Yavuz Dağ

Istanbul Gedik University

My Survey Responses

Survey Prompt Response
A priori knowledge Accept: no
Abortion Accept: permissible
Abstract objects Accept: nominalism
Aesthetic experience Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Aesthetic experience is a form of perception
  • Accept Aesthetic experience is a form of pleasure
  • Accept Aesthetic experience is sui generis
Aesthetic value Accept: subjective
Aim of philosophy Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Truth/knowledge is an important aim of philosophy
  • Accept Understanding is an important aim of philosophy
  • Accept Wisdom is an important aim of philosophy
  • Accept Happiness is an important aim of philosophy
  • Accept Goodness/justice is an important aim of philosophy
Analysis of knowledge Accept: other analysis
Analytic-synthetic distinction Accept: no
Arguments for theism Accept a combination of answers:
  • Reject The cosmological argument is the strongest argument for theism
  • Reject The design argument is the strongest argument for theism
  • Reject The ontological argument is the strongest argument for theism
  • Reject The pragmatic argument is the strongest argument for theism
  • Reject The moral argument is the strongest argument for theism
Belief or credence Accept: neither
Capital punishment Accept: impermissible
Causation Accept: primitive
Chinese room Accept: doesn't understand
Concepts Accept: empiricism
Consciousness Other
Continuum hypothesis Accept: indeterminate
Cosmological fine-tuning Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept The multiverse explains cosmological fine-tuning
  • Accept There is no cosmological fine-tuning
Eating animals and animal products Accept: omnivorism (yes and yes)
Environmental ethics Accept: non-anthropocentric
Epistemic justification Accept: externalism
Experience machine Accept: no
Extended mind Accept: yes
External world Accept: non-skeptical realism
Footbridge Accept: don't push
Foundations of mathematics Accept: constructivism/intuitionism
Free will Accept: compatibilism
Gender Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Gender is biological
  • Accept Gender is psychological
  • Accept Gender is social
  • Reject Gender is unreal
Gender categories Accept: revise
God Accept: atheism
Grounds of intentionality Accept: causal/teleological
Hard problem of consciousness Accept: no
Human genetic engineering Accept: permissible
Hume Accept: naturalist
Immortality Accept: yes
Interlevel metaphysics Accept: supervenience
Justification Accept: reliabilism
Kant Accept: one world
Knowledge Accept: empiricism
Knowledge claims Accept: contextualism
Law Accept: legal non-positivism
Laws of nature Accept: Humean
Logic Accept: non-classical
Material composition Accept: restrictivism
Meaning of life Accept: subjective
Mental content Accept: externalism
Meta-ethics Accept: moral anti-realism
Metaontology Accept: deflationary realism
Metaphilosophy Accept: naturalism
Method in history of philosophy Accept: contextual/historicist
Method in political philosophy Accept: non-ideal theory
Mind Accept: physicalism
Mind uploading Agnostic/undecided
Moral judgment Accept: cognitivism
Moral motivation Accept: externalism
Moral principles Accept: moral particularism
Morality Accept a combination of answers:
  • Reject Non-naturalism about morality
  • Accept Naturalist realism about morality
  • Reject Constructivism about morality
  • Reject Expressivism about morality
  • Accept Error theory of morality
Newcomb's problem Accept: two boxes
Normative concepts Agnostic/undecided
Normative ethics Other
Other minds Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Adult humans are conscious
  • Accept Cats are conscious
  • Accept Fish are conscious
  • Accept Flies are conscious
  • Reject Worms are conscious
  • Reject Plants are conscious
  • Reject Particles are conscious
  • Accept Newborn babies are conscious
  • Reject Current AI systems are conscious
  • Reject Future AI systems are conscious
Ought implies can Accept: yes
Perceptual experience Accept: representationalism
Personal identity Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Biological views of personal identity
  • Accept Psychological views of personal identity
  • Accept Further-fact views of personal identity
Philosophical knowledge Accept: a lot
Philosophical methods Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Conceptual analysis is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
  • Accept conceptual engineering is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
  • Accept Empirical philosophy is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
  • Accept Experimental philosophy is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
  • Accept Formal philosophy is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
  • Accept Intuition-based philosophy is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
  • Accept Linguistic philosophy is among the most useful/important methods of philosophy
Philosophical progress Accept: a little
Plato Accept: knowledge also of concrete things
Political philosophy Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Communitarianism in political philosophy
  • Accept Egalitarianism in political philosophy
  • Reject Libertarianism in political philosophy
Politics Accept a combination of answers:
  • Lean towards Capitalism in politics
  • Lean against Socialism in politics
Possible worlds Agnostic/undecided
Practical reason Accept: Aristotelian
Principle of sufficient reason Accept: false
Proper names Accept: Millian
Properties Accept: tropes
Propositional attitudes Accept: representational
Propositions Accept: structured entities
Quantum mechanics Accept: many-worlds
Race Accept: social
Race categories Accept: revise
Rational disagreement Accept: permissivism
Response to external-world skepticism Accept: epistemic externalist
Science Accept: scientific realism
Semantic content Accept: moderate contextualism (intermediate)
Sleeping beauty Agnostic/undecided
Spacetime Accept: relationism
Statue and lump Accept: one thing
Teletransporter Accept: survival
Temporal ontology Accept: presentism
Theory of reference Accept: deflationary
Time Accept: B-theory
Time travel Accept: metaphysically impossible
Trolley problem Accept: switch
True contradictions Accept: actual
Truth Accept: deflationary
Units of selection Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Genes are the unit of natural selection
  • Accept Organisms are the unit of natural selection
Vagueness Accept: metaphysical
Values in science Accept: can be either
Well-being Accept a combination of answers:
  • Accept Hedonism or experientialism about well-being
  • Accept Desire satisfaction views of well-being
Wittgenstein Accept: late
Zombies Accept: metaphysically possible