philosophical u…Read more
  •  11
    It is with profound sorrow that we share the passing of Prof. Jaysankar Lal Shaw, who left us on 29 August 2025 at the age of 84, surrounded by his closest family. Born in the bustling city of Kolkata, India, his remarkable intellectual journey began with a BA (Hons, 1959) and MA (1961), both in philosophy, from Calcutta University. His pursuit of knowledge then carried him across continents to Rice University in Texas, where he earned his PhD as a Fulbright and Rice University Fellow. His entry…Read more
  •  12
    The open-ended future of philosophy, including Indian philosophy, is tied to the boundless nature of human consciousness and creativity. It also implies that the trajectory of Indian philosophy remains uncertain, as it can either witness growth and innovation or fall into a state of stagnant clichés and historical research. This becomes problematic if the latter dominates the academic discourse, reinforcing the belief that philosophy does not progress at all and collapses in historicism. Conside…Read more
  •  11
    The Unhappy Cārvāka: A Critical Appraisal of Pradeep Gokhale and Sachchidanand Mishra’s Philosophical Reconstruction
    Journal of the Indian Council of Philosophical Research 43 (2): 249-260. 2026.
    This review brings into conversation two distinctive thinkers—realists and traditionalists in their own right—Pradeep Gokhale and Sachchidanand Mishra, along with some classical and modern philosophical questions. Both scholars have recently undertaken the task of reviving the Indian materialist tradition of Cārvāka. Following a critical appraisal of their efforts, we argue that while their attempts are philosophically significant—indeed, amounting to a kind of renaissance—they remain incomplete…Read more
  •  10
    Owen Ware’s latest work, Indian Philosophy and Yoga in Germany, the focus of this review, is a decent collection on how German scholars acknowledged the Indian philosophy in general and yoga, including the Bhagavad Gītā in particular. Ware’s study is more specific, focusing on 19th-century German thinkers, including Schlegel, Hegel, and Schelling, who engaged with Indian philosophy through concepts such as pantheism, nihilism, and freedom. Altogether, Ware also investigates how early-20th-centur…Read more
  •  1
    In recent years, Sri Aurobindo—a twentieth-century Indian thinker and visionary—has attracted renewed interest across diverse fields, including spirituality, nationalism, aesthetics and the philosophy of mind. Among his many contributions, it is his metaphysical and spiritual vision, particularly articulated in The Life Divine, that continues to inspire deep engagement. Building briefly on some of his other works as well, this study traces the philosophical journey from the aspirational hypothes…Read more
  •  28
    The epistemology of modality is a specialized branch of philosophy that explores how we gain knowledge and justified beliefs about modal truths--claims about what is possible, necessary, contingent, or impossible. Unlike empirical knowledge, which is based on observable facts, modal knowledge deals with abstract possibilities such as “Water must be H₂O” or “Humans could have evolved differently.” This field raises key questions about how we access modal facts that are not empirically verifiable …Read more
  •  21
    The Dialectics of an Advaitin Gandhi and the Modern World
    Journal of World Philosophies 9 (1). 2024.
    This review critically examines Sanatan Gandhi: Bapu Se Vaishwik Samvād by Ambika Dutt Sharma and Vishwanath Mishra. The review will assess the authors’ contribution to the discourse on peace, violence, and Mahatma Gandhi’s philosophy, while exploring intersections with selected modern thinkers. It highlights the book’s strengths in critiquing modernity and presenting Gandhi as a relevant guide in today’s world, including as a cultural analyst. It suggests potential challenges regarding cultural…Read more
  •  3
    Jonardon Ganeri. (2021). Inwardness: An Outsider's Guide. Columbia University Press. (pp.ix+144) (review)
    Journal of the Indian Council of Philosophical Research 43 (2): 285-292. 2026.
    What does it truly mean to turn inward, and what do we find when we do? Jonardon Ganeri’s Inwardness: An Outsider’s Guide undertakes a cosmopolitan exploration of the inner self, drawing on diverse traditions—Buddhist, Hindu, Islamic, Christian, and Western philosophical thought. This review traces the book’s guiding claim that inwardness is the “presence of yourself to yourself,” and examines the philosophical challenges it raises: Does introspection require agency? Does Pessoa’s heteronymy dee…Read more
  •  20
    For centuries, philosophical inquiry into theology and religion was confined to a narrow range of questions about a singular God, the nature of divinity, the origins of creation, and the tension between good and evil, free will and determinism. In our times, it would seem, the conversation has struggled to expand beyond these erstwhile boundaries to embrace diverse traditions, subaltern voices, and even issues that do, or arguably should, concern the proper work of the philosophy of religion. Th…Read more
  •  13
    This review article critically studies Krishna Chandra Bhattacharyya’s (KCB) Bhagavadgītā Vicāra using D. K. Mohanta’s English translation from Bengali, published by the Indian Council of Philosophical Research. The article can be considered a metareflection, as it researches into the KCB’s reflections and interpretation of the Bhagavadgītā thematically rather than chronologically. Utilizing Mohanta’s translation, the article scrutinizes the gradations of Bhattacharyya’s interpretation. It explo…Read more
  •  8
    Swami Vivekananda is often remembered as a defining figure of modern Indian thought. His Chicago address, his universalist reading of religion, and his humanistically oriented presentation of Vedānta have together shaped his global reputation and secured his place in popular culture memory. These features have also led many to regard him as a philosophical representative of Indian culture and nationalism. This paper revisits this narrative through the critical lens of Acharya P. K. Mukhopadhyay.…Read more
  •  33
    Introspecting Indianness: An Analysis of Acharya P. K. Mukhopadhyay’s Nyāya-Based Perspective on the Making of Modern India
    with Rajneesh Mishra
    Journal of the Indian Council of Philosophical Research 43 (1): 1-18. 2026.
    This review engages with Bhāratīyatā kī Ātmagaveṣaṇā: Ādhunik Bhārat kī Nirmiti par Nyāyaśāstrīya Dṛṣṭi (Introspection into Indianness: A Nyāya-based Perspective on the Making of Modern India), a dialogical work by Acharya Pradyot Kumar Mukhopadhyay and Dr. Udayan Vajpeyi. Eschewing the structure of a conventional treatise, the book unfolds as a reflective conversation on India’s civilizational and intellectual challenges. Mukhopadhyay critiques reformist and reductionist tendencies, the flatten…Read more
  •  49
    The attributes and representative spirit of a culture, era, or community, as manifested in its attitude and aspiration, hold the concept of ethos. Likewise, every civilization has its own unique ethos; however, at present, it is shared through multiple globalized dynamics such as—media, technology, and other connectivities. The communication gaps have been filled with unique mediums; people are more open to new things, and comforts have increased dramatically. Nevertheless, despite such liberal …Read more
  •  23
    In Defence of Jain Philosophy and Religion: An Experimental and Comparative Approach Towards Peaceful Culture
    Journal of the Indian Council of Philosophical Research 43 (1): 23-45. 2026.
    Indian philosophy, particularly the Vedānta tradition, has long engaged in hermeneutic and exegetical practices, especially in interpreting the prasthānatrayī texts—the Upaniṣads, Bhagavad Gītā, and Brahmasūtra—which are central to Vedāntic schools of thought. These interpretations have produced diverse readings highlighting knowledge, action, devotion, Advaitism, Dvaitism, Viśiṣṭādvaitism, and other perspectives, often marked by exclusivity and intense internal critique among the different trad…Read more
  •  53
    One of the legacies of Western philosophical thought has been its evolution through movements and slogans such as modernism, postmodernism, existentialism and analyticism. These popular intellectual standpoints have contributed to making Western culture more dialogical and progressive. However, in contrast, exploration of socio-philosophical movements within the Indian philosophical tradition, except for ancient times, remains relatively uncharted territory. Acknowledging this variance, the pres…Read more