-
70Standards of practice in empirical bioethics research: towards a consensusBMC Medical Ethics 19 (1): 68. 2018.This paper responds to the commentaries from Stacy Carter and Alan Cribb. We pick up on two main themes in our response. First, we reflect on how the process of setting standards for empirical bioethics research entails drawing boundaries around what research counts as empirical bioethics research, and we discuss whether the standards agreed in the consensus process draw these boundaries correctly. Second, we expand on the discussion in the original paper of the role and significance of the conc…Read more
-
65
-
63Use or ornament? Clinical ethics committees in infertility units: a qualitative studyClinical Ethics 4 (2): 91-97. 2009.This paper examines the role of clinical ethics committees (CECs) in infertility clinics in the UK, focusing on whether they usefully support infertility clinicians' ethical decision-making. The overall aim of the study reported here was to investigate how infertility clinicians approached and handled ethical problems in their everyday practice and this paper reports on one aspect of these data – what they thought about the use of CECs. This paper gives an overview of what arrangements there are…Read more
-
56How experience makes a difference: practitioners' views on the use of deferred consent in paediatric and neonatal emergency care trialsBMC Medical Ethics 14 (1): 45. 2013.In 2008 UK legislation was amended to enable the use of deferred consent for paediatric emergency care (EC) trials in recognition of the practical and ethical difficulties of obtaining prospective consent in an emergency situation. However, ambiguity about how to make deferred consent acceptable to parents, children and practitioners remains. In particular, little is known about practitioners’ views and experiences of seeking deferred consent in this setting
-
56Pandemic medical ethicsJournal of Medical Ethics 46 (6): 353-354. 2020.The COVID-19 pandemic will generate vexing ethical issues for the foreseeable future and many journals will be open to content that is relevant to our collective effort to meet this challenge. While the pandemic is clearly the critical issue of the moment, it’s important that other issues in medical ethics continue to be addressed as well. As can be seen in this issue, the Journal of Medical Ethics will uphold its commitment to publishing high quality papers on the full array of medical ethics. …Read more
-
55Institute of Medical Ethics Guidelines for confirmation of appointment, promotion and recognition of UK bioethics and medical ethics researchersJournal of Medical Ethics 44 (5): 289-291. 2018.This document is designed to give guidance on assessing researchers in bioethics/medical ethics. It is intended to assist members of selection, confirmation and promotion committees, who are required to assess those conducting bioethics research when they are not from a similar disciplinary background. It does not attempt to give guidance on the quality of bioethics research, as this is a matter for peer assessment. Rather it aims to give an indication of the type, scope and amount of research t…Read more
-
49General Practice and Ethics: Uncertainty and Responsibility (edited book)Routledge. 1999.Explores the ethical issues faced by GPs in their everyday practice, addressing two central themes; the uncertainty of outcomes and effectiveness in general practice and the changing pattern of general practitioners' responsibilities
-
47Symbiotic empirical ethics: A practical methodologyBioethics 26 (4): 198-206. 2012.Like any discipline, bioethics is a developing field of academic inquiry; and recent trends in scholarship have been towards more engagement with empirical research. This ‘empirical turn’ has provoked extensive debate over how such ‘descriptive’ research carried out in the social sciences contributes to the distinctively normative aspect of bioethics. This paper will address this issue by developing a practical research methodology for the inclusion of data from social science studies into ethic…Read more
-
44Conscientious objection to participation in abortion by midwives and nurses: a systematic review of reasonsBMC Medical Ethics 19 (1): 31. 2018.Freedom of conscience is a core element of human rights respected by most European countries. It allows abortion through the inclusion of a conscience clause, which permits opting out of providing such services. However, the grounds for invoking conscientious objection lack clarity. Our aim in this paper is to take a step in this direction by carrying out a systematic review of reasons by midwives and nurses for declining, on conscience grounds, to participate in abortion. We conducted a systema…Read more
-
43Life Choices: A Hastings Center Introduction to Bioethics (review)Journal of Medical Ethics 28 (2): 131-131. 2002.
-
40Lockdown, public good and equality during COVID-19Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (11): 713-714. 2020.On 22nd September 2020 the UK Government announced new lockdown restrictions to supress the COVID-19 virus, with some areas of England having more restrictive lockdown guidance. Students in a number of cities have been confined to their halls of residences after outbreaks of COVID-19 and in Manchester security guards were preventing students leaving the buildings. The scientific community are, unsurprisingly, divided over the question of how far lockdowns should extend.1 Monday 21st September 20…Read more
-
37They Can't Have My Embryo: The Ethics of Conditional Embryo DonationBioethics 27 (6): 317-324. 2013.There are substantial numbers of frozen embryos in storage that will not be used by those who produced them for their own fertility treatment. One option for such embryos is to donate them to others to use in their fertility treatment. There has been considerable debate about how this process should be organized. In the US, there are embryo adoption programmes that mediate between those relinquishing embryos and potential recipients. This is a form of conditional embryo donation, where the relin…Read more
-
34HIV testing and informed consentJournal of Medical Ethics 31 (12): 699-700. 2005.People should be allowed to decide how and where they wish to be tested for HIV without there being a formal requirement for pretest counsellingIn his paper, Ethics of HIV testing in general practice without informed consent, Fraser argues that pretest counselling and informed consent are pillars of the ethical conduct of HIV testing. In my response I want to look critically at these contentions. While I will agree with Fraser that it is always necessary to get informed consent from a patient fo…Read more
-
33Good Clinical Practice and Ethics in European Drug ResearchJournal of Medical Ethics 22 (4): 249-249. 1996.
-
30The Cambridge Medical Ethics Workbook: Case studies, Commentaries and Activities: M Parker, Donna Dickenson. Cambridge University Press, 2001, 29.95, pp 359. ISBN 0521788633 (review)Journal of Medical Ethics 29 (4). 2003.
-
30Public involvement in the governance of population-level biomedical research: unresolved questions and future directionsJournal of Medical Ethics 47 (7): 522-525. 2021.Population-level biomedical research offers new opportunities to improve population health, but also raises new challenges to traditional systems of research governance and ethical oversight. Partly in response to these challenges, various models of public involvement in research are being introduced. Yet, the ways in which public involvement should meet governance challenges are not well understood. We conducted a qualitative study with 36 experts and stakeholders using the World Café method to…Read more
-
29Why health services research needs bioethicsJournal of Medical Ethics 43 (10): 655-656. 2017.It is nearly 20 years since Tony Hope wrote an editorial in this journal on Empirical Medical Ethics,1 arguing for both a recognition of the increasing amount of work being done in ‘empirical ethics’ and for its importance as a new direction for medical ethics research. Since then empirical ethics has flourished, with debates over the role of ‘empirical’ data in ethical reasoning producing a growing body of literature and the JME and other bioethics journals regularly publishing empirical studie…Read more
-
29This paper examines a legal case arising from a workplace grievance that progressed to being heard at the UK’s Supreme Court. The case of Doogan and Wood versus Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board concerned two senior midwives in Scotland, both practicing Roman Catholics, who exercised their perceived rights in accordance with section 4 of the Abortion Act not to participate in the treatment of women undergoing abortions. The key question raised by this case was: “Is Greater Glasgow and Clyde…Read more
-
28COVID-19 and beyond: the ethical challenges of resetting health services during and after public health emergenciesJournal of Medical Ethics 46 (11): 715-716. 2020.COVID-19 continues to dominate 2020 and is likely to be a feature of our lives for some time to come. Given this, how should health systems respond ethically to the persistent challenges of responding to the ongoing impact of the pandemic? Relatedly, what ethical values should underpin the resetting of health services after the initial wave, knowing that local spikes and further waves now seem inevitable? In this editorial, we outline some of the ethical challenges confronting those running heal…Read more
-
28The NHS and market forces in healthcare: the need for organisational ethicsJournal of Medical Ethics 39 (1): 17-21. 2013.The NHS in England is an organisation undergoing substantial change. The passage of the Health and Social Care Act 2012, consolidates and builds on previous health policies and introduces further ‘market-style’ reforms of the NHS. One of the main aspects of these reforms is to encourage private and third sector providers to deliver NHS services. The rationale for this is to foster a more competitive market in healthcare to encourage greater efficiency and innovation. This changing healthcare env…Read more
-
27Clinical ethics: Process and consensus: ethical decision-making in the infertility clinic—a qualitative studyJournal of Medical Ethics 35 (11): 662-667. 2009.Infertility treatment is a speciality that has attracted considerable attention both from the public and bioethicists. The focus of this attention has mainly been on the dramatic dilemmas created by theses technologies. Relatively little is known, however, about how clinicians approach and resolve ethical issues on an everyday basis. The central aim of this study is to gain insight into these neglected aspects of practice. It was found that, for the clinicians, the process by which ethical decis…Read more
-
25The Concise ArgumentJournal of Medical Ethics 45 (4): 217-218. 2019.This issue of the Journal of Medical covers a range of ethical issues and care settings making the task of beginning to summarise these papers challenging. They reflect the diversity of our field, representing different branches of bioethics focussing on specific areas or topics using a variety of methodologies: but how do we categorise these branches of bioethics? What demarks one branch from another? And what function do such categorisations fulfil? From the early days of medical ethics we now…Read more
-
22The concise argumentJournal of Medical Ethics 46 (1): 1-2. 2020.This post-holiday edition of the JME brings together a number of papers, covering a range of methodologies, surveys on public opinion, the application of developmental neuroscience, comparative risk/benefit questionnaires, scoping reviews and analysis of guidance and health policy, alongside what might be seen as more traditional medical ethics, analysing concepts and advancing arguments. This range of methodologies is suggestive of the kind of discipline that bioethics has become, and how a wea…Read more
-
22Priority Setting and Evidence Based PurchasingHealth Care Analysis 7 (2): 139-151. 1999.The purpose of this paper is to consider the role that values play in priority setting through the use of EBP. It is important to be clear about the role of values at all levels of the decision making process. At one level, society as a whole has to make decisions about the kind of health provision that it wants. As is generally accepted, these priority setting questions cannot be answered by medical science alone but involve important judgements of value. However, as I hope to show values come …Read more
-
22Medical ethics and the climate change emergencyJournal of Medical Ethics 48 (12): 939-940. 2022.The editors of the _Journal of Medical Ethics_ support the call of the UK Health Alliance on Climate for urgent action to ensure that the current Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change ‘finally delivers climate justice for Africa and vulnerable countries’. 1 As they note ‘Africa has suffered disproportionately although it has done little to cause the crisis’. The burden of climate change has thus far fallen disproportionately on Global South countr…Read more
-
21Beneath the Rhetoric: The Role of Rights in the Practice of Non-Anonymous Gamete DonationBioethics 15 (5-6): 473-484. 2001.The use of rights based arguments to justify claims that donor offspring should have access to information identifying their gamete donor has become increasingly widespread. In this paper, I do not intend to revisit the debate about the validity of such rights. Rather, the purpose is to examine the way that such alleged rights have been implemented by those legislatures that have allowed access to identifying information. I will argue that serious inconsistencies exist between the claim that don…Read more
-
21This paper examines a legal case arising from a workplace grievance that progressed to being heard at the UK’s Supreme Court. The case of Doogan and Wood versus Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board concerned two senior midwives in Scotland, both practicing Roman Catholics, who exercised their perceived rights in accordance with section 4 of the Abortion Act not to participate in the treatment of women undergoing abortions. The key question raised by this case was: “Is Greater Glasgow and Clyde…Read more
-
21Donor Conception and Mandatory Paternity Testing: The Right to Know and the Right to Be ToldAmerican Journal of Bioethics 13 (5): 50-52. 2013.No abstract
-
20Managing Ethical Challenges to Mental Health Research in Post‐Conflict SettingsDeveloping World Bioethics 16 (1): 15-28. 2015.Recently the World Health Organization has highlighted the need to strengthen mental health systems following emergencies, including natural and manmade disasters. Mental health services need to be informed by culturally attuned evidence that is developed through research. Therefore, there is an urgent need to establish rigorous ethical research practice to underpin the evidence-base for mental health services delivered during and following emergencies.
-
19Medical ethics, equity and social justiceJournal of Medical Ethics 50 (4): 221-221. 2024.As John McMillan notes in January’s editorial, 1 many countries are reflecting on how they responded to the COVID-19 pandemic, what went wrong and how responses to such system shocks can be better managed in the future. However, while it is tempting to think that the COVID-19 pandemic is over and that what is now needed is a reflection on how countries could have responded better, some of the underlying issues and problems COVID-19 both highlighted and created are still with us. The legacy of th…Read more
Liverpool, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland